Business Education

When Your Best Salesperson Crosses the Line: How to Respond to Deceptive Upselling Without Losing Trust

Imagine this: you have a rockstar salesperson who brings in big business. You’re blown away by their performance and uncanny ability to persuade customers of add-ons or upsales, and it’s got you thinking seriously about bringing on another powerhouse who can rake in even more cash.

But then you begin to hear disturbing rumors among your staff, and before you know it, that very same scary scuttlebutt is validated by angry customer complaints; people who are furious that they’ve paid way more than necessary. Suddenly, you realize what’s been going on right under your nose, and you’re not prepared to deal with the stench.

7 Steps to Regain Trust When Salespeople Deceive Customers

For small business owners, a top-performing salesperson often feels like a blessing. They close deals, hit ambitious targets, and drive revenue. But what happens when that rainmaker turns rogue, intentionally upselling customers on products or services they don’t truly need, just to fatten their commission?

The fallout can be swift and damaging: customer complaints, lost trust, and potential reputational harm. If you’ve discovered this behavior within your business, don’t panic—but do act decisively.

1. Investigate Before You Accuse

As tempting as it is to react immediately, start by gathering facts. Review transaction records, customer complaints, and sales scripts or recordings (if available). Speak privately with a few affected customers to verify patterns.

You’ll need a clear understanding of whether this was a one-off lapse in judgment or a systemic issue driven by incentives, lack of oversight, or toxic sales culture.

2. Talk to the Salesperson—Candidly and Compassionately

Once you’ve reviewed the evidence, schedule a confidential conversation with the salesperson in question. Give them a chance to explain. Was this behavior driven by pressure to meet quotas? Did they misunderstand the product’s value?

While deception is never excusable, understanding motivations can help you decide the appropriate consequence, whether it’s coaching, probation, commission restructuring, or termination.

3. Own Up to Customers and Make It Right

If customers were sold unnecessary add-ons or services, they deserve honesty and remedies. Reach out individually to apologize. Offer refunds or replacements where appropriate. Most importantly, reassure them that corrective action is being taken to prevent future issues.

Transparency won’t erase the mistake, but it can rebuild trust and distinguish your business as one that holds itself accountable.

4. Reevaluate Sales Incentives

Commission structures that reward only high-ticket sales can breed short-term thinking and even unethical behavior. Consider revising your incentive model to reward:

Customer satisfaction scores
Repeat business or long-term retention
Cross-team collaboration and accuracy of recommendations

And keep this in mind: when integrity becomes as valuable as revenue, behavior tends to follow.

5. Retrain Your Team on Ethical Selling

Use the incident as a teachable moment. Host a company-wide refresher on values, ethical selling, and the long-term importance of customer trust. Reestablish that upselling is only acceptable when it genuinely enhances the customer’s experience.

Share real examples—an upsell gone wrong vs. an upsell that provided clear value—and encourage open dialogue.

6. Put Safeguards in Place

Preventative systems protect your business moving forward. These might include:

Customer feedback surveys triggered post-purchase
Sales audits conducted monthly or quarterly
Anonymous reporting channels for team members who witness ethical breaches

Even simple changes—like requiring managerial review for unusually high-value sales—can deter problematic behavior.

7. Reflect on Culture and Leadership

Deceptive sales tactics don’t exist in a vacuum. Consider whether your internal messaging emphasizes performance over people, or speed over service. Culture starts at the top—your values as a leader echo across your team.

If necessary, realign your messaging to prioritize relationships, integrity, and long-term growth over short-term spikes.

What We’ve Learned

Discovering dishonest behavior from your top salesperson is frustrating, especially when you thought they were setting the standard, not breaking it. But handled thoughtfully, this can be a turning point for your business: a chance to recommit to ethical practices, reinforce your values, and prove to customers that your company does the right thing even when it’s hard.

