When Your Best Salesperson Crosses the Line: How to Respond to Deceptive Upselling Without Losing Trust

Imagine this: you have a rockstar salesperson who brings in big business. You’re blown away by their performance and uncanny ability to persuade customers of add-ons or upsales, and it’s got you thinking seriously about bringing on another powerhouse who can rake in even more cash.

But then you begin to hear disturbing rumors among your staff, and before you know it, that very same scary scuttlebutt is validated by angry customer complaints; people who are furious that they’ve paid way more than necessary. Suddenly, you realize what’s been going on right under your nose, and you’re not prepared to deal with the stench.

7 Steps to Regain Trust When Salespeople Deceive Customers

For small business owners, a top-performing salesperson often feels like a blessing. They close deals, hit ambitious targets, and drive revenue. But what happens when that rainmaker turns rogue, intentionally upselling customers on products or services they don’t truly need, just to fatten their commission?

The fallout can be swift and damaging: customer complaints, lost trust, and potential reputational harm. If you’ve discovered this behavior within your business, don’t panic—but do act decisively.

1. Investigate Before You Accuse

As tempting as it is to react immediately, start by gathering facts. Review transaction records, customer complaints, and sales scripts or recordings (if available). Speak privately with a few affected customers to verify patterns.

You’ll need a clear understanding of whether this was a one-off lapse in judgment or a systemic issue driven by incentives, lack of oversight, or toxic sales culture.

2. Talk to the Salesperson—Candidly and Compassionately

Once you’ve reviewed the evidence, schedule a confidential conversation with the salesperson in question. Give them a chance to explain. Was this behavior driven by pressure to meet quotas? Did they misunderstand the product’s value?

While deception is never excusable, understanding motivations can help you decide the appropriate consequence, whether it’s coaching, probation, commission restructuring, or termination.

3. Own Up to Customers and Make It Right

If customers were sold unnecessary add-ons or services, they deserve honesty and remedies. Reach out individually to apologize. Offer refunds or replacements where appropriate. Most importantly, reassure them that corrective action is being taken to prevent future issues.

Transparency won’t erase the mistake, but it can rebuild trust and distinguish your business as one that holds itself accountable.

4. Reevaluate Sales Incentives

Commission structures that reward only high-ticket sales can breed short-term thinking and even unethical behavior. Consider revising your incentive model to reward:

  • Customer satisfaction scores
  • Repeat business or long-term retention
  • Cross-team collaboration and accuracy of recommendations

And keep this in mind: when integrity becomes as valuable as revenue, behavior tends to follow.

5. Retrain Your Team on Ethical Selling

Use the incident as a teachable moment. Host a company-wide refresher on values, ethical selling, and the long-term importance of customer trust. Reestablish that upselling is only acceptable when it genuinely enhances the customer’s experience.

Share real examples—an upsell gone wrong vs. an upsell that provided clear value—and encourage open dialogue.

6. Put Safeguards in Place

Preventative systems protect your business moving forward. These might include:

  • Customer feedback surveys triggered post-purchase
  • Sales audits conducted monthly or quarterly
  • Anonymous reporting channels for team members who witness ethical breaches

Even simple changes—like requiring managerial review for unusually high-value sales—can deter problematic behavior.

7. Reflect on Culture and Leadership

Deceptive sales tactics don’t exist in a vacuum. Consider whether your internal messaging emphasizes performance over people, or speed over service. Culture starts at the top—your values as a leader echo across your team.

If necessary, realign your messaging to prioritize relationships, integrity, and long-term growth over short-term spikes.

What We’ve Learned

Discovering dishonest behavior from your top salesperson is frustrating, especially when you thought they were setting the standard, not breaking it. But handled thoughtfully, this can be a turning point for your business: a chance to recommit to ethical practices, reinforce your values, and prove to customers that your company does the right thing even when it’s hard.

