Business Education

When Your Best Salesperson Crosses the Line: How to Respond to Deceptive Upselling Without Losing Trust

Imagine this: you have a rockstar salesperson who brings in big business. You’re blown away by their performance and uncanny ability to persuade customers of add-ons or upsales, and it’s got you thinking seriously about bringing on another powerhouse who can rake in even more cash.

But then you begin to hear disturbing rumors among your staff, and before you know it, that very same scary scuttlebutt is validated by angry customer complaints; people who are furious that they’ve paid way more than necessary. Suddenly, you realize what’s been going on right under your nose, and you’re not prepared to deal with the stench.

7 Steps to Regain Trust When Salespeople Deceive Customers

For small business owners, a top-performing salesperson often feels like a blessing. They close deals, hit ambitious targets, and drive revenue. But what happens when that rainmaker turns rogue, intentionally upselling customers on products or services they don’t truly need, just to fatten their commission?

The fallout can be swift and damaging: customer complaints, lost trust, and potential reputational harm. If you’ve discovered this behavior within your business, don’t panic—but do act decisively.

1. Investigate Before You Accuse

As tempting as it is to react immediately, start by gathering facts. Review transaction records, customer complaints, and sales scripts or recordings (if available). Speak privately with a few affected customers to verify patterns.

You’ll need a clear understanding of whether this was a one-off lapse in judgment or a systemic issue driven by incentives, lack of oversight, or toxic sales culture.

2. Talk to the Salesperson—Candidly and Compassionately

Once you’ve reviewed the evidence, schedule a confidential conversation with the salesperson in question. Give them a chance to explain. Was this behavior driven by pressure to meet quotas? Did they misunderstand the product’s value?

While deception is never excusable, understanding motivations can help you decide the appropriate consequence, whether it’s coaching, probation, commission restructuring, or termination.

3. Own Up to Customers and Make It Right

If customers were sold unnecessary add-ons or services, they deserve honesty and remedies. Reach out individually to apologize. Offer refunds or replacements where appropriate. Most importantly, reassure them that corrective action is being taken to prevent future issues.

Transparency won’t erase the mistake, but it can rebuild trust and distinguish your business as one that holds itself accountable.

4. Reevaluate Sales Incentives

Commission structures that reward only high-ticket sales can breed short-term thinking and even unethical behavior. Consider revising your incentive model to reward:

Customer satisfaction scores
Repeat business or long-term retention
Cross-team collaboration and accuracy of recommendations

And keep this in mind: when integrity becomes as valuable as revenue, behavior tends to follow.

5. Retrain Your Team on Ethical Selling

Use the incident as a teachable moment. Host a company-wide refresher on values, ethical selling, and the long-term importance of customer trust. Reestablish that upselling is only acceptable when it genuinely enhances the customer’s experience.

Share real examples—an upsell gone wrong vs. an upsell that provided clear value—and encourage open dialogue.

6. Put Safeguards in Place

Preventative systems protect your business moving forward. These might include:

Customer feedback surveys triggered post-purchase
Sales audits conducted monthly or quarterly
Anonymous reporting channels for team members who witness ethical breaches

Even simple changes—like requiring managerial review for unusually high-value sales—can deter problematic behavior.

7. Reflect on Culture and Leadership

Deceptive sales tactics don’t exist in a vacuum. Consider whether your internal messaging emphasizes performance over people, or speed over service. Culture starts at the top—your values as a leader echo across your team.

If necessary, realign your messaging to prioritize relationships, integrity, and long-term growth over short-term spikes.

What We’ve Learned

Discovering dishonest behavior from your top salesperson is frustrating, especially when you thought they were setting the standard, not breaking it. But handled thoughtfully, this can be a turning point for your business: a chance to recommit to ethical practices, reinforce your values, and prove to customers that your company does the right thing even when it’s hard.

