Ways to Deal with Employee Theft

One of the most unappealing things about managing a workplace is having to deal with ugly situations. Employee theft, or, internal theft is perhaps the single worst scenario to encounter because often times, you won’t know the extent of it, at least, right away. This behavior can take shape in a number of ways, including fudging clock-in and clock-out times, taking supplies without permission, or, even stealing money. While the latter might get your heightened attention, it’s the more subtle that can go on for much longer periods and cost more in losses.

Ways to Deal with Employee Theft

Make no mistake about it, internal theft is a huge problem in the United States. However, it is difficult to gauge because so much of it goes unreported due to embarrassed or recalcitrant employers. The average estimate ranges widely from $20 to $50 billion per year, with Fortune reporting in the retail sector alone, a whopping $32 billion was lost in 2014, with an amazing 34.5 percent of that being attributed to employee theft. Only shoplifting outpaced it, accounting for 38 percent.

Whether it’s downloading and sharing company confidential information (a hot topic these days), manipulating expense reports, or stealing merchandise- employee theft and fraud is a serious issue for business owners. In fact, studies show that occupational fraud now results in the loss of five percent of an organization’s annual revenue. —U.S. Small Business Administration

While it’s an unpleasant experience to-be-sure, it nonetheless exists, and, in practically every workplace. The level, though, might be very minute, like the employee who occasionally takes a few postage stamps for personal use. When it comes to bigger issues, it’s not unusual for the owner and/or manager to be taken by surprise. After all, you do what you can to screen and interview every new hire, but sometimes, it’s not enough. The primary reason for this is a simple necessity, especially for small business owners who need to delegate responsibilities. They just don’t have the time to do it all on their own, so, they leave certain things to employees. This creates an atmosphere of opportunity where trust can be easily breached. When that happens, here are some ways to deal with employee theft:

  • Evaluate the situation. When you discover the problem, it’s best not to jump to conclusions about the scope. It could just be a case of miscommunication or simply a lack of judgment. If you believe it to be serious and particularly one that’s ongoing, you should commit to take action. If it’s minor, you might consider issuing a written warning, placing him or her on probation, or, repayment.
  • Document everything you can. If you discover supplies, inventory, materials, or money is missing, do everything you can to document what it is, when it happened, and it’s worth. You should gather as much evidence as you can to bring the situation to resolve.
  • Phone your attorney or HR Consultant immediately. Dealing with internal theft is a serious matter and you don’t want to overstep your legal bounds. While you certainly have rights, you cannot afford to act in a rash manner. Call your lawyer and ask about what options are available to you.
  • Call the local police or sheriff’s department. If your legal counsel instructs you to contact the local authorities on their non-emergency line, you should do so right away. While this won’t likely resolve the issue immediately, it will be a step in the right direction.
  • Get in touch with your insurer. Another one of the first phone calls you should make is to your insurer to learn exactly what coverage you have in-place. You might have to file a claim to recover most or a portion of your loss.

Once the initial work is done, consider how you’ll deal with preventing the same problem from occurring in the future. You should also discuss the matter with key team members and think seriously about how to present the issue and your reaction to others in your business. As a Leader, it is important that you don’t allow this to become office gossip, get out in front of it, and demonstrate your commitment to your company and how you reward good work and the consequences for theft.

Want to find out about what a business coach can do for you?

[shareaholic app=”follow_buttons” id=”26833294″]

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

Handshake illustration

Managers should Avoid these Phrases to Avoid Killing Employees’ Trust in Their Leadership

