Business Education

You Promoted Your Star Employee. Now They’re Struggling. Don’t Panic—Read This

Almost nothing can cut an entrepreneur deeper than misjudging the aptitude of a long-time employee. It’s an almost unbelievable and unbearable situation: giving a strong team member a shot at management only to learn the individual isn’t up to performing on the next level. Such a circumstance surely prompts a business owner to question their own instincts. Aside from the shock is what to do to resolve the problem.

Navigating the Promotion Pitfall: What Small Business Owners Can Do When a Star Employee Struggles in a New Role

Promoting a top-performing employee is one of the most rewarding decisions a small business owner can make. It recognizes hard work, boosts morale, and fills key positions internally. However, what happens when that promotion doesn’t pan out?

The employee, once a standout in their previous role, now falters under the demands of greater responsibility—a classic case of the Peter Principle in action. For small businesses, where every team member counts, this scenario can disrupt operations and strain relationships. The good news? There are proactive, compassionate strategies to address it without losing valuable talent.

1. Assess the Situation Objectively

Before taking action, step back and assess the situation. Is the issue skill-based (e.g., lacking managerial experience) or something else, like burnout or mismatched expectations? Schedule a candid, private conversation with the employee to discuss their challenges. Utilize tools such as performance reviews or 360-degree feedback from peers to gather valuable insights. In a small business, this personal touch can reveal if the promotion was premature or if external factors are at play. Remember, admitting a misstep early prevents bigger problems down the line.

2. Invest in Training and Support

Often, the employee just needs a bridge to success. Offer targeted training, such as leadership workshops, online courses, or mentorship from you or an external coach. Pair them with a seasoned colleague for shadowing, or implement a performance improvement plan (PIP) with clear, measurable goals and timelines—say, 30-60 days. This approach shows commitment to their growth and can turn things around. For cash-strapped small businesses, free resources like SCORE mentoring or LinkedIn Learning can be game-changers.

3. Consider a Graceful Demotion or Lateral Move

If training doesn’t yield results, demotion might be necessary, but frame it as a “role realignment” to preserve dignity. Explain how returning to their strengths benefits the company and them—perhaps with a title like “senior specialist” to maintain status. Alternatively, explore lateral moves to roles that leverage their skills without the added pressure. In small teams, this flexibility can help maintain high morale and retain institutional knowledge. Always document discussions to protect against potential legal issues, and consider offering incentives, such as a bonus, to ease the transition.

4. Foster a Culture of Open Communication and Learning

Prevent future pitfalls by building a promotion process that includes trial periods or assessments. Encourage employees to voice concerns about readiness for advancement. As a small business owner, lead by example: Share stories of your own career hiccups to normalize setbacks. This creates a resilient team where promotions are seen as opportunities, not traps.

Ultimately, handling a failed promotion thoughtfully can ultimately strengthen your business. It demonstrates empathy, fairness, and strategic thinking—qualities that attract and retain top talent. By viewing it as a learning experience, you’ll not only salvage a great employee but also refine your leadership for long-term success.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

Thinking of Hiring a Family Member for Your Small Business? Here’s Why You Should Think Twice

August 25, 2023 No Comments

Bringing family members into your small business might seem like an appealing idea, often driven by the desire to strengthen family bonds and keep the business within the family circle. It very much seems a win-win situation. At least, on first thought. However, this decision merits careful consideration. While there are undeniable advantages to hiring family, there are also potential pitfalls that can impact both personal relationships and business success. So, read on to explore the pros and cons of hiring family members in your small business. Pros of Hiring Family in Your Small Business There is certainly no question that hiring one or more family members comes with a few enticing benefits. (You can probably think of a few right off the bat.) Here are some of the biggest advantages to bring a family member on board your small business: Shared values and loyalty. Family members usually share your values and vision for the business, resulting in loyalty and dedication. Family members are more likely to be invested in the success of your business than non-family members. They’ll be more likely to work hard and go the extra mile to help the business succeed. Trust and reliability. Family bonds often translate into greater trust and reliability, reducing concerns about employee dishonesty. Plus, you know their strengths and weaknesses, their work ethic, and their commitment to the family. This can make it easier to trust them with important tasks and responsibilities. Flexible work dynamics. Family members might be more willing to work unconventional hours or take on varied responsibilities, contributing to the business’s flexibility. Additionally, hiring a family member can save you money on labor costs. You won’t have to pay them as much as you would a non-family member, and you may be able to arrange a more novel pay structure or compensation package. Another benefit is their personal knowledge of family dynamics. Family employees often understand the nuances of family dynamics, which can be quite advantageous in managing the business together. Cons of Hiring Family in Your Small Business Obviously, as with anything else, working with one or more family members can cause a few headaches. While the good can easily outweigh the bad, there are some things you should think long and hard about before hiring family to work in your small business: Blurred boundaries. Lines between work and family life can blur, leading to conflicts and stress that spill over into both realms. Working with family members can create conflict, especially if there are personality clashes or disagreements about how the business should be run. This can damage your personal relationships and make it difficult to work together effectively. Lack of objectivity. Family dynamics can hinder unbiased decision-making, potentially leading to poor business choices. When you’re working with family members, it can be difficult to be objective. You may be more likely to give them preferential treatment, even if they’re not the best person for the job. Creating unfair perceptions. Non-family employees might perceive favoritism or unequal treatment, affecting team morale. What’s more, it could involve limited skill diversity. Relying solely on family for expertise might limit the diversity of skills in the business. The decision to hire family members in your small business requires careful consideration of both the benefits and challenges. While shared values, loyalty, and trust can be advantageous, the potential for blurred boundaries, lack of objectivity, and conflicts should not be underestimated. Navigating this dynamic successfully requires a balance of clear communication, well-defined roles, and professionalism. Before extending a job offer to a family member, weigh the pros and cons, assess the potential impact on both your business and personal relationships, and establish strategies to manage challenges that might arise. By doing so, you can make an informed decision that serves the best interests of both your small business and your family ties. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Trump Clinton Obama Spying Teach a Great Business Lesson

