3 Necessary Replacement Manager Qualities

Replacing a manager in any size business presents a number of challenges. It’s not just finding the person with the right skill set, or the most experience, or even the best aptitude for the position, but all of these and more. Unfortunately, too many administrators and entrepreneurs only look at these types of qualities. They fail to factor in other intangibles that would benefit their team members the most. Read on to learn about the three most important qualities of a replacement manager.

Why Past Job Performance is No Guarantee of Future Success

You’ve no doubt heard or experienced two different cliches: that past performance of an investment is no guarantee of its future result, and the Peter Principle (the phenomenon of people rising to their highest level of incompetence). Unfortunately, this is where many administrators and business owners go wrong. They mistakenly believe that an individual’s past performance is indicative of future results. But, this just isn’t true.
Bad managers cost businesses billions of dollars each year, and having too many of them can bring down a company. The only defense against this massive problem is a good offense, because when companies get these decisions wrong, nothing fixes it. Businesses that get it right, however, and hire managers based on talent will thrive and gain a significant competitive advantage. —Harvard Business Review
Sure, it’s absolutely necessary to look at a candidate’s previous experience and performance. It’s also just as necessary to rely at least somewhat on their proven skill set and untapped potential. However, this isn’t likely to give you a good overall evaluation of how he or she will fit into his or her new role.

3 Important Replacement Manager Traits

One of the most difficult aspects of replacing a manager in any type of business is how he or she will be received by the team members he or she will lead. So, ask yourself if potential candidates have the following qualities:
  • Empathetic ears. There are many different kinds of managers out there, and some of them are a better fit for a promotion or lateral move than others. Depending on their new responsibilities, you most definitely want them to be ambitious and take ownership of their responsibilities. Equally so, it’s critical to have a manager who truly listens to their team members because this will be the perception employees have of the company overall.
  • Decision confidence. Obviously, if someone has all the experience and potential to move up or across, he or she should likewise possess a strong self confidence. In other words, a manager who doesn’t always have to rely on higher ups to make decisions, particularly ones that are relatively small. After all, you don’t want to put someone in a management role who just can’t make up their mind and constantly comes to you for those very reasons.
  • Golden rule follower. If there’s one thing that rank-and-file team members despise the most, it is managers who cannot follow their own rules. Hypocrisy, double standards, and negative traits such as these will quickly erode away employee morale and productivity. Nobody performs well under such types of management, because it is so counterproductive by its nature.
What other suggestions do you have for replacing a manager as a business owner? Please take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your unique perspective! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

Business Owners: Want to Win More Bids? Ditch the Lowest Price Strategy Now!

Tired of losing bids despite offering the lowest price? It’s time to rethink your strategy. Savvy business owners are winning more contracts by focusing on value, not just cost, and this gives them a key advantage in today’s super-competitive market. Below, we’ll look into why ditching the race to the bottom could be your key to securing more deals and boosting profits. Winning Contract Bids Without the Lowest Price: Smart Strategies for Business Owners For many business owners, securing a contract bid is a critical step toward growth and stability. But when competitors undercut your pricing, it can feel like an uphill battle. Fortunately, winning a bid isn’t just about having the lowest price—it’s about demonstrating unmatched value, reliability, and expertise. Here are the smartest strategies business owners can use to beat out competitors—even when they can’t offer the lowest price. 1. Highlight Your Unique Value Proposition Instead of competing on price, compete on value. What makes your business unique? Whether it’s exceptional service, proprietary methods, superior materials, or long-term cost savings, make sure your bid clearly communicates why you’re the best choice. 2. Focus on Quality and Longevity Some clients prefer reliability over rock-bottom pricing. If your product or service lasts longer, requires less maintenance, or improves efficiency, quantify that value. For example, a higher upfront investment in your service may reduce operational costs down the line—making your bid the smarter financial choice in the long run. 3. Showcase a Strong Track Record Clients want assurance that their investment won’t go to waste. Use testimonials, case studies, and historical data to prove that your company delivers results. Highlight successful projects, positive customer feedback, and retention rates that demonstrate your reliability and excellence. 4. Offer Customization and Flexibility Many companies struggle with one-size-fits-all solutions. If your competitors are bidding with generic offerings, showcase how your business tailors services to client needs. Providing custom options, phased implementations, or adaptable contracts can make you the preferred choice. 5. Strengthen Your Relationship with Decision-Makers Building strong relationships can significantly impact contract decisions. Engage with prospective clients before the bid process, understand their pain points, and position yourself as a trusted partner—not just a vendor. Personal connections and a reputation for integrity can make your proposal more appealing. 6. Provide Exceptional Customer Service A client’s experience matters just as much as the service itself. If you’ve built a reputation for responsive, personalized customer care, highlight it in your bid. Show how your customer-first approach helps clients avoid headaches down the road. 7. Offer Value-Added Incentives You may not be the cheapest option, but adding extras can sweeten the deal. Consider offering extended warranties, priority support, free training, or additional consulting as part of your bid package. Small enhancements can make a significant impact in the decision-making process. 8. Be Transparent About ROI Clients want to know why they should pay more. Break down the long-term return on investment (ROI) in clear numbers, showing that your offering delivers better results, fewer risks, and overall savings despite a higher initial cost. 9. Strengthen Your Proposal Presentation A well-crafted, professional bid stands out. Avoid generic templates—customize your proposal to address the client’s specific pain points. Use compelling visuals, clear data, and a persuasive narrative to make your case stronger than price alone. 10. Optimize Your Reputation in the Industry Your credibility matters. Industry awards, certifications, expert endorsements, and strong reviews enhance your perceived value. If your company has a respected name in the market, leverage it in your bid to strengthen your position. Winning Without Undercutting Prices Your ability to win bids without being the cheapest depends on how well you communicate your business’s strengths and advantages. Price may be a factor, but it’s not the only factor. With a strategic approach that highlights reliability, quality, and added value, your business can secure contracts while maintaining profitable pricing. Want to Accomplish More? Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do? We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test. You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer,

Read More »

The ‘Ghost Money’ Formula: How Small Businesses Can Hand Out Meaningful Annual Bonuses Without Draining the Bank

Small businesses and bonuses aren’t synonymous. Such “lavish” gifts are associated with big companies and organizations with tons of employees, bringing in oversized profits. But there’s no denying the benefits of bonuses: increased motivation and productivity, improved morale and retention, and better alignment with company goals. However, small businesses often operate on small margins or moderate profits, making every expense count. So, how can a small company reap the benefits of giving employees bonuses when money is tight?

Read More »

3 Subtle but Serious Signs a Business Partnership is in Big Trouble

Ostensibly, a partnership is an ideal way to bring two necessary but different skill-sets together. After all, it makes sense to join various strengths in order to form an alliance. Such an arrangement seems like it will yield fruitful results. However, far more partnerships fail than succeed. There are many obvious reasons why this happens. But, it’s not always so clear-cut. So, let’s take a look at some subtle telltale signs that a partnership is in trouble. The Biggest Partnership Dangers Dave Ramsey has made famous his five dangerous D’s of partnerships: death, disability, disinterest, drugs, and divorce. Of those, only one makes the list below. That’s because it’s not always crystal clear that something is awry. You generally spend more waking hours at work than at home, which means you have more opportunities to interact with your business partner and the nature of your interactions tend to be more intense, with more potential for conflict because there are so many external variables that are beyond your control. —Forbes.com There are scenarios when very subtle factors are in play. Unfortunately, most business people miss these signals put out by their partners. Eventually, they become more pronounced and at that point, it is usually too late to save the enterprise. 3 Signs a Business Partnership is in Jeopardy When a business partner goes through a very difficult time in his or her life, it’s usually quite easy to see the writing on the wall. But, there are instances when there are no overt problems or issues. Here are three subtle yet serious signs a business partnership is in trouble: Apathetic. Let’s begin with the only sign that makes the list above — disinterest. This can manifest in two different but similar forms: distraction and apathy. A lack of concern and focus can wreak loads of havoc on a business. Before you know it, the onus falls on you alone. That’s when you’ll realize your partner is no longer interested in participating. And, by this time, it usually causes an irreversible rift. Autonomy. On the opposite side of the spectrum is autonomy. Sure, being able to operate independently is typically a good thing. Except when there’s far too much of it. So much, you find out about key decisions well after the fact. This is a sign that unpleasant news is most likely on its way to you. Elusive. This is a very tough one and perhaps, the most frustrating of the two because it’s so difficult to understand. When your partner becomes elusive, that is to say, overzealous one moment and indifferent the next, you’ll struggle to cope with why. This will only lead to unnecessary disruptions and make the partnership unsustainable. What other signs would you add to the list? Please share your thoughts and experiences by commenting! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »