Business Education

Caught Red-Handed! Our Secret Strategy for Dealing with an Employee Poaching Talent for a Rival

When a trusted employee starts poaching talent to launch a rival business, it’s a gut punch that tests your leadership and strategy. This betrayal threatens not just your team’s cohesion but your company’s future. How do you respond decisively while protecting your business and maintaining morale?

What to Do When an Employee Is Poaching Talent to Launch a Competing Business

Every small business owner hopes to foster ambition—but not when it’s weaponized against the company. Discovering that a trusted employee is quietly recruiting your team to join their secret startup is tough. That’s a breach of loyalty, integrity, and potentially, contract. But emotional reactions won’t fix the problem. Strategic action will.

Here’s how to protect your business, your people, and your future.

Verify Before You Accuse

Rumors aren’t enough. If you’ve heard whispers or noticed unusual behavior—secret meetings, shifts in morale, sudden resignations—start documenting. Check whether company devices or accounts are being used for non-company purposes. But tread carefully.

Jumping to conclusions can backfire. You need facts, not suspicion.

Review Employment Agreements

This is the moment those dusty contracts matter. Look for clauses related to:

Non-solicitation (they can’t recruit your team)
Confidentiality (they can’t use your proprietary knowledge)
Non-compete (they can’t launch a rival business—depending on your state laws)

Even if you’re in a state where non-competes are weak, a strong non-solicitation clause gives you leverage.

Initiate a Private Conversation

Once you’re confident the behavior is real, talk to the employee directly. The goal isn’t confrontation—it’s clarity.

You can say something like: “I’ve heard concerns about side projects involving our team members. I want to understand what’s happening before making assumptions. Let’s talk openly.”

If they admit it, stay calm. This is chess, not dodgeball.

Act Swiftly, But Thoughtfully

Depending on what they disclose (or what you’ve confirmed), your options range from:

A formal warning
Legal notice
Immediate termination

If they’re still actively soliciting talent, letting them stay may do more harm than good.

Protect the Rest of Your Team

Your remaining employees may feel confused, even betrayed. Some may be tempted to follow the renegade. Communicate with the team—without creating drama.

Frame it this way: “Someone made a decision that conflicted with our values and agreements. We’ve taken steps to protect our team and mission.”

Reaffirm what your business stands for, and why your team is vital to its success.

Lock Down IP and Internal Access

Change passwords. Restrict access to sensitive files. Make sure cloud folders, CRMs, and communications tools aren’t bleeding into external channels. You’re not just protecting today—you’re preserving tomorrow.

Use It to Strengthen Your Culture

If an employee wants to leave and build something, fine. But if they feel the need to do it secretly? That’s a failure in trust—on both sides.

Ask yourself: Are you offering growth opportunities?

Is your team aligned with your long-term vision?
Do you encourage open conversations about ambition?

You don’t need to be perfect, but you do need to evolve.

Dealing with a covert talent raid isn’t just about closing ranks—it’s about opening eyes. With composure, clarity, and swift action, you can turn a breach of trust into a blueprint for resilience.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