June 7, 2017 No Comments

If you follow the latest news, you no doubt know there’s a lot of allegations about spying. And, you’ve definitely heard the word “collusion” all-too-many times. It’s post-election politicking at its worst (or best, depending on your perspective). Anonymous sources are spilling the proverbial beans day in and day out. Regardless of your take, all of this does teach a solid business lesson, you just have to look past the ugliness. That lesson is how to protect company secrets, particularly when employees depart. How to Protect Company Secrets after Employees Leave One of the best measures is to get to know all your team members so you can keep them happy. You might learn it’s time to transform your company’s culture or take other steps to improve the environment. The more involved you are with your employees, the better able you are to deal with problems before they arise or before they become overwhelming. This way, if you have a new hire who is willing to share information about a previous employer, you’ll know that’s a possibility when he or she leaves. Ever wonder why generic forms of cola never seem to taste quite like the taste made famous by Coca-Cola brand? Or why nothing quite measures up to the “special sauce” in a McDonald’s Big Mac? It’s not for lack of effort by way of competitors, but instead, a careful product of some of the best-kept industry secrets. While many industries basically work to reproduce the same type of product in different forms, what helps a company distinguish itself from its competitors, gain notoriety, and keep a competitive edge is the little known inner workings that make their products or services stand out from the pack. —Business.com It’s also a great idea to get to know your team members because then you can learn about them as individuals. This is a wonderful way to know what rewards are most appreciated. And, content employees are typically more loyal. On the other hand, employees who are kept at arm’s length tend to be more disgruntled. According to a Ponemon Institute study, 61 percent of unhappy team members steal company information. But there are other steps you can take to protect company secrets, even after employees leave your organization: Set expectations. “It’s better to be safe than sorry,” the old adage warns. And, this is true when it comes to keeping company secrets. You have to ask yourself about what’s most valuable to your business and that’s what needs top priority protection. This starts by setting expectations and keeping employees informed about company confidentiality policies. If necessary, have employees sign non-disclosures so they are less tempted to share secrets. Utilize technology. In today’s modern technological environment, there are plenty of tools at your disposal. Use them to your advantage so there’s less access or blocked access where it’s appropriate. For instance, if you are developing a new tool, salespeople should not have access to the plans but designers should. Put technology to work where needed and that will help to minimize potential risk. Monitor employees. You can also use technology beyond controlling access. Monitoring employees can be a treasure trove and provide much appreciated relief. For example, if a team member is about to leave and is actively interviewing with other companies, monitoring their digital activity might be worthwhile. Cut off access quickly. Although it’s not pleasant to think about, when an employee departs, unless it’s on truly amicable terms, there’s a risk something that could go with them, carried right out the door. So, be sure to terminate access right away to remain safe. How do you keep trade secrets? What steps do you take to protect company secrets? Please share your thoughts and experiences by leaving a comment! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group. [shareaholic app=”follow_buttons” id=”26833294″]

Smartest Ways to Refresh Your Business Brand for the New Year

November 28, 2024 No Comments

The start of a new year brings a sense of renewal and opportunity—a perfect time to breathe fresh life into your business brand. Whether you’re looking to attract new customers, better connect with your audience, or outshine competitors, a brand refresh can be the key to staying relevant and impactful in an ever-changing market.