Your reputation isn’t built on being perfect. It’s built on how you respond when things go wrong.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, send us an email. You can also visit us at Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

How Business Owners Running on an Empty Tank can Refuel

Are you feeling run down and stressed out? Are you finding it hard to get motivated to work on your business? If so, you are not alone. Many business owners find themselves in this position at some point in their careers. However, just because you are feeling worn out doesn’t mean that you have to give up. There are things that you can do to re-energize yourself and get back on track. In this article, we will discuss some of the best tips for overcoming burnout and getting your energy back. Start by Lowering Street, Eating Senisbly One of the most important things that you can do to combat stress and fatigue is to control your stress levels. If you are constantly feeling overwhelmed, it is important to take some time for yourself and relax. There are many ways to do this, such as yoga, meditation, or simply taking a walk outside. Taking some time each day to de-stress will help you feel more refreshed and ready to work on your business. Burnout hurts. When you burn out at work, you feel diminished, like a part of yourself has gone into hiding. Challenges that were formerly manageable feel insurmountable. It’s the opposite end of the spectrum from engagement. The engaged entrepreneur is energized, involved, and high-performing; the burned-out entrepreneur is exhausted, cynical, and overwhelmed. —Harvard Business Review Another way to re-energize yourself is to make sure that you are eating light lunches. Heavy meals can make you feel sluggish and tired. Instead, focus on eating healthy foods that will give you sustained energy throughout the day. Fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and lean protein are all great options for an energy-boosting lunch. Effective Steps Burned-Out Business Owners can Re-Engergize In addition to reducing stress and eating light lunches, it is also important to drink plenty of water. Dehydration can lead to fatigue and make it difficult to focus. Make sure to drink water throughout the day to stay properly hydrated. But, these alone may not be enough. So, also do the following: Exercise. Exercise is another great way to combat stress and fatigue. Taking a brisk walk or going for a run can help you clear your head and boost your energy levels. Exercise releases endorphins, which have mood-enhancing properties. If you can, try to get in some exercise every day, even if it’s just a short walk around the block. Sleep better. Getting more restful sleep is also crucial for overcoming burnout. If you are not getting enough sleep, you will find it difficult to focus and get things done. Make sure to give yourself time to wind down before bed and create a relaxing environment in your bedroom. This will help you fall asleep more easily and get the restful sleep that you need. Take breaks. Finally, it is important to take regular breaks throughout the day. Working non-stop will only make you feel more stressed and tired. Instead, take a few minutes every hour or so to take a break. Stretch your legs, grab a cup of coffee, or simply step away from your desk for a few minutes. Taking breaks will help you stay refreshed and focused on your work. If you are feeling burned out, don’t despair. There are things that you can do to re-energize yourself and get back on track. By following these tips, you will be well on your way to feeling refreshed and ready to take on the world. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »

How New Entrepreneurs can Deal with People Who Don’t Take Them Seriously in Business

Financial expert and best-selling author Dave Ramsey occasionally tells a brief story about his road to success. Unsurprisingly, it involves an obstacle that he had to face and eventually overcome – his southern drawl or accent. When he started out in radio, he faced pushback from station managers in the north (particularly the northeast) who told him that their local audiences wouldn’t take him seriously because he had a southern accent. It was a cultural bias, but a real one, nonetheless. Folks up north just didn’t take him seriously. How New Entrepreneurs Can Deal with People Who Don’t Take Them Seriously in Business Entrepreneurship can be a difficult journey, and one of the biggest challenges that many entrepreneurs face is dealing with people who don’t take them seriously in the business world. Whether it’s investors, potential clients, or even friends and family, not being taken seriously can be demoralizing and discouraging. However, there are several strategies that entrepreneurs can use to overcome this obstacle and gain the respect they deserve. Develop a clear and compelling value proposition One of the most effective ways to gain credibility in the business world is to develop a clear and compelling value proposition. This means clearly articulating what your business does, why it matters, and what sets it apart from competitors. A strong value proposition can help you stand out from the crowd and demonstrate to others that you are serious about your business. Build a strong network Another way to gain credibility and overcome skepticism is to build a strong network of supporters and advocates. This includes mentors, advisors, investors, and other entrepreneurs who can vouch for your skills and expertise. A strong network can also provide valuable feedback and support as you navigate the ups and downs of entrepreneurship. Focus on results In the business world, results speak louder than words. By focusing on delivering results and achieving measurable goals, you can demonstrate your credibility and expertise. This may involve conducting market research, developing a minimum viable product, or securing initial customers. By showing that you can deliver on your promises, you can gain the trust and respect of others. Be confident and persistent Confidence and persistence are key traits for any successful entrepreneur. Even when faced with skepticism and criticism, it’s important to stay confident in your abilities and your business. This may involve practicing your pitch, seeking feedback, and developing a thick skin. Persistence is also important, as building a successful business often involves overcoming obstacles and setbacks. Stay focused on your vision Finally, it’s important to stay focused on your vision for your business. This may involve making tough decisions and taking risks, but ultimately it’s your vision that will guide you through the ups and downs of entrepreneurship. By staying true to your vision and working tirelessly to achieve your goals, you can overcome skepticism and build a successful business. All and all, dealing with people who don’t take you seriously in the business world can be challenging, but it’s not impossible – with the right attitude and tools, you can gain the respect and credibility you deserve as an entrepreneur. So, what other bits of advice would you add to these? Please, take a moment to comment with your own thoughts and experiences in order to benefit others! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Read More »

Why a Recession Spells O-p-p-o-r-t-u-n-i-t-y for Successful Entrepreneurs

As every savvy business owner knows, their company is not only subject to seasonality in at least some industries, but it can also be positively or negatively impacted by the overall national economic landscape and more particularly, the macroeconomy of their local community. So, there are cycles, or ups and downs, which more or less can be predicted. However, these factors don’t necessarily dictate every aspect of how they operate their businesses during good or bad times. Entrepreneurs still have quite a bit of say and it’s essential to understand that business owners are not totally helpless in uncertain times. The smartest and boldest entrepreneurs know and understand this, which is why they use recessionary periods to their advantage. One of the biggest debates in the business world really centers around individual personalities. In other words, two business owners in the same industry competing for the same consumer dollars might react in two totally different ways. When inflation spikes, interest rates go up, and consumers pull back their spending, one entrepreneur might also decide to pull back and scale down. This is not the time for inertia and despair or running around like the proverbial scaredy-cat. Instead of dwelling on the negatives as so many others do, realize that their preoccupation gives you a chance to one-up them. In fact, to be really contrarian about it, think of this catastrophe as a gift. The gift of challenges and opportunities. Challenges are what make business so exciting. Now’s the time to look for new, sustainable opportunities to grow your business and make it stronger. —Inc.com Meanwhile, the other business owner looks at this as an opportunity. Although consumers may be pulling back a bit, it doesn’t mean they can totally go without the goods and services they need. And, seeing that one of his chief competitors has decided to play it safe means there is a serious opportunity to be had for the bold entrepreneur. How Successful Entrepreneurs Turn a Recession into Opportunity Unfortunately, as stated above, this really depends on personality or more particularly mindset. Entrepreneurs who play it safe and try to ride out economic downturns will probably survive and even grow when things turn around. But, those people who played it safe might see a competitor grab up more market share because that rival decided to do the opposite. Here are some of the ways savvy business owners can take advantage of a recession: Increase advertising. The companies who continue to market their businesses aggressively will practically always reap the rewards and gain a return on investment. While others cut back on their advertising, entrepreneurs who are bolder and continue or increase their advertising put themselves in a stronger position in the marketplace. Buy out competition. This is something that happens regularly in certain professions, for instance, financial advisors. When one individual retires or a firm is winding down its operations, buying a book of business is quite common. Think about doing the same in your industry and how that could benefit your company in the long term. Streamline operations strategically. It’s not all just about going bigger, it’s also about being smart about how you’re running your business. Take some time to review your logistics and budget to see where you can streamline things to cut expenses while maximizing revenue. What other suggestions do you have? Please take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences so others can learn from you! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »