3 Necessary Replacement Manager Qualities

Replacing a manager in any size business presents a number of challenges. It’s not just finding the person with the right skill set, or the most experience, or even the best aptitude for the position, but all of these and more. Unfortunately, too many administrators and entrepreneurs only look at these types of qualities. They fail to factor in other intangibles that would benefit their team members the most. Read on to learn about the three most important qualities of a replacement manager.

Why Past Job Performance is No Guarantee of Future Success

You’ve no doubt heard or experienced two different cliches: that past performance of an investment is no guarantee of its future result, and the Peter Principle (the phenomenon of people rising to their highest level of incompetence). Unfortunately, this is where many administrators and business owners go wrong. They mistakenly believe that an individual’s past performance is indicative of future results. But, this just isn’t true.
Bad managers cost businesses billions of dollars each year, and having too many of them can bring down a company. The only defense against this massive problem is a good offense, because when companies get these decisions wrong, nothing fixes it. Businesses that get it right, however, and hire managers based on talent will thrive and gain a significant competitive advantage. —Harvard Business Review
Sure, it’s absolutely necessary to look at a candidate’s previous experience and performance. It’s also just as necessary to rely at least somewhat on their proven skill set and untapped potential. However, this isn’t likely to give you a good overall evaluation of how he or she will fit into his or her new role.

3 Important Replacement Manager Traits

One of the most difficult aspects of replacing a manager in any type of business is how he or she will be received by the team members he or she will lead. So, ask yourself if potential candidates have the following qualities:
  • Empathetic ears. There are many different kinds of managers out there, and some of them are a better fit for a promotion or lateral move than others. Depending on their new responsibilities, you most definitely want them to be ambitious and take ownership of their responsibilities. Equally so, it’s critical to have a manager who truly listens to their team members because this will be the perception employees have of the company overall.
  • Decision confidence. Obviously, if someone has all the experience and potential to move up or across, he or she should likewise possess a strong self confidence. In other words, a manager who doesn’t always have to rely on higher ups to make decisions, particularly ones that are relatively small. After all, you don’t want to put someone in a management role who just can’t make up their mind and constantly comes to you for those very reasons.
  • Golden rule follower. If there’s one thing that rank-and-file team members despise the most, it is managers who cannot follow their own rules. Hypocrisy, double standards, and negative traits such as these will quickly erode away employee morale and productivity. Nobody performs well under such types of management, because it is so counterproductive by its nature.
What other suggestions do you have for replacing a manager as a business owner? Please take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your unique perspective! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

From Surviving to Dominating

How Waters Business Consulting Group has helped transform many commercial landscape companies into more profitable, scalable businesses Every commercial landscape company eventually hits a moment that defines what happens next. For some, it’s growth outrunning the systems meant to support it. Revenue climbs, but profit doesn’t follow. Labor costs creep up. Cash gets tighter. The owner is working more hours and feeling less in control of the business every month. What used to feel like success starts to feel like an endless string of problems to solve from employees, field operations, customers to cash flow. For others, the challenge shows up faster and with more urgency. Margins have already eroded. Operations are inconsistent from crew to crew. Leadership is stretched too thin. Customers expect more, and the company doesn’t have the structure or financial visibility to respond. In both cases, most owners reach for the same fix: more sales. But more sales don’t automatically fix thin margins; the exacerbate them! With fuzzy accountability, inefficient processes, or an owner who’s become the bottleneck. Usually, what the company actually needs isn’t more revenue. It’s a better business. Waters Business Consulting Group has worked with commercial landscape maintenance and construction companies across the country, including Pleasant Places, Blue Star Landscaping, Genesis Landscape Solutions, Sun Country, and Creative Environments, to find what’s really limiting their performance and build practical paths toward stronger profitability and cash flow, tighter operations, real leadership capacity, and long-term value. Our goal was never just to help these companies survive. It’s to help them build what it takes to lead and increase the the value of their business asset.   Struggling doesn’t always look small Some of the most challenged companies we’ve worked with had real revenue, loyal customers, experienced crews, and a strong reputation in their market. From the outside, everything looked fine. Underneath, the same familiar warning signs kept showing up: revenue growing while profit stayed flat, the owner still involved in nearly every major decision, labor costs nobody could quite explain, crews performing inconsistently from job to job, estimates that didn’t reflect what jobs actually cost, financial reports arriving too late to act on, managers held accountable for results they had no real authority over, cash flow swinging unpredictably, and roles and processes that were never clearly defined in the first place. These problems rarely show up alone. A bad estimate turns into a margin problem and project losses. A margin problem turns into a cash-flow problem. Weak reporting means leadership doesn’t catch it until the financial damage is already real. And without a capable leadership team in place, the owner becomes the answer to every question and the fix for every problem. Over time, the business ends up running on effort instead of systems. Our approach starts by understanding how these challenges connect to each other, then figuring out which changes are actually likely to move the needle in a lasting way … in the same way we moved the needle for Pleasant Places Landscape, Blue Star Landscaping, Genesis Landscape Solutions, Sun Country, and Creative Environments.   Clarity comes before transformation You can’t fix a business you can’t see clearly. That’s why we look past the top-line revenue number and into the operational, financial, and organizational factors actually driving performance: profitability by customer, contract, or service line; labor efficiency and crew productivity; how accurate the estimating really is; direct costs and overhead; pricing strategy; cash flow and forecasting; org structure; leadership capacity; roles and accountability; the sales pipeline; operational processes; and how dependent the business is on the owner. We’re not trying to hand leadership another binder of reports. We’re trying to find the small handful of constraints actually driving performance, the levers, so leaders can stop treating symptoms and start fixing what’s underneath them. Pleasant Places: turning rapid growth into stronger profit Pleasant Places was already a real success story by the time the company partnered with us. Founded in 1984, this commercial landscaping company had grown fast, taking annual revenue from roughly $10 million to nearly $18 million in just two years. But that pace of growth had created its own problems. Margins were under pressure, processes and procedures needed real work, accountability was inconsistent from department to department, and the organization simply didn’t have the infrastructure to operate efficiently at its new size. We worked with the Pleasant Places leadership team to strengthen the financial, operational, and organizational foundation underneath all that growth. That meant digging into historical financial trends and building a model to evaluate cost of goods sold, margins, and breakeven performance; putting systems in place to track labor hours and materials against estimates; refining pricing to hit target gross margins; implementing real purchasing controls; identifying gaps in leadership and org structure; clarifying roles, responsibilities, and who reported to whom; supporting a management transition from father to son; establishing real performance metrics; and researching and implementing an ERP system to give the company far better operational visibility. The results speak for themselves. Pleasant Places gained real visibility into projected revenue, gross margins, profitability, and cash flow. Pricing discipline, tighter labor and material cost controls, and real leadership accountability helped push gross margins up from low 20’s to an average of 42%. Revenue grew past $35 million, and the company came out the other side with a stronger leadership structure, clearer expectations, and a healthier culture. The lesson here is simple: growth gets a lot more sustainable when financial discipline, operational systems, leadership accountability, and org structure grow right alongside revenue instead of trailing behind it. Blue Star Landscaping: building profitable growth, and a successful exit Blue Star Landscaping came to us with a different set of problems. The company needed to improve profitability, tighten up its pricing, get real control over labor and material costs, develop its leadership bench, and build a clear plan for growth. The team had solid industry experience, but they needed a more disciplined way to connect strategic growth to financial forecasting, pricing, cost control, and actual profitability. We worked with Blue Star

Read More »

