Business Education

3 Necessary Replacement Manager Qualities

Replacing a manager in any size business presents a number of challenges. It’s not just finding the person with the right skill set, or the most experience, or even the best aptitude for the position, but all of these and more. Unfortunately, too many administrators and entrepreneurs only look at these types of qualities. They fail to factor in other intangibles that would benefit their team members the most. Read on to learn about the three most important qualities of a replacement manager.

Why Past Job Performance is No Guarantee of Future Success

You’ve no doubt heard or experienced two different cliches: that past performance of an investment is no guarantee of its future result, and the Peter Principle (the phenomenon of people rising to their highest level of incompetence). Unfortunately, this is where many administrators and business owners go wrong. They mistakenly believe that an individual’s past performance is indicative of future results. But, this just isn’t true.

Bad managers cost businesses billions of dollars each year, and having too many of them can bring down a company. The only defense against this massive problem is a good offense, because when companies get these decisions wrong, nothing fixes it. Businesses that get it right, however, and hire managers based on talent will thrive and gain a significant competitive advantage. —Harvard Business Review

Sure, it’s absolutely necessary to look at a candidate’s previous experience and performance. It’s also just as necessary to rely at least somewhat on their proven skill set and untapped potential. However, this isn’t likely to give you a good overall evaluation of how he or she will fit into his or her new role.

3 Important Replacement Manager Traits

One of the most difficult aspects of replacing a manager in any type of business is how he or she will be received by the team members he or she will lead. So, ask yourself if potential candidates have the following qualities:

Empathetic ears. There are many different kinds of managers out there, and some of them are a better fit for a promotion or lateral move than others. Depending on their new responsibilities, you most definitely want them to be ambitious and take ownership of their responsibilities. Equally so, it’s critical to have a manager who truly listens to their team members because this will be the perception employees have of the company overall.
Decision confidence. Obviously, if someone has all the experience and potential to move up or across, he or she should likewise possess a strong self confidence. In other words, a manager who doesn’t always have to rely on higher ups to make decisions, particularly ones that are relatively small. After all, you don’t want to put someone in a management role who just can’t make up their mind and constantly comes to you for those very reasons.
Golden rule follower. If there’s one thing that rank-and-file team members despise the most, it is managers who cannot follow their own rules. Hypocrisy, double standards, and negative traits such as these will quickly erode away employee morale and productivity. Nobody performs well under such types of management, because it is so counterproductive by its nature.

What other suggestions do you have for replacing a manager as a business owner? Please take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your unique perspective! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Like this article?

Tips for Transforming a Companys Culture

May 17, 2017 No Comments

Transforming a company’s culture isn’t for the faint of heart. It takes a lot of courage, dedication, and plenty of humility. While that’s sounds contradictory or confusing, it’s actually the case. You’re going to need to lead in a new direction and be able to take things in stride (at least, to a point). Because changing an organization’s culture will feel much like trying to push a boulder up a steep hill. At any moment, it can roll right over you. But, if you know a few ways to deal with this change, you’ll have a much better shot at success. Tips for Transforming a Company’s Culture It’s very common for a company’s culture to reflect the prevailing management style. Let’s face it, most individuals tend to hire people who reflect their own style, so this isn’t a surprise. That means if a hiring manager or another leader has certain bad habits, chances are excellent others on team will likewise possess those same or like behaviors. It’s also true that culture doesn’t form overnight. It takes time for a company culture to develop. As a [business owner] or as a manager, you may have the power to change your organization’s policies with the stroke of a pen. And you may have the ability to hire, fire, promote and demote people with relatively little effort. But changing an entrenched culture is the toughest task you will face. To do so, you must win the hearts and minds of the people you work with, and that takes both cunning and persuasion. —The Wall Street Journal Once that culture forms, it’s very difficult to change. People become complacent and it takes a significant event to shake that off. It could be a big change in the industry for the worse, losing a lot of money, a sudden shrink in customers, or something else. Great cultures drive productivity and profits. Poor cultures slow productivity and profits. Culture starts with Leadership. So, it’s very important to realize when the culture is toxic and/or when crazy has infiltrated the business. It’s at this juncture you need to take immediate action. Here are some helpful tips for transforming a company’s culture: Team-up with an insider. If you are new to the business, team-up with an insider — someone who can give you the details of what’s happened is a very valuable person. Or, if you’re part of a company that’s just gone awry, you still need someone you can trust. A person who gives you confidence you’re getting the straight story. You’ll learn a lot and probably discover different ways to get back on-track. Get feedback from team members. Aside from your go-to person, you still need to solicit feedback from the entire team. Encourage people to communicate their experiences and expectations. This is a great way to identify who is and isn’t working out. You’ll know by each person’s input and reactions who is an asset and who is a liability. Then, you can work with individuals to help them improve. Define the limits and be extra clear. While getting in-the-loop will provide a lot of valuable information, it’s not going to be a magic bullet. You’ll still need to define boundaries and be very clear on your expectations. Remember the old saying, “To be unclear is to be unkind.” It’s true and will certainly prove as much if you do not define your goals. Be bold and take the lead when necessary. What all of this means is, you’ll have to lead by example. You must set the tone day in and day out so everyone has a chance to adjust. Eventually, a new normal, a better culture, will evolve. Have you taken over an organization and changed its culture? How did you approach the situation? What other tips and tricks do you suggest to change a company’s culture. Please share your thoughts and experiences by leaving a comment. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group. [shareaholic app=”follow_buttons” id=”26833294″]

Your Industry Is Dying, But You Can Survive (and Thrive!)

