Former Employee becomes a Rival Without a Non-Compete Agreement — What Should I Do

Here’s an unusual but not unheard of situation. A team member leaves your company only to go off and form a rival business. Making matters worse, there’s no non-compete agreement in place. Perhaps you never considered one, or thought it unnecessary. Whatever the case, your former employee is now a direct competitor — so, what should you do?

Legal Action might Not be the Best Action

The reflexive answer might be to sue. However, this will be very costly and challenging. Without an explicit non-compete agreement, you’ll have to prove with documented evidence that he or she used proprietary methods, and/or work product, and/or more, in order to start his or her business and poach customers. In other words, it will be a very expensive and uphill proposition that doesn’t have more than a 50/50 chance of succeeding.

When the employer faces a worker that engages in certain activities, he or she may need to sue the person for the actions that lead to the individual becoming a competitor. Many of these circumstances involve the employee acting in direct violation of company policy or the state or federal laws by stealing information from the company or poaching clients. —HG.org

That means you’ll have to find another way to deal with the situation. Since you’re probably not going to persuade him or her to give up their newfound success, or come back to work for you, what alternatives are there? Well, it really depends on your relationship as it stands now.

How to Deal with an Ex-Employee Who is Now a Competitor

When a former employee becomes a competitor, it can stir up a number of emotions. You might feel proud, if this was the plan all along. But, if it came out of the blue, chances are excellent that you will feel angry and even cheated. Fortunately, there are ways to deal with an ex-employee who becomes a business rival:

  • Talk about establishing some mutual boundaries. Although there was no arrangement in-place prior to his or her departure, that doesn’t mean that you can’t come to some agreement now. Speak with him or her about establishing some ground rules. Perhaps, you both can offer different variations of what is essentially the same within the industry. For instance, you take on one type of client, why he or she takes on another. Or, you agree not to cross certain geographic boundaries.
  • Form a strategic alliance. Here’s another idea — work together, yet separately. If the above suggestion isn’t feasible, then there’s no reason you can’t work together, behind-the-scenes. For example, you might be able to serve clients in one capacity, while he or she serves them in another. Yet another alternative is to work in tandem, where you pick up where he or she isn’t available, and vice-versa.
  • Shift your focus. This just might give you the opportunity you’ve been waiting for, for some time. You can look at it as a blessing in disguise to transition from one business model to another. Perhaps you’ve wanted to take the company in a different direction, but have been unable to fill the void. Now, there’s someone to do just that, freeing you to pursue new things.

What other suggestions do you have to deal with such a situation? Please take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your prospective!

Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

How Small Businesses can Make the Best Use of Local Partnerships

Small businesses often find it difficult to compete with larger businesses, not just in terms of scale and resources, but also in terms of visibility. However, by partnering with local businesses, small businesses can create an ecosystem where they can mutually benefit from each other’s strengths. In this article, we will explore four ways that small businesses can make the best use of local partnerships to improve their business. After all, this is one of the best and most powerful growth strategies available, and better still, it’s often just a matter of making the right arrangements. How Small Businesses can Make the Best Use of Local Partnerships The first way that small businesses can make the best use of local partnerships is by optimizing customers’ experience. Local partnerships give small businesses an opportunity to provide their customers with a more personalized and customized experience. By partnering with other local businesses, small businesses can offer their customers a one-stop-shop solution that meets all their needs. One of a small business owner’s most strategic, and potentially profitable relationships, is the one he establishes with fellow business owners. When business owners offer complementary services, they can form partnerships to help them reach new customers and expand the products and services they offer. These local partnerships help businesses increase their visibility and build customer loyalty. —Houston Chronicle Small Business Another way that small businesses can benefit from partnering with other local businesses is by using local partnerships to experiment with variations. Small businesses often lack the resources to experiment with different product offerings or marketing strategies. However, by partnering with other local businesses, they can test out different variations without incurring too much risk. Third, small businesses can create complementary offerings through local partnerships. For example, a coffee shop can partner with a local bakery to offer customers a discount when they purchase both coffee and pastries. This principle can also apply to a number of other businesses. So, co-existing industry peers, like in real estate, such as a title company and a mortgage broker, or a residential sales broker and an interior decorator can do the same. By partnering with other businesses, small businesses can offer their customers a more complete package that meets all their needs. Finally, small businesses can give and receive customer referrals through local partnerships. By partnering with other businesses in the same industry, small businesses can tap into each other’s customer base and generate more leads. In addition, by giving referrals, small businesses can build trust and credibility with their partners, which can lead to more business opportunities in the future. Local partnerships are a great way for small businesses to improve their business. By optimizing customers’ experience, experimenting with variations, creating complementary offerings, and giving and receiving customer referrals, small businesses can make the best use of local partnerships to improve their business. What other benefits do local partnerships offer? Please take a few minutes to share your own thoughts and experiences so others get the most out of these relationships. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »

Considering Setting Up an Employee Profit-Sharing Plan? Here’s What You Need to Know

