There’s No Synergy and Little Camaraderie between My Tenured Staff and New Hires… What Do I Do?

So, you had a wonderful staff and everything was going really well. Then, the whole world fell into chaos due to the pandemic. But, you managed to work your way through and even brought on additional personnel. It was a reasonable and logistical decision. Now, you’re caught in a quagmire because your tenured employees aren’t syncing with your new hires. What can you do before it becomes too big a problem? Simple, take immediate action, size up differences, be impartial, formulate an action plan, and then keep an eye out.

Every Solution Breeds New Problems

It sure seems that when you find a way to fix an issue, it only creates another problem. Although it’s a well-known cliche, it’s certainly something that practically every business has experienced. When you brought aboard fresh talent, you probably pictured them working side by side with your existing staff. Instead, you’ve got a kind of civil war unfolding in your place of business.
…it is important to intervene early. In extreme examples, the conflict might be due to one employee who is creating a problem, but most often it is a matter of having two personalities that don’t mesh well together. The sooner a solution is reached, the sooner both employees will be happy to be able to move on—and the sooner their coworkers will be relieved to feel the easing of tensions in the office. —The Balance Careers
Obviously, you can’t let this go on and need to address it as quickly as possible. If you don’t, it will only worsen over time and divisions will grow deeper among your combative team members. They might even go so far as to quit abruptly in a moment of anger and leave you to deal with the very untimely fallout. Instead of letting this situation grow out of control, you need to intervene and take rational, measured action. Otherwise, you might also become emotionally overcharged and that will only lead to a lot more trouble.

How to Deal with Employees Who Don’t Work Well Together

There is always a potential for personalities to clash. It’s the opposite problem of having employees who get along too well, to the point they isolate themselves from the rest of the staff and that too becomes an issue. Because people are inherently social, they really like to get along. But, there are individuals who feel an innate need to do their own thing and this also can present a number of problems. If you have a tenured staff that isn’t meshing with new hires, here are a few bits of advice about how to deal with these circumstances:
  • Identify the problem(s). We’ll start with the most obvious step to take. And that is, to identify the root issues of what’s causing so much chaos. You might find there are very petty differences here that have managed to quickly balloon out of proportion. If so, that’s actually good news because it’s a much easier fix. However, if you discover it’s a very wide and deep rift, you’ll have your work cut out for you.
  • Understand basic personalities. It’s not just enough to understand what’s going on at the most basic level, it’s imperative that you also know precisely what types of personalities are involved. If you don’t have a firm grip on these elements, there’s really nothing that you can do to end the feud. If necessary, take a little time to get to know your new people better so that you can approach this with confidence.
  • Don’t show favoritism to anyone. If there’s one thing that will sabotage all of your healing attempts, it’s showing favoritism. Usually, this trait appears on behalf of the people you know best and is biased against the new people in the business. Even if it’s the other way around, favoritism is a poison pill. Be objective and think things through before you take any significant action.
  • Present some real, workable solutions. Obviously, as the leader of the business, you’ll be the one who needs to come up with one or more solutions or a set of compromises. Regardless of what these are, don’t apply them unilaterally. Instead, speak to people individually in order to get a sense of what they think is most fair, then bring everyone together as a group to talk it out.
  • Monitor the situation objectively thereafter. Lastly, don’t pull yourself away from the situation too quickly. Instead, watch what unfolds over the next few days to several weeks and be ready to make changes if necessary. You could discover that it’s just not workable and have to make changes to your staff or even put people in different roles. Hopefully, they will begin to work well together and develop strong professional relationships.
What other suggestions do you have for dealing with team members who don’t necessarily get along? Please take a moment or two to express your thoughts and experiences; you might just help someone else out in a big way! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

An image of Roof on a residential house.

How C&S Roofing Grew Revenue 400% Without Losing a 60-Year Family Legacy

A Family Legacy at a Crossroads C&S Roofing traces its roots back to 1958, when Harold Benard Patterson founded a small Phoenix-area construction company built on honest work and lasting relationships. More than sixty years later, the business — now run by his grandson Collin Patterson and Collin’s wife, Susan, under the DBA C&S Roofing — has never had a single complaint filed against its contractor’s license. That kind of track record is rare. But by 2020, Collin and Susan realized that reputation alone wouldn’t carry the company to its next stage of growth. The business had hit a plateau, and they knew it was time to bring in outside expertise. “I have worked with John for quite some time now, and it has been amazing. They have helped guide myself and my team with a very aggressive growth and have done an amazing job. We have hit our growth goals for the 2021 year and are looking forward to growing with the Waters Group in 2022,” said Collin Patterson, co-owner of C&S Roofing. Uncovering the Gaps When Waters Business Consulting Group (WBCG) began working with C&S Roofing, the picture that emerged was a familiar one for fast-growing family businesses: strong craftsmanship, but disorganized workflows, unclear project management processes, and financial forecasting that couldn’t keep pace with the company’s ambitions. Collin and Susan had a solid handle on their current financials, but cash flow tracking and revenue forecasting were largely reactive rather than strategic. Roles within the organization were loosely defined, which created friction as more people joined the team, and the company lacked a clear enough view of its capital needs to build the credit foundation required for serious growth. Building Structure Around a Strong Foundation Rather than reinvent what was already working, WBCG focused on giving the Pattersons the systems and visibility they needed to scale with confidence. That started with a full financial model — one that tracked expense margins and revenue generated per sale, and connected the dots between product sold and the growth targets the company was chasing. From there, the team built an organizational structure that clarified roles and responsibilities, mapped out a workflow process from the first customer call through project completion, and introduced key performance indicators so every employee understood what they were accountable for and how their work tied back to results. Just as important, the engagement helped the Pattersons step back and define the vision and culture they wanted to build the company around — the kind of clarity that turns a family business into an organization other people want to be part of. The Payoff: Structure That Scales The results showed up quickly and kept compounding. Since 2020, C&S Roofing has grown revenue by 400%, with record sales projected to surpass $8,000,000 in 2022 alongside improving net profit margins. The company added key talent that fit its culture, freeing Collin and Susan to focus on leadership and vision rather than day-to-day firefighting. C&S Roofing has since partnered with two national builder clients and one international client on major projects across the Phoenix and Tucson markets, and was actively bidding with two additional national builders at the time of this case study. Just as meaningfully, the ownership team now has real clarity and confidence in the direction of the business. Responsibilities are clearly assigned, metrics are tracked across the pipeline and financials, and marketing has stabilized into a predictable growth engine — a far cry from the plateau the company was facing just a couple of years earlier. Ready to Build That Kind of Structure Into Your Business? Every growing company eventually hits the same wall C&S Roofing did — great work, but not enough structure to scale it. If your business is ready to move from reactive to strategic, Waters Business Consulting Group can help you build the financial clarity, organizational structure, and accountability systems to get there. Contact Waters Business Consulting Group to schedule a free consultation.

Read More »
Waters Business Consulting Group

Ways Business Owners can Deal with Personal Crisis

Entrepreneurs pride themselves on self-reliance, but a personal crisis—a death, a divorce, a financial blow—doesn’t care about your business plan. When your personal life falls apart, keeping your company running can feel impossible. Here are some practical ways business owners can protect their company and themselves when life throws a real curveball.

Read More »
Credit card stock photo

How Entrepreneurs Can Establish Good Business Credit

Starting a business gives you the chance to build credit that’s completely separate from your personal finances—a separation that can protect you if either one takes a hit. But good business credit doesn’t happen automatically; it takes deliberate steps to establish and maintain. Here’s what entrepreneurs need to know about securing a debt instrument, building payment history, and keeping your credit files error-free.

Read More »

Imagine Selling Your Business…

How Would Your Life Change?

You didn’t start your business just to stay busy—you built it to create freedom, security, and options for yourself and your family. Selling your business can be life-changing, but the real question is whether you’re intentionally building toward that outcome or simply leaving it to chance.

Sign up below for a free consultative session to learn what your business could be worth today and in the future! 

Thank you for your interest in learning what your business is worth. We will be in touch shortly.