Your reputation isn’t built on being perfect. It’s built on how you respond when things go wrong.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, send us an email. You can also visit us at Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

What Small Business Owners Need to Know about Instituting Employee PTO

September 1, 2023 No Comments

Providing Paid Time Off (PTO) is a critical component of a comprehensive employee benefits package. For small business owners, understanding the nuances of PTO can be crucial for both employee satisfaction and business success. In the following article, we will explore the pros and cons of offering PTO to your team members, helping you make informed decisions that balance employee well-being and operational efficiency. The Pros and Cons of Small Businesses Offering Paid Time Off As you already know, Paid Time Off (PTO) is a benefit that allows employees to take time away from work without losing pay. It can be used for vacation, sick leave, or other personal reasons. While there is no federal law requiring small businesses to offer PTO, many states do have their own laws. For example, California requires employers to provide at least 10 days of paid vacation per year after an employee has been with the company for one year. So, be sure to look into the specific laws in your area in order to be legally compliant. Pros of Offering PTO When small business owners first consider instituting a Paid Time Off program, they of course think about the cost. But entrepreneurs should also equally consider the enjoyment current employees will experience, and the appeal it will have for future hires. Such a benefit has other positives, too, including the following: Employee well-being. Offering PTO demonstrates your commitment to your employees’ work-life balance and overall well-being. PTO also helps reduce stress levels for employees. When employees are able to take time away from work to relax and recharge, they are better able to cope with the demands of their jobs. Enhanced morale. PTO boosts employee morale and job satisfaction, leading to higher levels of motivation and productivity. When employees feel like they are valued and have the opportunity to take time off, they are more likely to be happy and engaged in their work. Attracting talent. A robust PTO policy can attract top talent, showcasing your business as one that values its employees’ time and efforts. In fact, a survey by Glassdoor found that 72% of employees would be more likely to accept a job offer if it included PTO. Reduced burnout. Regular breaks contribute to reduced burnout, increasing employee engagement and long-term retention. This in turn, also reduces employee turnover, which is yet another huge benefit, especially in terms of continuity. Flexibility. PTO provides employees with flexibility to address personal matters, reducing stress and absenteeism. It also provides them with a sense of freedom and less apprehension about having to ask for time off that is not compensated. Plus, Paid Time Off will help to boost creativity and innovation. When employees are able to take time away from their work, they can come back with fresh ideas and perspectives. Cons of Offering PTO Okay, there’s just no getting around the fact that with any change, even an ostensibly positive one, it will come with at least a few downsides. With this in mind, here are the most common disadvantages small businesses experience when introducing such an employee benefit: Operational impact. PTO can disrupt daily operations, especially if multiple employees are on leave simultaneously. That means it’s best to coordinate ahead of time in order to avoid such inconveniences. Financial considerations. Paid time off requires budgeting for wages during employee absences, potentially affecting cash flow. Be sure to have this worked out before making an announcement to your team. Workload redistribution. When employees are on PTO, their tasks may need to be redistributed, causing potential strain on remaining team members. Potential abuse. Some employees might abuse PTO, leading to reduced team productivity and resentment. Yet another downside is a lack of coverage. In a small team, the absence of a key employee on PTO might result in a lack of expertise or coverage. Additionally, if too many employees are taking time off at the same time, it can be difficult to keep the business running smoothly. Tips for Effectively Implementing PTO Policies The decision of whether or not to offer PTO is a complex one. There are many factors to consider, such as your budget, the needs of your employees, and the laws of your state. If you are considering offering PTO, here are a few more things to keep in mind: Clear guidelines. Develop clear PTO policies, outlining accrual rates, approval procedures, and blackout periods. Advance notice. Encourage employees to provide advance notice for PTO requests to facilitate operational planning. Fair allocation. Ensure PTO is allocated fairly, preventing any perception of favoritism or inequality. Seasonal considerations. Plan for peak seasons when PTO might be challenging to accommodate without affecting business operations. Encourage balance. Promote the use of PTO to maintain a healthy work-life balance among employees. Of course, communication is also important. Clearly communicate your PTO policies, including how to request time off and the expected response time. Offering Paid Time Off is a critical consideration for small business owners, with far-reaching impacts on both employees and operations. The benefits of PTO, including improved morale, productivity, and employee well-being, can offset the challenges of operational disruptions and budgeting. By thoughtfully designing and implementing PTO policies, small business owners can create a positive work environment that attracts and retains top talent, promotes employee satisfaction, and contributes to the overall success and growth of the business. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Microsoft just Demonstrated Why the Hard Sell doesn’t Work — Again