Reasons Why Small Business Loans are Denied

Small business owners can easily find themselves in the unenviable position of needing capital, but, not having ready access to cash. It presents an age-old problem, buying equipment ties cash up, even though said equipment is considered an asset. Such assets can depreciate, which worsens the situation all the more. On the cash liquidity side, there are tax consequences to having a certain level of retained earnings. This is why debt instruments are a part of doing business. However, even profitable small businesses can be denied for a loan, and, there’s ample evidence to support this phenomenon. In the first two quarters of 2014, about half of applicant businesses received any funds, according to a survey conducted by the Federal Reserve Banks of New York, Atlanta, Cleveland and Philadelphia. Reasons Why Small Business Loans are Denied Unfortunately, present trends don’t show much improvement in the access to capital, or, in reducing operational costs. In fact, since November 2014, three out of ten businesses reported more difficulty in trying to reduce operating expenses, and, one-quarter reported unexpected expenses too hard to plan for, according to a study conducted by Nav (formerly Creditera), a business credit management company. If your company recently applied for business credit and was rejected, you’re not alone. So what can you do if your business credit application is denied? Start by trying to find out why. The Federal Trade Commission suggests submitting a written request for the reasons within 60 days of the denial, and the creditor must give you the specifics in writing within 30 days of the request. Consider discussing any concerns you have with your lender, and you may be able to resolve the issues. —Washington Post Within the same survey, about 20 percent of participant companies considered closing their doors, citing two primary reasons: lack of growth and issues with positive cash flow. These factors are likely why 53 percent of all companies applied for lines of credit or loans over the past half-decade, with more than one-in-four attempting to access capital numerous times. During the same five year period, one-fifth were denied and of those, 45 percent reported being turned down more than once. Twenty-three percent of all those denied loans or lines of credit did not know the reason why their applications were denied. So, why is this happening and what makes it appear so prevalent? There are reasons why small business loans are turned down, and, it’s actually not complicated. Here are some of the most common reasons small business loans are denied: Having no credit or even bad credit. Some business owners do not realize they have two credit scores: their personal credit and their business’ credit. What’s worse, some owners have relied on personal lines of credit and have seriously driven their DTI or debt-to-income ratio into dangerous territory. Making payments on-time, keeping a low balance, and not seeking to continually open new credit lines are all necessary to improve both personal and business credit. Too little collateral. Since most business owners aren’t willing to sign a personal guarantee, leveraging their personal vehicles and home to secure a loan, there’s little to nothing left to pledge as collateral. Lenders aren’t keen and will not provide financing that constitutes an unnecessary risk. Anemic cash flow. After all other expenses are paid, lenders want to see demonstrable proof there’s enough cash to repay the loan. Too tight a margin and banks won’t be willing to approve a business loan. Lack of strategic planning. It’s often true that business owners don’t understand the loan process, including the application itself, and all necessary documentation and that can lead to being turned down. Applicants must provide a clear forecast and show a realistic, actionable plan. Under capitalization on loan applications. There are sometimes more assets available to claim than applicants realize and as a result, their loan application makes the organization appear under capitalized. Some assets aren’t immediately clear, which means all potential assets ought to be identified. Another reason businesses might have trouble securing debt instruments is industry-specific difficulties. For instance, a construction company that’s operating in a locality where people are moving away from, or, a taxi company that’s facing tougher licensing regulations or an industry disruption as we have recently seen with Uber. The best solution in the short term is to reduce your Cost of Goods (labor and materials) to improve Gross Margins and reduce Expense Overhead to increase Net Profits which will help with cash flow and operating capital. Also, negotiating terms with your Receivables and slowing growth will allow for an influx of cash. Where possible, attempt to self fund your growth. If capital is required for growth, pursue alternative lending sources other than banks. There are several available and feel free to contact us if you are in need of alternative lending sources. Want to find out about what a business coach can do for you? [shareaholic app=”follow_buttons” id=”26833294″]

Read More »

Imagine Selling Your Business…

How Would Your Life Change?

You didn’t start your business just to stay busy—you built it to create freedom, security, and options for yourself and your family. Selling your business can be life-changing, but the real question is whether you’re intentionally building toward that outcome or simply leaving it to chance.

Sign up below for a free consultative session to learn what your business could be worth today and in the future! 

Thank you for your interest in learning what your business is worth. We will be in touch shortly.