Is it Gutless or Genius to Hire Replacements Before Firing?

Any entrepreneur struggling with this situation surely cringes at the thought of sacking a team member, even if that employee is messing up everything they touch. It’s a tough decision, but the business must come first, or it could suffer irreparable damage. So, the question becomes, is it smart to hire a replacement and then separate the underperformer, or would it be better to offload the problem and then bring in someone competent to fill the gap? Well, it’s not easy to answer and arguably even more difficult to execute.

Should I Subtly Bring in a Replacement Before Firing a Bad Employee?

Small-business owners hate this question because the answer feels sleazy. You’ve got an underperformer draining payroll, killing morale, and costing you customers. Do you quietly line up their replacement first, or do you fire them cold and pray the role doesn’t sit empty for weeks?

Yes, it’s okay. In fact, for most small businesses, it’s the responsible move.

What You Should Know about Hiring Before Firing

Forty-nine states have “at-will” employment. That means you can terminate someone for any non-illegal reason without notice. Nothing in federal law forbids interviewing or even hiring their replacement while they’re still on the clock. Courts have repeatedly upheld the practice. The only real legal traps are (1) retaliation claims if the employee recently complained about discrimination, wages, or safety, or (2) breaching an actual employment contract that requires notice. For 95 % of small-business employees, neither applies.

How to Hire Before You Fire

The practical case is even stronger. When you fire first and hunt later, you lose institutional knowledge, customer relationships, and revenue—sometimes for months. One missed payroll cycle or a single missed deadline can sink a five-person shop. Hiring discreetly lets you keep the lights on and the workflow running. The new person starts the Monday after the old one leaves. Zero gap, zero drama for customers.

But here’s where owners screw it up and turn a smart move into a lawsuit magnet.

  • Don’t let the current employee catch wind. That means no sloppy reference checks using company email, no “we’re growing the team” hints in staff meetings, and definitely no onboarding the new hire in the same office while the old one is still punching in. Use personal phones, conduct off-site interviews, and use a simple NDA if the role involves handling sensitive data.
  • Document everything before you even start the search. Performance notes, customer complaints, missed deadlines—keep them factual and dated. That paperwork is your best friend if the fired employee claims they were “ambushed.”
  • And be humane on the way out. Give a clean severance if you can afford it, offer a neutral reference, and let them keep their laptop for the afternoon to clear personal files. Treating people with basic dignity costs almost nothing and slashes the odds they’ll badmouth you on Glassdoor or sue just to feel heard.
The real alternative—waiting until you have a signed offer letter—is what actually destroys small businesses. You limp along with dead weight for six weeks while you “search,” productivity tanks, good employees quit, and you end up paying two salaries for the overlap anyway.

All of this means that hiring the replacement first isn’t backstabbing. It’s running a business. Your job is to protect the company, the customers, and the other employees who actually show up and deliver. Pretending otherwise is just expensive virtue-signaling.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

