Business Education

The Hidden Costs of Retaining Bad Employees—and How Small Business Owners Can Fix It

Last week, we discussed how to deal with a backstabbing employee. But what happens when business owners don’t fire them, even though they continue to hurt their peers? Well, as you probably imagine, the results aren’t pleasant (and more than likely, horrible).

This seems self-evident, though sometimes, entrepreneurs choose to ignore the problem because everything else is all right. That’s a recipe for disaster, and can easily lead to bigger problems. So, read on to learn what’s in store.

Why Clinging to Underperforming or Toxic Employees Secretly Erodes Your Company’s Foundation

Running a small business means wearing many hats, but one of the toughest decisions is letting go of an underperforming or toxic employee. Many owners hesitate, hoping things will improve or fearing the hassle of replacement. Yet, clinging to “bad fits” can quietly erode your company’s foundation. According to research from Harvard Business School, a single toxic employee can cost a business far more than their salary—up to $12,800 in turnover alone —by driving away good talent. For small teams, this chronic drain often outweighs the short-term pain of firing.

Risks You Run

The risks are multifaceted and compounding. First, productivity plummets. A poor performer doesn’t just underdeliver; they drag everyone else down. Studies show teams with even one toxic member see 38% lower engagement and higher error rates. Good employees pick up the slack, leading to burnout and resentment.

Second, morale and culture suffer irreparably. High-performers notice when bad behavior goes unchecked—it signals that mediocrity is tolerated. Gallup data indicates disengaged workers (often spurred by toxic environments) cost the U.S. economy trillions in lost output, with small businesses feeling it acutely through voluntary quits. In fact, good hires leave at 54% higher rates around toxic colleagues.

Financially, the hit is brutal. Replacement costs for a departed star can run 1.5–2x their salary in recruiting, training, and lost knowledge. Customers notice too—sloppy work or rude service drives them away, damaging your reputation in a word-of-mouth world. Legally, ignoring issues like harassment or consistent underperformance risks lawsuits if they escalate, especially without documentation. In at-will states (most of the U.S.), you can terminate for any non-discriminatory reason, but delays invite claims of retaliation or unfairness.

Small business owners often delay for understandable reasons. For instance, “They’re nice,” “Hard to replace,” or “What if I can’t find someone better?” But as one expert notes, keeping them is a disservice to both the employee (trapped in a mismatch) and your company (stuck in mediocrity).

Rectifying the Situation for a Proactive Path Forward

The good news? You can address this decisively while minimizing fallout. Start with prevention through better hiring. Use structured interviews, skills tests, and reference checks to spot red flags early. Clear job descriptions and probation periods set expectations upfront.

When issues arise, document relentlessly. Track performance with specifics, including missed deadlines, client complaints, or policy violations. Issue verbal warnings, followed by written ones via a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP). A 30–60 day PIP outlines measurable goals, support offered, and consequences—giving a fair shot while building your case. Consult an employment attorney or an HR service early; small businesses without this support often face surprises under laws like the FMLA or anti-discrimination rules.

When Involuntary Separation Becomes a Necessity

If improvement doesn’t happen, terminate thoughtfully. Schedule a private meeting at week’s end (e.g., Friday afternoon) to allow time for processing. Have a witness (HR or trusted manager) present. Be direct by saying, “We’ve discussed these issues, and we’ve decided to end your employment effective today.” Avoid debate—focus on facts, express appreciation for past contributions, and outline next steps: final paycheck (immediate in many states), benefits continuation (COBRA notice), and property return.

Prepare a transition. Reassign duties, notify the team neutrally (“We’ve parted ways with [Name]; we’ll redistribute tasks”), and offer a neutral reference if warranted. Some provide severance (1–2 weeks’ pay) for goodwill, though not required.

Post-firing, reinforce culture. Use the moment to hire rigorously—seek A-players who align with your values. Many owners report relief and renewed energy after taking action; the “acute pain” of change beats the chronic drag.

