Former Employee becomes a Rival Without a Non-Compete Agreement — What Should I Do

Here’s an unusual but not unheard of situation. A team member leaves your company only to go off and form a rival business. Making matters worse, there’s no non-compete agreement in place. Perhaps you never considered one, or thought it unnecessary. Whatever the case, your former employee is now a direct competitor — so, what should you do?

Legal Action might Not be the Best Action

The reflexive answer might be to sue. However, this will be very costly and challenging. Without an explicit non-compete agreement, you’ll have to prove with documented evidence that he or she used proprietary methods, and/or work product, and/or more, in order to start his or her business and poach customers. In other words, it will be a very expensive and uphill proposition that doesn’t have more than a 50/50 chance of succeeding.

When the employer faces a worker that engages in certain activities, he or she may need to sue the person for the actions that lead to the individual becoming a competitor. Many of these circumstances involve the employee acting in direct violation of company policy or the state or federal laws by stealing information from the company or poaching clients. —HG.org

That means you’ll have to find another way to deal with the situation. Since you’re probably not going to persuade him or her to give up their newfound success, or come back to work for you, what alternatives are there? Well, it really depends on your relationship as it stands now.

How to Deal with an Ex-Employee Who is Now a Competitor

When a former employee becomes a competitor, it can stir up a number of emotions. You might feel proud, if this was the plan all along. But, if it came out of the blue, chances are excellent that you will feel angry and even cheated. Fortunately, there are ways to deal with an ex-employee who becomes a business rival:

  • Talk about establishing some mutual boundaries. Although there was no arrangement in-place prior to his or her departure, that doesn’t mean that you can’t come to some agreement now. Speak with him or her about establishing some ground rules. Perhaps, you both can offer different variations of what is essentially the same within the industry. For instance, you take on one type of client, why he or she takes on another. Or, you agree not to cross certain geographic boundaries.
  • Form a strategic alliance. Here’s another idea — work together, yet separately. If the above suggestion isn’t feasible, then there’s no reason you can’t work together, behind-the-scenes. For example, you might be able to serve clients in one capacity, while he or she serves them in another. Yet another alternative is to work in tandem, where you pick up where he or she isn’t available, and vice-versa.
  • Shift your focus. This just might give you the opportunity you’ve been waiting for, for some time. You can look at it as a blessing in disguise to transition from one business model to another. Perhaps you’ve wanted to take the company in a different direction, but have been unable to fill the void. Now, there’s someone to do just that, freeing you to pursue new things.

What other suggestions do you have to deal with such a situation? Please take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your prospective!

Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

Tired of New Employees Abruptly Quitting? Here’s a Novel Solution for Recouping Your Training Costs

One of the most costly and infuriating aspects of running a business is training new employees only to have them up and abruptly quit. It takes a lot of time, effort, and extra expense to onboard new hires and get them familiar with practices and procedures. When they depart shortly after their training, it means having to fill that position all over again. Since this is such a huge hassle and a costly one at that, some companies are actually billing employees who quit. The strategy is to ensure new employees don’t receive critical industry training only to leave and use their new skills at a competitor paying higher wages and/or offering more enticing benefits packages. Companies Recovering Employee Training Costs through TRAPs Healthcare, retail, trucking, beauty, and more companies are adopting a new approach in order to reduce their workforce losses. Known as Training Repayment Agreement Provisions or TRAPs, these clauses are included in employee contracts. Nearly 10% of all American companies are now using these provisions, according to a recent report by Reuters News. When a valued employee quits, the loss can have a detrimental effect on the person’s team and department and maybe even on the entire company. Not only can an unexpected departure lead to lost revenue, but it also could lower the morale and productivity of remaining employees. —Society for Human Resource Management Other industries may follow this emerging trend if it proves successful and legal. There are already federal and state government agencies looking into the practice, and it appears to be legitimate. If it continues to grow in popularity, it should be not only a big benefit to businesses but to employees as well, as both parties will know precisely what’s expected of them and how to proceed accordingly. How to Use Employee Training Repayment Agreement Provisions Because this is somewhat new, it’s very important to take thoughtful, measured steps in order to implement such a practice. Here are some suggestions for how to use an employee training repayment agreement provision in your business: Consult a labor law attorney. The very first thing you should do is to speak with a lawyer who specializes in labor law in your state. Even if a future employee willingly signs such an agreement, there may be something on the books that does not allow you to enforce such a provision. So, be crystal clear it is legal and actionable in your state. Speak with your human resources department. Obviously if you are able to include an employee training repayment agreement provision in your hiring contracts, you’ll need to get the right people in your organization on board and in the know. You can help to develop a new section in your training process that discloses and advises potential hires and new team member about this provision. Make sure new hires are made fully aware of the provision. When you’re recruiting someone new to your organization, be sure this is made abundantly clear before you proceed with follow-up interviews and probably before the very first, initial interview. Any job candidate should be made aware of this provision well before you get deep into the hiring process. Include a mechanism to recoup new employee training costs. Of course, you’ll need a way to actually recoup those training costs. So, if you offer a sign-on bonus, that may be one way to recapture the expense. Here again, you’ll need to consult an experienced, licensed labor law attorney in your state to establish a recuperation mechanism for the provision. What else would you suggest business owners do to deal with new hires who quit shortly after being brought on? Please share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your input! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »

How to Push Forward Starting a New Business when Few People Believe You can Make It

Entrepreneurship is a journey that is full of challenges, and it is not uncommon for entrepreneurs to experience moments of self-doubt and a lack of motivation. However, it becomes even more challenging when the people around them are negative and tell them that they cannot succeed. How Entrepreneurs can Stay Motivated and Focused Even when People Around them Say they Can’t Succeed Negativity can weigh heavily on an entrepreneur’s mind – leading to a lack of focus and plenty of unnecessary second-guessing. So, let’s go ahead and discuss some strategies that entrepreneurs can use to stay motivated and focused even when the people around them are saying they can’t succeed. Believe in Yourself The first and most important thing is to believe in yourself. You must have confidence in your abilities and trust that you are capable of achieving your goals. If you don’t believe in yourself, it will be difficult for you to stay motivated and focused when others doubt you. Surround Yourself with Positive People Surrounding yourself with positive people who believe in you and your vision is essential. Negative people can bring you down and sap your energy. Seek out individuals who are supportive and can offer encouragement and constructive feedback. Focus on Your Vision Stay focused on your vision and goals, and don’t allow others to deter you from your path. (This isn’t easy because we all have self-doubts and are unavoidably influenced by the opinions of others – particularly the people closest to us.) Entrepreneurs have to make a lot of tough choices each day and it can take a toll. Throughout the rest of the day, though, they tend to limit decision-making to keep things simple. It’s a great tool for motivating entrepreneurs because it keeps them sharp when their abilities are needed elsewhere. —Inc.cdom Remember that success often comes after a series of failures and setbacks, so stay the course and remain committed to your vision. If you can put failures in perspective, you’ll have a much better chance of persevering when things don’t go right. Celebrate Small Wins Entrepreneurship is a journey, and it is essential to celebrate small wins along the way. Recognize the progress you’ve made, no matter how small, and use it as motivation to continue working towards your goals. Take Breaks and Practice Self-Care Running a business can be overwhelming, and it’s crucial to take breaks and practice self-care. Take time for yourself and do activities that bring you joy and help you relax. This will help you stay on task and keep your drive to succeed healthy in the long run. Keep Learning and Growing Entrepreneurship is a continuous learning process, and it’s essential to consistently grow and develop your skills. Attend seminars, conferences, and networking events to learn from other entrepreneurs and industry leaders. This will help you stay motivated and focused as you work towards your goals. Embrace Failure Finally, it’s essential to embrace failure as part of the learning process. Every entrepreneur has failed at some point, but what sets successful entrepreneurs apart is their ability to learn from their failures and use them as motivation to keep pushing forward. Summing it all up, staying motivated and focused as an entrepreneur can be challenging, especially when others doubt your ability to succeed. However, by believing in yourself, surrounding yourself with positive people, focusing on your vision, celebrating small wins, taking breaks and practicing self-care, keep learning and growing, and embracing failure, you can stay motivated and focused on your path to success. What other strategies and/or attitudes would you add to this list? Please, take a few minutes to share your own thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your perspective! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »

The Smartphone Stagnation Explains Why Consumers Are Ghosting New Models (And What It Means for Your Business)

Remember when the newest smartphone was actually exciting? Even non-techy people looked forward to upgrading their devices to get their hands on the latest and greatest features. Consumers genuinely felt they were switching up for something better, improving their experience and, in some ways, their lives. But today, people just aren’t as interested. When a company announces a new model, few pay attention. But why?

Read More »

Imagine Selling Your Business…

How Would Your Life Change?

You didn’t start your business just to stay busy—you built it to create freedom, security, and options for yourself and your family. Selling your business can be life-changing, but the real question is whether you’re intentionally building toward that outcome or simply leaving it to chance.

Sign up below for a free consultative session to learn what your business could be worth today and in the future! 

Thank you for your interest in learning what your business is worth. We will be in touch shortly.