June 19, 2025 No Comments

Industries evolve rapidly, and business owners may face the daunting reality that their skill set—or even their entire industry—is becoming obsolete.

How To Quickly – But Smartly – Fill a Very Sudden and Unexpected Vacancy in a Key Position in Your Small Business

December 13, 2023 No Comments

How To Quickly – But Smartly – Fill a Very Sudden and Unexpected Vacancy in a Key Position in Your Small Business Ever been hit with the unexpected departure of a key team member, leaving a crucial role vacant? It’s unnerving and quite unpleasant. But, don’t panic. There are effective strategies for dealing with this very situation. Well, you’ve found the right place to get the advice you’re seeking. In this article, we’ll explain the art of filling a vacancy rapidly – but strategically. So, let’s transform this challenge into an opportunity for growth with a playbook that ensures your business sails smoothly through uncharted waters. How Small Business Owners Can Fill a Vacancy in an Important Employee Role You know that sinking feeling. The email arrives or the text chimes and suddenly you’re staring at a gaping hole in your team – a vital position vacated without warning. Your brain screams, “Oh no!” Breathe and step back. We’ve all been there. But here’s the good news: filling an unexpected vacancy (especially in a small business where everyone wears multiple hats), doesn’t have to be a disaster. With a sprinkle of MacGyver ingenuity and these battle-tested strategies, you’ll not only plug that gap, but you might even emerge stronger on the other side. Step 1: Triage Time – Assess the Damage and Your Options Before you launch into a hiring frenzy, take a moment to assess the situation. What’s the critical function of this role? What are the immediate needs, both short-term and long-term? Can existing team members temporarily cover essential tasks, or is a full-blown replacement a must? Remember, you’re not just filling a job description; you’re patching a leak in your ship. Prioritize tasks that keep the boat afloat, delegate where possible, and resist the urge to overthink things. Step 2: Forget the Perfect Fit, Embrace the Quick Fix Casting a wide net and hoping for the “unicorn candidate” might not fly right now. Instead, embrace flexibility. Consider internal talent – that design whiz who secretly loves spreadsheets, or the customer service rep with a developer’s mind. Could upskilling or cross-training bridge the gap? Think outside the traditional “employee” box too. Could a freelancer, consultant, or even a temp agency be the right way to go as a short-term fix? Feel free to get creative and mix-and-match solutions to find the right puzzle piece for this immediate need. Step 3: From Panic to Process – The Art of the Speedy Hire Even with a “MacGyver approach,” you still need some structure. Here’s how to turbocharge your hiring process without sacrificing quality: Crystallize your ideal candidate. What skills and experience are non-negotiable, and what can be learned on the fly? Craft a concise yet compelling job description highlighting the immediate need and your company culture. Tap into your network. Emergency situations necessarily call for emergency measures. Reach out to your trusted network – colleagues, mentors, even former employees – and spread the word. You might be surprised at the hidden gems lurking just outside your usual talent pool. Master the “interview-a-thon.” Time is of the essence, so ditch the five-round interview marathon. Utilize video calls, skills assessments, and even a good old-fashioned phone chat to quickly gauge potential. Look for passion, adaptability, and a willingness to jump in headfirst – those are the qualities that will get you through this storm. Step 4: Remember, You’re Not Drowning, You’re Surfing – Embrace the Learning Curve and Lean on Your Team Filling a sudden vacancy is stressful, but you don’t have to go it alone. Your team is your anchor, your support system. Delegate tasks, ask for feedback, and foster a spirit of collaboration. This is a chance to solidify your team’s resilience and discover hidden strengths. And hey, if things don’t go according to plan at first? Don’t beat yourself up. This is a learning experience. Adapt, adjust, and keep moving forward. You’ve got the grit, the ingenuity, and the metaphorical duct tape to get through this. Stay Calm and Take Stock of the Long-Term Journey So, the next time the talent void opens, remember – it’s not the end, it’s just a detour. With a clear head, a dash of creativity, and the unwavering support of your team, you’ll not only weather the storm but emerge stronger on the other side. Now, go out there and show that unexpected vacancy who’s boss! Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while you spend more time with your family, which is why you started your business in the first place? We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test. You can call us for your free appointment at 602-435-5474, or, if you prefer, send us an email. You can also visit us at Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.