When it comes to small businesses, one of the biggest challenges is finding ways to keep employees happy and motivated. This, especially in challenging times such as these, when there’s a labor shortage and even qualified individuals aren’t seeking new opportunities or becoming statistics of the Great Resignation. What’s more, it can be tough to compete with larger businesses when it comes to salary and benefits. One way that small businesses can attract and retain top talent is by setting up an employee profit-sharing plan. In this blog post, we will discuss the pros and cons of employee profit-sharing plans and why they are so beneficial for small businesses. Biggest Concerns Small Business Usually Have about Employee Profit-Sharing Plans There are a few drawbacks to setting up an employee profit-sharing plan as well. Obviously, the biggest concern is the expense. There can be some costs associated with setting up and maintaining a profit-sharing plan. Doing so can be complex. Profit-sharing plans are generally nuanced, and it is important to make sure that they are set up correctly. Otherwise, it could create problems down the road. Moreover, these programs usually include tiers, making them even more difficult to establish in the beginning. A profit-sharing plan, also referred to as a deferred profit-sharing plan, gives employees a share in the profits of the company based on the company’s earnings. Employee profit-sharing plans have distinct advantages, which contribute to a small business’s overall morale and bottom line. —Houston Chronicle Small Business Employee trust is yet another common issue. Employees need to trust that the company is doing well and that their hard work is actually contributing to the company’s success. If there is a lack of trust, employees may be less likely to participate in the profit-sharing plan. In other words, at least some plans require employees to give up part of their immediate compensation (or future earnings). Pros of Employee Profit-Sharing Plans However, though downsides do exist, there are several benefits to setting up an employee profit-sharing plan. Some of the biggest benefits that create win-win situations for employees and businesses alike include: Increased morale and motivation. When employees see that they are benefiting from the company’s success, they will be more motivated to work harder and be a part of the company’s success. Increased productivity. When employees are motivated and feel appreciated, they will be more productive in their work. This boosts overall output and contributes to a healthier bottom line, which likewise contributes to the profit-sharing model. Attracts and retains top talent. Employees want to know that they are valued and that their hard work is being duly rewarded by making the company financially stronger. A profit-sharing plan shows employees that you care about them and want to reward them for their hard work. Overall, setting up an employee profit-sharing plan can be a great way to attract and retain top talent at your small business. While there are some drawbacks, the pros far outweigh the cons. If you are considering setting up a profit-sharing plan, be sure to consult with an accountant or financial advisor to make sure you are doing it correctly. My firm has helped many of our Clients set up profit-share plans that have been very effective in providing incentives for those employees who qualify and contribute to the success of the business profitability. What other advantages and disadvantages would you include? Please share your own thoughts and experiences so others can make a more informed decision. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »

I Found Out an Employee has been Doing Something Unethical but Not Illegal – Now What?

First, this has to stop right away. And second, it has to stop because you definitely don’t want this type of practice to be representative of your business – even if it is somehow benefiting your customers. (For example, cheating a manufacturer’s rebate.) Even if it’s small, the very fact that your employee has to do something that isn’t ethical makes it wrong. You already know this, which is precisely why it bothers you in the first place. Regardless, it can be very tempting to let certain instances slide. But, you must think about the possible consequences and repercussions should this go bad. So, let’s get into a few suggestions for what to do when you discover an employee is doing something unethical but no illegal. Ethics and the Law There’s no question that just because an act isn’t ethical doesn’t mean it’s necessarily illegal. After all, the law doesn’t deal strictly with morality. (Although a lot of laws are indeed based on standards of decent behavior.) Notwithstanding, you instinctively know when a practice isn’t ethical and just because there isn’t a direct on-point law, that doesn’t mean it’s all right. The experts in leadership and management at Michigan State University emphasize that it’s important to consider who is involved with the situation when dealing with unethical behavior in the workplace. Is it just one person involved or are there several people connected to act? —Houston Chronicle Business Management However, there could be illegality. What might seem to be mostly harmless could be against the law. Obviously, this is exactly what you should know. Take the time to research the subject and find out if there are legal issues – be they criminal, civil, or possibly, both. How to Deal with Unethical Employee Behavior If you learn that what’s going on isn’t illegal but is still unethical, you have some options. Unfortunately, none of them are particularly pleasant. But, your business’ integrity could well be at stake. Here are a few ways to deal with unethical employee behavior: Arm yourself with facts. Before you act on the issue, be sure to have all the facts at your disposal. If necessary, write them down to become familiar. You’ll undoubtedly have to confront this employee and he or she will probably have at least a few justifications and/or excuses. So, be ready to counter and push back with the facts. Talk with your employee. Speak with your employee and your HR leader. If your company doesn’t have such a department, just speak with him or her one-on-one. Be polite but firm. And, listen to what he or she has to say. They’re likely justifying their actions and it might be something that’s easily fixed. Establish a new company policy. You may have to establish an entirely new company policy. Or, make adjustments to an existing one. Regardless, be sure that every single employee knows so this doesn’t continue. What other suggestions do you have for dealing with this type of situation? Please share your thoughts and experiences so that others can benefit from your input! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »

Imagine Selling Your Business…

How Would Your Life Change?

You didn’t start your business just to stay busy—you built it to create freedom, security, and options for yourself and your family. Selling your business can be life-changing, but the real question is whether you’re intentionally building toward that outcome or simply leaving it to chance.

Sign up below for a free consultative session to learn what your business could be worth today and in the future! 

Thank you for your interest in learning what your business is worth. We will be in touch shortly.