Less Texting More Face Time Equals More Success in Business

No, I am not talking about the Facetime application … I am talking real, live one-on-one face time! Texting has become as normal a standard in our world as eating and sleeping, and in some cases it has become more important to some people than eating or sleeping! With texting, the level of trust is low. Texting does not allow for relationship building and real relationship building is required to develop trust. Texting only provides tentative, at best, minimal trust. It’s important to understand that low trust does not translate to success in business! Why Personal Contact Always Beats Out Texting in Business Ok, I am as guilty as anyone using text to communicate. Texting is an efficient and immediate form of communication that allows the sender and recipient to respond on their own terms. It’s very convenient. The benefits of texting are numerous, but the problems that texting develop or cause are now beginning to surface as we track data; auto accidents, pedestrian accidents, sleeplessness, lack of productivity, poor communication skills … and now less success in business due to limited and poor planning! Texting has its place, but not while walking, driving, during meetings, or especially at the dinner table. You want to improve your relationships with family, friends, and business associates, along with clients/customers? Call them, meet them for coffee or lunch, and build a relationship with eye-to-eye contact instead of sending texts. We never talk any more: The problem with text messaging – From CNN Tech Web site By Jeffrey Kluger As texting use rises, the phone call is becoming a dying institution American age 18-29 send an average of nearly 88 text messages a day Psychologists worry social skills in young texters won’t develop Habitual texters may hurt relationships, miss out on new ones Because texting is convenient and can be done almost anywhere, it tends to substitute proper planning in advance for last minute texting to coordinate meetings, directions, critical information, etc. Recently, it hit me why last minute texting is a pet peeve of mine. Why? It minimizes our need to plan because we expect immediate responses. So why plan in advance when you can text at the last minute? Is it not more convenient? Does this rationalization sound familiar? Let me provide a real-world example. When texting or cell phones didn’t exist, we all had to plan out our days, our travel, our meetings … our whole day-to-day life. It required goal setting and developing a plan because there was no cell or text to connect at the last minutes. We had to pre-plan even if the plan was just meeting someone for lunch, or meeting someone at an event. Today, I hear many people say, “We’ll figure it out; I’ll text you.” Real success occurs when you plan in advance by writing down your goals and when you have a plan to achieve those goals. Or in the case of meeting or connecting with someone, you plan in advance so that you minimize the use of text while driving to the meeting! Achieving Your Goals Statistics show more than 70 percent of people never have goals. And, only 28 percent say they have some kind of goals, with just a meager 2 percent having written goals. Moreover, it’s estimated that this 2 percent controls over 90 percent of all income. Goals require planning. This includes planning your weekly business calendar of priorities which are part of your strategy to achieve you goals. So, if you have a plan, you can easily set a meeting and location based on your schedule. If you have no plan, and your plan is to “figure it out and text” at the last minute, then your potential for success diminishes greatly. Align your plan with your goals, by scheduling your plan in a calendar. Instead of texting for directions or meeting locations or times at the last minute, usually while driving and walking, pre-plan your meeting in advance and call or e-mail the information. Then use the time while driving to clear your mind and prepare for your meeting. That will produce far more effective and successful meetings than texting at the last minute. “By failing to prepare, you are preparing to fail.” –Benjamin Franklin Try this for 2 weeks Take 1 hour to plan your week by pre-scheduling all the priorities you need to accomplish in your plan for achieving your goals for the next two weeks. Put each priority in your schedule under a block of time. Allow time for travel, meals, errands, family, work outs, etc. (This takes thinking in advance, but by pre-planning, you will address any logistical challenges in preparing your plan and be able to adjust prior to your meeting or event.) Call and use your voice to communicate your plans with those you are meeting. When you get to the meeting or event, avoid texting and focus on eye contact and listening to your client, customer, vendor, or associate. In doing so, you will have less stress, higher productivity and greater success … with less aggravating, last minute, in between traffic lights and phone call texts … I guarantee it! So, put down your mobile device and start planning for Less texting and more real face time that will help you succeed in business!

Read More »