In the end, firing isn’t failure—it’s leadership. As Inc. Magazine puts it, underperformers aren’t doing you (or themselves) a favor by staying. For small businesses, swift, fair action protects your team, customers, and bottom line. Act now, and watch your venture thrive.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, send us an email. You can also visit us at Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

How Established Businesses Can Smartly Break into Emerging Cottage Industries

September 22, 2023 No Comments

How Established Businesses Can Smartly Break into Emerging Cottage Industries The business landscape is constantly evolving, and emerging cottage industries are a testament to this incredible dynamism. These small-scale, niche markets often represent new opportunities for both startups and established businesses alike to explore. However, established businesses face unique challenges when entering emerging cottage industries. So, let’s go ahead and take a look at what to expect. Why Established Businesses Should Consider Entry Obviously, existing companies with a solid customer base would expect to grow their profits by getting into new spaces. But, there are other advantageous motivators. For instance, established businesses should consider entering a new cottage industry for several compelling reasons: Diversification. Entering an emerging cottage industry can diversify an established business’s product or service portfolio, reducing reliance on a single market. Growth potential. These industries may be in their infancy, offering significant growth opportunities for early entrants with proven business skills. Consumer trends. Many consumers prioritize local, artisanal, and sustainable products, making these markets attractive for established businesses. Plus, getting into a cottage industry can create a competitive advantage. Entering early can establish a strong foothold, making it difficult for competitors to catch up. Strategic Ways Established Businesses Can Enter New Cottage Industries Emerging cottage industries are small, niche businesses that are often based on traditional skills or crafts. They are usually started by passionate individuals who are eager to share their products and services with the world. Established businesses can see a number of benefits to breaking into emerging cottage industries. These industries can offer new opportunities for growth, innovation, and differentiation. They can also help established businesses to connect with new customers and markets. However, there are also some challenges that established businesses need to be aware of when breaking into emerging cottage industries. These industries are often highly competitive, and it can be difficult to gain a foothold. Additionally, established businesses may need to adapt their business models and strategies to succeed in these new markets. Here are some tips for established businesses on how to smartly break into emerging cottage industries: Do your research. The first step is to identify emerging cottage industries that are relevant to your business and that have the potential for growth. Once you have identified a few potential industries, research them thoroughly to understand the trends, the competition, and the customer base. Identify your niche. Once you have a good understanding of an emerging cottage industry, you need to identify your niche. What unique value proposition can you offer to customers in this market? What products or services can you provide that no one else can? Partner with existing businesses. One of the best ways to break into an emerging cottage industry is to partner with existing businesses in that industry. This can give you access to their customer base, expertise, and resources. Invest in marketing and branding. It is important to invest in marketing and branding to build awareness of your business and your products or services in the emerging cottage industry. Make sure that your marketing and branding are tailored to the specific needs and interests of your target customers. Be patient and persistent. It takes time and effort to build a successful business in any industry, but it is especially important to be patient and persistent when breaking into an emerging cottage industry. Don’t expect to see results overnight. Entering emerging cottage industries can be a rewarding venture for established businesses. With thorough research, strategic adaptation, a commitment to authenticity, and a long-term vision, these businesses can successfully navigate and thrive in these promising markets. By understanding the unique dynamics and values of cottage industries, established businesses can harness new growth opportunities and stay ahead of the curve in an ever-changing business landscape. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer. You can phone 602-435-5474 or send us an email.

Whether You Think You Can Or You Think You Can’t, You’re…Wrong?