Why Natural Disasters are So Disastrous to Businesses

September 28, 2017 No Comments

While hurricanes Harvey and Irma are gone, Hurricane Maria poses a possible threat. And, that’s a warning because in the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy, there were over 1 million insurance claims processed. The fact of the matter is, there are still businesses in Texas and Florida which are dealing with the devastation left by Hurricane Harvey and Hurricane Irma. Although time has passed, simple supplies remain scarce. This isn’t to unnecessarily frighten you, only to serve as a stark reminder natural disasters are so disastrous to businesses of all kinds. Why Natural Disasters are So Disastrous to Businesses Dealing with a business emergency doesn’t have to be an exercise done on the fly. In fact, it shouldn’t be approached without an effective plan. However, too many businesses simply are not prepared. Statistics show that 94 percent of all small businesses in the U.S. do backup their critical financial information. But, only 4 in 10 backup off-site. From natural disasters like Hurricane Sandy to common theft and hardware malfunctions, small businesses are particularly vulnerable in times of crisis. “Disasters can wipe out a small business in seconds,” said the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA). Yet small businesses are often the most unprepared for emergencies. —Forbes This one figure is a peek into why so many businesses fail in the wake of natural disasters. Nearly 40 percent of all small businesses never reopen following a natural disaster, according to the Federal Emergency Management Agency or FEMA. That’s not an insignificant figure to ignore. And, it clearly shows businesses are quite susceptible to natural disasters. How to Protect Your Business from Natural Disasters You shouldn’t have to endure more stress and worry than necessary. Your company can make it through a fire, earthquake, tornado, or hurricane. All you need is a plan and to be proactive. This way, you’re fully prepared and know precisely what to do. Here’s a few helpful suggestions for how to protect your business from natural disasters: Back up company records in the cloud. Not only should you routinely backup your company records, including your financials, on-site, but off-site, as well. There are many platforms out there and these provide an invaluable service. Focus on those which cater to business information as those will offer the best fit. Establish clear policies for employee, vendors, and customers. To keep your working relationships in good standing, you’ll need an actionable plan for team members, vendors, and customers. After all, if there’s going to be a delay in paying employees or delivering to your customers, you need a way to deal with such situations. Create a workable continuity plan to follow in the aftermath. Your continuity plan should identify key and essential operations. Basically, what your business can’t do without. You might need to cross-train employees. But, your goal is to put a workable continuity plan into place. Run drills from time to time and strive to make improvements. Even the best plan is useless if it’s never practiced. So, run drills periodically to keep everyone in practice. This will help ensure things run smoothly if the time comes. What’s your business’ plan for a natural disaster? How are you preparing your company to avoid losses? Are there any other precautions you would suggest taking? Please share your thoughts and experiences by commenting! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group. [shareaholic app=”follow_buttons” id=”26833294″]

The Secret Weapon for Small Biz: Unlock a Pool of Brilliant Summer Interns (Before Your Competitors Do)

June 5, 2025 No Comments

Forget expensive hires and chasing talent you simply can’t afford. Your small business needs a competitive edge this summer, and it’s not what you think. While your rivals are scrambling, you could be tapping into an often-overlooked goldmine: brilliant summer interns.

How to (Re)Establish Business Relationships Post Shutdown

June 3, 2020 No Comments

As you reopen your company, people you previously did business with might or might not return with you. Or, it could be the same people, but in different positions, not necessarily having the same latitude and/or resources at their disposal. These individuals, vendors or customers, will most likely continue their relationships, but it will probably be one that’s changed. So, you’ll need to re-establish said relationships and do so in a thoughtful and careful manner. Why Business Relations are Now more Important and Fragile than Ever Of course, whether or not you’re dealing with the same individuals and/or roles Will depend on a number of factors. It’s important to understand and accept the fact that you have no control over these situations. That means you’ll have to make adjustments on your end, in order to make the relationships work. Hopefully, the people you deal with will have some say of their own, but it’s best to hope for the best and plan for the worst. In the early months of 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic prompted wide-sweeping shutdowns and shelter-in-place orders across the United States. Now, as parts of the country look to start relaxing these strict measures, small business owners need to think about what’s next and how they will adapt and move forward safely and sustainably. —U.S. Chamber of Commerce As you reopen, some of the individual vendors and customers you previously worked with might not come back. Also, there’s the inevitability of personnel change among vendors you worked with prior to the shutdown. This means they’ll be some level of give and take, and you’ll need to temper your expectations from time to time until the new relationship takes form. How to (Re)Establish Business Relationships Post Shutdown Going forward, This new and strange dynamic will present its own set of challenges. But, with a bit of patience, tact, and along the way analysis, you can either establish new business relationships or re-establish old ones. Here’s how: Reach out. Obviously, this is where you’ll start. Reach out to those you had the strongest relationships before. Then, to others and go down the list to eventually get to those you only occasionally worked with prior to the shut down. Listen carefully. When you do speak to vendors and customers, make a conscious decision to actively listen. Don’t give into the urge to carry on about your business. Instead, take the time to listen carefully to them and learn about their circumstances. Communicate clearly. By the same token, be honest about your situation, exactly where you stand, and where you expect to be in the near future. In short, under promise and over deliver. Offer Meeting options. Not all clients, customers or partners will feel comfortable meeting in person so offer them options. We have asked our clients; would you prefer to do a video or ZOOM conference or have us meet you in person. Just asking shows you are sensitive to their concerns. Pay on time, every time. Also, be sure not to get too far ahead of yourself so you’re always in a position to pay on time, every time you receive an invoice. Otherwise, you’re opening yourself for trouble. Refer good vendors to others. Another thing you can do is to refer your favorite vendors (and customers) to others to show your appreciation. What other suggestions do you have? Please share your thoughts and experiences by commenting! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.