Business Owners, it’s Time to Stop using Covid as an Excuse

Covid isn’t over. In fact, the virus is probably here to stay for a long, long time, perhaps forever as endemic. But, the worst is likely well behind us. However, some small business owners are using the pandemic as an excuse and customers aren’t buying it. This is because consumers are well aware of what’s really going on and do not take kindly to such unbelievable explanations. So, it’s time for small business owners to stop using Covid as an excuse. Now, let’s take a look at why it’s so damaging. Excuses are Bad for Business Small business owners have a lot on their plate. They are responsible for wearing many hats and often have to do everything themselves. This can lead to some owners making excuses to their customers when things don’t go as planned. While it may be tempting to do this, it’s important to remember that there are many consequences for doing so. This is because there are compelling reasons why small business owners should never make excuses to their customers. Business experts wince at pandemic excuses because, well, they’re excuses, which are not the bailiwick of successful entrepreneurs—who are, by definition, problem solvers. Although tossing off a Covid excuse may seem benign, it creates a messaging problem because it’s likely deceitful: Customers are now savvy to the fact that supply chain, safety, and staffing challenges are well-established market conditions—not sudden pandemic blows. —Bloomberg Business Remember, customers will accept difficulties for what they are. They understand some situations are simply beyond a small business’ control. But, when others in the industry are moving forward, meeting their customers’ needs, it becomes dangerous for entrepreneurs to make excuses. Why Small Business Owners Shouldn’t make Excuses to their Customers Covid has become the proverbial “dog ate the homework” excuse. Sure, it is possible, but it’s also growingly becoming improbable. In other words, sure, the pandemic and shutdown may have lingering effects. But, to apply it capriciously is just a bad business practice. Some of the reasons why small business owners should never make excuses to their customers include: It harms credibility. When a small business owner makes an excuse to a customer, they are essentially saying that they are not capable of handling the situation. This can cause the customer to lose faith in the small business and may never use their services again. Businesses can suffer a bad name. If a small business is known for making excuses to their customers, it will not be long before word gets out. Customers will start to avoid doing business with them because they know that they will not be able to count on them to deliver what they promise. It makes owners appear ineffective. When a small business owner makes excuses to their customers, it makes them look like they are not in control of their business. This can lead to the customer questioning the owner’s ability to run their business and may cause them to take their business elsewhere. Customers may never return. If a small business owner regularly makes excuses to their customers, it is only a matter of time before they start losing them. Once a customer has had enough of being lied to, they will take their business to competitors who deliver and may never come back. As you can see, there are many reasons why small business owners should never make excuses to their customers. While it may be tempting to do so in the moment, it is important to remember that the consequences can be very severe. If you are a small business owner, do your best to always be honest with your customers and never make excuses for your mistakes. Your business will be better off in the long run. Do you have any tips for small business owners on how to avoid making excuses to their customers? Please, take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your input! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »

The Samsung Galaxy Fold Demonstrates this Powerful Business Lesson

The mobile technology world experienced one of the biggest public blunders of all time. Samsung shipped a number of demo units of its $2,000 foldable smartphone to several high-profile reviewers. Within 48 hours, a good number of the devices were broken. The reviewers shared their surprise and since, Samsung has delayed the release of its “Foldable Phone of the Future.” The Samsung Galaxy Fold Unfolds Unnecessary Bad Publicity To be fair, some broken due to reviewer mishandling. They mistook a part of the screen as a protective layer that all smartphones ship with. Others noticed bulges in corners near the fold. While the former did inadvertently damage the devices, the latter simply watched as the units failed. You’re anxious to get your business off the ground or get your latest product out to the public as quickly as possible. Perhaps you’ve already started your marketing and promotional campaigns. You’ve got visions of a best-selling product dancing in your head. But selling too quickly can be dangerous; there can be drawbacks if you are putting the cart before the proverbial horse. Businesses that start selling new or innovative products without taking the time to put their ducks in a row often regret their decision. —All Business It’s yet another example of a manufacturer rushing a product to market before it’s truly ready. When such bad PR situations occur, these can lead to companies going out of business outright. The Negative Effects of Rushing a Product to Market Companies rush products to market. It does happen. And, it’s a huge and completely unnecessary risk. Here’s why: Damage to reputation. Let’s begin with the obvious. While mega corporations can weather such storms, small businesses might suffer tarnishes to large to overcome. It sends the wrong message. Thomas Edison practically invented “vapor-ware,” the introduction of a product which doesn’t actually exist. When you release something prematurely, you’re sending a message you care more about turning a profit than your customers. It causes a loss of trust. If the gamble fails to payoff, it means you’ve sacrificed trust. Consumers just won’t trust your brand in the future and that’s never a good thing. Your team will also suffer. Pushing out a product before it’s ready just might lead to a loss of key employees. Some could walk away, not wanting an association with a company who isn’t willing to wait until it’s right. You’ll regret the decision. Of course, as the leader of the organization, it’s you who takes all the blame. Ultimately, you’ll have to accept making a bad decision and the consequences which inevitably follow thereafter. What other negative consequences does rushing a product to market have? Please share your thoughts and experiences by commenting! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »

Imagine Selling Your Business…

How Would Your Life Change?

You didn’t start your business just to stay busy—you built it to create freedom, security, and options for yourself and your family. Selling your business can be life-changing, but the real question is whether you’re intentionally building toward that outcome or simply leaving it to chance.

Sign up below for a free consultative session to learn what your business could be worth today and in the future! 

Thank you for your interest in learning what your business is worth. We will be in touch shortly.