October 24, 2024 No Comments

Henry Ford once famously said, “Whether you think you can or you think you can’t, you’re right.” But, if you just replace the last word with its antonym, does it really change the statement’s meaning? It’s not much different than the glass half-empty, glass half-full analogy. The point is that in every situation, no matter how challenging, opportunity does present itself. It’s whether you choose to act on it or not. So, let’s take a few moments to break this down and gain some insight that can be very valuable in tough circumstances. Best Tips For Maintaining A Positive Outlook When Things Go Wrong We’ve all heard the comparison: entrepreneurship is a “rollercoaster ride” of highs and lows, triumphs and setbacks. While the allure of success drives many to embark on this journey, the reality often includes unexpected hurdles and long moments of doubt. When carefully laid plans go awry and obstacles seem insurmountable, maintaining a positive outlook can be a Herculean task. Yet, optimism is the lifeblood of entrepreneurship, fueling perseverance and innovation in the face of adversity. Staying Optimistic as an Entrepreneur Let’s stay with the rollercoaster analogy—some days you’re soaring high, and other days, you feel like you’re plunging down. It’s easy to get lost in the negativity that comes with challenges. But how can you keep that sparkle of optimism alive, even when the going gets tough? Below, we’ll explore some strategies to help you maintain a bright outlook, starting with perspective. Embrace the Learning Curve Every setback can feel like a punch to the gut, but what if we saw them as opportunities for growth? When things don’t go as planned, instead of sulking, ask yourself: “What can I learn from this?” Entrepreneurs are all about problem-solving. Shift your focus from the problem to the lesson. Treat it like opening up a roadblock on a thoroughfare. The more you learn, the stronger you become. Surround Yourself with Positivity Ever heard the saying, “You are who you hang out with”? It rings true for entrepreneurs, too. Surround yourself with people who lift you up, not those who bring you down. Friends, mentors, or even fellow business owners can spark a fresh wave of optimism. When you share your struggles with like-minded folks, it provides you with a cheering squad. Positive vibes are contagious—let them fuel your spirit. Set Small, Achievable Goals Large goals look a lot like mountains on the horizon. They can be overwhelming, especially when obstacles appear. Why not break that mountain down into smaller, manageable hills? This way, every small step you take feels like a victory. Celebrate those wins, no matter how tiny they seem. Each small success can boost your confidence and help you stay optimistic about reaching your ultimate goal. Cultivate Gratitude Daily It’s easy to dwell on what’s going wrong, but spotting the good in your day can flip the script. Take a moment to jot down three things you’re grateful for every day. It could be a helpful customer, a supportive friend, or just a sunny day. This simple act can shift your mindset from scarcity to abundance. When you focus on gratitude, optimism naturally follows. Visualize Your Success Picture this: you’re standing on a stage, your business thriving, customers loving your product. How does that feel? Visualization is a powerful tool. Spend a few minutes each day imagining your success. This practice ignites motivation and fuels optimism. When you can see the finish line, it’s easier to stay positive when hurdles appear along the way. Find Inspiration Everywhere Life often has its fair share of ups and downs. Seek stories of other entrepreneurs who have faced adversity and come out shining. These tales can act as fuel for your fire. When you hear how someone turned their setbacks into comebacks, it’s the same as a light bulb flicking on in your brain. It reminds you that challenges don’t define you—they’re merely stepping stones on your path to success. Practice Self-Care Regularly Amid the hustle and bustle of entrepreneurship, it’s easy to overlook your well-being. Neglecting self-care can drain your energy and optimism. Make time for activities that recharge your spirit—be it exercise, meditation, or reading a good book. Taking care of your body and mind equips you to handle challenges with a clearer perspective. Want to Accomplish More? Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while you spend more time with your family doing all the things you started your business to do? We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test. You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer,

How to Deal with Employees Who Don’t get Along

August 13, 2020 No Comments

You may have some terrific employees who always deliver on their promises and go above and beyond expectations. They intuitively know where to pick up on certain projects and how to get the job done right. You wish that all your employees delivered the same high quality work, but you’re content that you have enough to really help make your company stand out. There’s just one problem — they don’t get along. It’s a real shame, because when teamed up, they ostensibly could do so much more. However, putting them together in the same room sets off a series of bickering and arguments and the whole thing becomes counterproductive. So, how do you deal with employees who don’t get along but are otherwise great assets to your company? Disagreement Can be a Good Thing While you’d like everyone to get along and work in harmony, you’ve got to remember that differences of opinion can be quite helpful. Call it devil’s advocate or thinking outside the box, but whatever it is, it can help you see certain things you would not otherwise consider. After all, different perspectives can help stir creativity and lean to solutions that you wouldn’t have thought of before. Managers face a sticky problem when confronted with two adults in the same office who won’t get along. The tension between the two employees affects their work as well as the work of others in close proximity to their conflict. Employees become stressed because just coming into the office feels uncomfortable. —The Balance Careers Disagreement can even lead to resolving issues that previously could not be solved. Sometimes, revisiting old problems can help people see others points of view and they become friends as a result, with a good working relationship. Of course, this magical moment doesn’t always happen, and it’s much more common than employees hold on to their differences instead of putting them aside to work together without strife. How to Deal with Employees Who Don’t get along The one thing you can’t do is ignore it and let the conflict fester. It will only worsen and that will eventually cause it to spread to other people. It could easily destroy company-wide morale. So, deal with it right away, by doing the following: Meet one-on-one. This is a great way to learn about the conflict from each person’s perspective. It will also give you a sense of where each individual is coming from. Plus, it will help you identify the real source of the problem. Meet together. After you have a better understanding of what’s going on, then you can meet together. Then, take the time to go over what each said to you separately and ask if what you recapped is a fair assessment. If so, you can work out one or more solutions. Follow-up regularly thereafter. Of course, you can’t just assume that will fix the situation for good. You’ll need to follow-up with both parties and do so routinely (at least for the foreseeable future). Be prepared to take additional action. It’s quite possible you’ll need to take more action. (It could even result in dismissing one or both of them. Or, some form of discipline, if necessary.) Should you need to devote more time, then it is definitely worth asking yourself if it’s worthwhile or descending into an unnecessary distraction. What other suggestions do you have for dealing with employees who don’t get along? Please take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences by commenting and giving others something to consider. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.