February 25, 2020 No Comments

Microsoft just undermined its launch of its newly released Edge browser by hard selling it. You may not know about this because it’s niche-worthy news. But, it’s a lesson that the company should have learned many years ago. Instead, it continues to make the same mistake over and over again. Here’s what it is, what it means, and why it proves the hard sell doesn’t work. Why the Hard Sell doesn’t Work Microsoft recently introduced a new version of its Edge browser. In order to promote it, the company shamelessly inserted a conspicuous ad in its Windows 10 menu. The advertisement “suggests” that users switch from their current browser of choice over to Edge. Of course, people don’t like this assertive tactic and are taking to social media to complain about it. Small-business owners successful at sales know the best way to sell something is not to sell it. You listen to potential customers about what they want or need, and then you introduce your product as the answer. You want people to think buying your services was their idea. —American Express Turns out that Microsoft is not willing to learn from its many repeated mistakes of the past. That is, the corporation’s insistence on pushing its customers into buying or using proprietary products and services that are promoted through the company’s various platforms. This is not only annoying, it’s obnoxious. Plus, it demonstrates the many problems with hard selling. There is no empathy, no relationship, no trust, and so it goes against human nature. Trying to badger people into becoming loyal customers is simply not a winning strategy. 3 Proven Ways to Sell without Being Pushy (or Obnoxious) So, how do you promote your products and/or services without hard selling? It’s actually easier than one would think. Better yet, it works and works very well. Here are three effective ways to sell without being pushy or obnoxious: Take your time. Rushing will only backfire. When you sell at a hurried pace, you don’t give your customer enough time to process what you’re offering. It’s confusing and overwhelming and unsurprisingly, it typically won’t work. Let potential customers do all the talking. Well, maybe not all the talking, but most definitely, the majority of it. This way, you’ll learn quite a bit about him or her and gain a better understanding of his or her needs. You’ll be regarded as empathetic and trustworthy and those two key elements are important to building any relationship. Focus on their problem, not your product or service. This goes hand-in-hand with the second point. You need to understand precisely what their problem is in order to offer an effective solution. You won’t be forcing a sale, but rather giving them answers they need. What other strategies do you use in-place of hard selling techniques? Please comment and share your thoughts and experiences! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Is Your Business Really Ready to Expand in the Coming New Year

January 7, 2020 No Comments

Is your business really ready to expand in the coming new year? Although the question seems complicated, it’s not too difficult to answer. Just four key factors can quickly help you determine if you’re ready to expand your business. And, perhaps more importantly, if your company is ready to expand. What it Really Means to Expand a Business Business owners often think about two elements when it comes to expansion — output and sales. Of course, it’s not that simple. However, these are two very important parts of the overall equation. Nonetheless, what it really means to expand a business is to take on a whole new level of responsibility. Even thinking about growing your business is exciting. Expansion means more products or services, customers, sales, and income for you. And, for businesses with physical locations, expansion might mean opening a bigger or second location. Before you rush into expanding your small business, you need to make sure your company is actually ready for growth. Your recent business success isn’t the only thing you should look at. —Forbes.com It also means the business having to respond to a new level of production while not losing it’s nimbleness or its personalized customer service. After all, if it can’t do the latter two — stay agile and maintain customer care quality — it will hurt the company greatly. 4 Signs It’s Time to Expand Your Business So, just what are the signs that it’s time to expand a business? Well, it comes down to only a select group of factors, which include the following: You have too much business. Time and again, you’re falling behind because you simply lack the resources to get all the work done. You’ve streamlined every single solitary step along the way and still, you’re not able to adequately keep up. Worse yet, it’s starting to show itself to customers. Too much work and too few resources to get it done in a timely manner. You have a strong team in-place. Your team members are your secret sauce. Without them, you’d really be in big trouble. Fortunately, they’re able to pull off magnificent feats over and over again. Well, that’s not only good news for the present, but really good for a future expansion. You have the money to expand. Expanding usually means incurring significant expenses. But, if you have some retained earnings saved and a strong forecast for the next several months, you probably can afford to expand your operation. You have a plan to upscale your operation. While the first three elements are absolutely critical, this is perhaps the most important of all because it will define your way forward. (It’s also where winging it just won’t cut it.) So, take the time to consult an experienced business consultant and coach. Someone who has helped companies grow before. Work together to formulate an actionable expansion plan. What other advice would you give business owners who want to know if it’s time to expand? Please share your thoughts and experiences by commenting! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.