When it comes to the workplace, trust is key. Employees need to trust their managers in order to feel comfortable taking risks and be productive. Managers, in turn, need to trust their employees in order to delegate tasks and give them the freedom to make decisions. Unfortunately, many managers say things that damage this trust relationship. So, let’s discuss five of the most common phrases that managers use that kill employees’ trust. Words can Speak Louder than Actions Managers should avoid the following phrases in order to maintain a trusting relationship with their employees. Trust is essential for a healthy workplace and these phrases can damage that trust relationship. Employees need to feel comfortable coming to their managers with questions and concerns, and they need to know that their manager will be open and transparent with them. The employee-manager relationship is one of the primary components to a strong organizational structure. Employees rely on their managers for career development and guidance on how to improve their skills. One of the elements of a successful employee-manager relationship is trust. When the sense of trust is strong between an employee and manager, it adds efficiency to other elements of workplace productivity. —Houston Chronicle Small Business When managers use these phrases, it sends the opposite message. It makes employees feel unimportant and disregarded. It creates uncertainty and frustration, which leads to a lack of trust on the part of the employees. And that, of course, results in a negative impact on morale, productivity, and overall company culture — three poison pills that can cause actual, long-lasting damage. Five Phrases Managers should Avoid to Avoid Destroying Employee Trust We’ve all heard the age-old wisdom about sticks and stones breaking bones but words never inflicting harm. Of course, this philosophy is entirely contextual because we all vividly remember instances when words cut deep. While these phrases aren’t intended to insult or hurt, they nevertheless undermine your authority, respect, and relatability. So, avoid using the following phrases because they will slowly kill employee’s trust: “I’m the boss, I don’t have to explain my decisions.” This phrase is incredibly damaging to trust. Employees need to feel like they can come to their managers with questions and that their manager will be open and transparent with them. When a manager uses this phrase, it sends the message that the employee is not valued and that their opinion does not matter. It also makes the manager seem like they are hiding something. This can lead to employees feeling uncomfortable coming to their managers with questions or suggestions, which can hurt productivity and morale. “I’m too busy to deal with this right now.” This phrase often comes across as dismissive and unprofessional. It sends the message that the employee’s concerns are not a priority and that their manager is too busy to deal with them. This can make employees feel unimportant and disregarded. It can also lead to them feeling like they are not able to come to their manager with problems or concerns, which can hurt morale and productivity. “I’ll get back to you.” This phrase often comes across as ambiguous and frustrating for employees. Employees want to know what is going on and they want answers from their managers. When a manager says this phrase, it sends the message that the employee is being ignored and that their question is not important. It also creates uncertainty, which can lead to employees feeling anxious and stressed. “I’m not sure, let me check on that.” This phrase is often used as a way to avoid making a decision or taking responsibility. It sends the message that the manager is not capable of making decisions and that they are not in charge. This can make employees feel like they are not being taken seriously and that their concerns are not important. It can also lead to frustration and a lack of trust on the part of the employees. “That’s not my job.” This phrase communicates that the manager does not care about their employees or their job responsibilities. It sends the message that the employee is unimportant and that their job is irrelevant. This can lead to employees feeling unvalued and unmotivated. It can also cause them to feel like they are not able to come to their manager with questions or concerns, which can hurt morale and productivity. Which other phrases would you include in this list? Please take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your perspective! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »
Agave rock garden landscape

When the Owner Becomes the Bottleneck

How commercial landscape companies build leadership teams that scale, and create greater owner freedom Most commercial landscape companies are built on the back of one person. The owner wins the early customers. Builds the first crews from scratch. Develops the relationships. Solves whatever operational problem comes up that day. Approves the big decisions. Handles the difficult employee conversations. Steps in personally when a customer is unhappy. Finds a way to make payroll when it’s tight. Keeps the whole thing moving. In the early years, that level of involvement is often exactly what the business needs. But somewhere along the way, the same leadership style that built the company starts to hold it back. The owner becomes the person everyone waits on. Managers hold off on decisions until they get the nod. Employees learn to escalate a problem instead of just solving it. The important customer relationships all live with one person. Strategic thinking keeps losing to whatever fire is burning today. And the strange part is, the company keeps growing while the owner keeps feeling more trapped, not less. At some point, the owner stops being the company’s biggest growth engine. They become its biggest constraint. At Waters Business Consulting Group, we help commercial landscape companies make that shift from owner-dependent to leadership-led. The point isn’t to push the owner out of the business or make them less important. It’s to build a company that’s stronger than any single person, including the one who started it. The hidden cost of owner dependency Owner dependency is easy to miss because it usually just looks like dedication. The owner is deeply involved, decisions happen fast, customers know exactly who to call, and employees trust that the owner will step in and fix whatever’s broken. All of that feels like strength. But when too many decisions flow through one person, the cracks start to show in ways that aren’t always obvious at first: decisions slow down, managers never really get the chance to develop, accountability gets fuzzy, the same operational problems keep resurfacing, employees get frustrated, and scaling gets genuinely hard. The owner’s workload keeps climbing. The business carries more risk than it should, and it’s worth less than it could be. From the outside, everything can look fine. Revenue’s up, crews are busy, new contracts keep coming in. Inside, the owner is quietly carrying far more of the business than is sustainable, and the company can’t really grow past what one person can personally manage. The warning signs Almost no owner sets out to create this kind of dependency. It builds up slowly, one small moment at a time. A manager asks for help, and the owner just gives them the answer instead of coaching them to find it. A customer has a concern, and the owner jumps in and handles it personally. A decision comes up, and the team waits rather than acts. Before long, everyone’s learned that escalating is just easier than owning the solution themselves. A few signs tend to show up when this has gone too far. Every real decision runs through the owner. Managers might have titles and job descriptions, but not the actual authority or confidence to make a call on pricing, hiring, a customer escalation, an equipment purchase, or a scheduling problem. When one person has to sign off on everything, the whole organization moves at that person’s speed. Managers show up with problems instead of solutions. Strong leaders identify an issue, weigh the options, and bring a recommendation. In an owner-dependent company, managers just hand the problem over and wait for instructions. The owner solves it, the manager doesn’t grow from the experience, and the exact same type of problem lands on the owner’s desk again next month. The owner can’t actually step away. Take a real vacation, or a week at an industry conference, and does the business keep running the way it should, or do decisions just pile up until you get back? A company that can’t function without the owner constantly present might be successful, but it isn’t scalable yet. Critical knowledge only lives in one head. If the owner is the only one who really understands the key customer relationships, the history behind certain pricing decisions, what “good” actually looks like operationally, or where the company is trying to go strategically, that’s a real risk. Knowledge that never gets shared or documented becomes a wall the company eventually runs into. Growth is creating more work instead of more freedom. A healthy business should open up more options as it grows. If every new customer, crew, or service line just adds more directly to the owner’s plate, the company is expanding faster than its leadership infrastructure can support. More revenue isn’t buying more leverage. It’s just buying more responsibility. Why hiring more people doesn’t fix it When owners start feeling overwhelmed, the instinct is usually to hire: another estimator, another account manager, another supervisor. More hands on deck can genuinely help, but hiring alone doesn’t solve owner dependency. A bigger team without real structure often just creates more confusion. Employees need more than a title on a business card. They need clearly defined responsibilities, real authority to make decisions, expectations they can actually measure themselves against, timely information, honest feedback, and accountability for the results they’re responsible for. The goal was never just to add headcount. It’s to build leadership capacity, meaning the organization’s actual ability to make sound decisions, manage performance, and execute without the owner having to direct every single move. Build the org chart around clear ownership As a company grows, responsibility tends to get blurry. Sometimes two people both think they own the same issue. Sometimes everyone assumes it’s someone else’s job. Real clarity starts with a few basic questions: who owns this result, what authority do they actually have, how will success be measured, what can they decide without asking the owner first, and when should something get escalated instead. Clear ownership doesn’t mean less

Read More »

Imagine Selling Your Business…

How Would Your Life Change?

You didn’t start your business just to stay busy—you built it to create freedom, security, and options for yourself and your family. Selling your business can be life-changing, but the real question is whether you’re intentionally building toward that outcome or simply leaving it to chance.

Sign up below for a free consultative session to learn what your business could be worth today and in the future! 

Thank you for your interest in learning what your business is worth. We will be in touch shortly.