Your reputation isn’t built on being perfect. It’s built on how you respond when things go wrong.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, send us an email. You can also visit us at Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

Pros and Cons of Building a Mobile App for a Small Business

April 22, 2022 No Comments

Small businesses often struggle with the decision of whether or not to build a mobile app. On one hand, there are many advantages to having an app – it can help increase brand credibility, engage customers, provide a personalized experience, act as a direct marketing channel, and let businesses create a loyalty program. However, on the other hand, there are also several disadvantages to consider – such as the cost of developing and maintaining an app, complying with Apple and Google’s store security and performance policies, the phenomenon of consumer app fatigue, and lack of customer use. In this article, we will explore both sides of the argument so that you can make an informed decision about whether or not to develop an app for your small business. Biggest Advantages of Building a Mobile App for a Business Another advantage of having a mobile app is customer engagement. A study by Forrester found that 78% of smartphone users check their phone within 15 minutes of waking up, while 60% check their phone within 15 minutes of going to bed (Forrester, 2014). This constant connection gives businesses a unique opportunity to engage with their customers throughout the day. Creating a loyalty program or sending push notifications about sales and promotions can help increase customer engagement and keep your business top of mind. As consumers become increasingly connected with businesses on their smartphones and devices, many businesses develop mobile apps to connect with their customers. If your company is going the app route, you want to be sure it’s worth your time and money. While a mobile app can be an invaluable tool for many companies, certain company types may not necessarily need one. —Forbes.com Building a mobile app can also provide a more personalized experience for your customers. With an app, you can collect data about your customer’s usage patterns and preferences which can then be used to customize the experience for each individual. This is much harder to do with a website because there is less data available about how users interact with it. For example, if you own a clothing store, you could use the data collected from your app to show each user relevant products based on their previous purchases and browsing history. This personalized experience can help increase customer satisfaction and loyalty. Finally, having a mobile app gives businesses a direct marketing channel to reach their customers. With over 90% of Americans owning a cellphone (Pew Research Center, 2019), businesses have a unique opportunity to reach a large audience with targeted messages. You can use push notifications to send special offers and announcements directly to your customer’s phones. This is an effective way to increase sales and improve customer retention. Common Disadvantages of Building an App for a Business While there are many advantages to building a mobile app for your small business, there are also some disadvantages that you should be aware of before making the decision. One of the main disadvantages is cost. Developing and maintaining an app can be expensive, especially if you hire a professional company to do it for you. In addition, you will also need to pay Apple and Google a yearly fee to keep your app in their respective app stores. Another disadvantage of having a mobile app is that you have to comply with the security and performance policies of both Apple and Google. This can be difficult and time-consuming, especially if you are not familiar with the technical aspects of building an app. If your app does not meet these standards, it could be removed from the store which would damage your business’s reputation. Despite the disadvantages, there are still many advantages to building a mobile app for your small business. These include increased brand credibility, improved customer engagement, and a more personalized experience for your customers. In addition, an app can act as a direct marketing channel and provide you with valuable feedback about your products and services. If you do your research and assess the needs of your target market, you can decide if a mobile app is right for your small business. What are some other pros and cons of building a mobile app for a small business? Please take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your input! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

I Reopened My Business, but Now I’m Short-Staffed, What Do I Do?

February 9, 2021 No Comments

The COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent shutdowns affected different businesses in different ways. Some industries, like financial services, online retail, and even real estate, experienced growth. However, other industries suffered big losses, particularly hospitality, restaurants, and brick and mortar retailers; even some office environments experienced significant setbacks. Now, with plans to reopen and resume business as normal underway, some companies are faced with a labor shortage. Obviously, it’s difficult to service customers without the proper employee support. So, let’s look at some ways to shore up your business staff in short order. Employees are the Single-Most Valuable Business Asset Regardless of what industry your company serves, you’ve probably learned over the years — or have least heard — that employees are true assets to any business. Companies who do not treat their employees as assets suffer from high rates of turnover, low quality work, and often poor morale. Before you start evaluating candidates, ask yourself what traits you want to have in those employees to ensure you’re aligning your new hires with your business objectives. Some common traits that I’ve seen among hiring for eCommerce and physical retailers include flexibility, high energy, and fast learner —Business 2 Community Conversely, businesses that treat their employees as valued assets enjoy quality production, higher rates of production, a strong camaraderie and positive morale, and very low turnover. The reason isn’t a mystery — treat employees well and they will in turn do their best. Of course, that begs the question of how to bring on several people in a short amount of time that will make a good fit? How to Find Quality Employees on Short Notice In order to staff a business quickly, you need to first determine which roles to prioritize. And, know exactly what type of personalities best fit said roles. Here are three attitudes you must embrace to find the right staff in a pinch: Be patient. You probably already have existing employees taking on expansive responsibilities out of necessity. You should continue that practice but with a goal to reach. It’s better to rely on known qualities and compensate them well than to rush through the hiring process simply to fill positions. Start with previous employees to fill empty roles and give them more responsibilities for the short-term. Be flexible. Of course, you should streamline your hiring and training processes. But along with these changes, it’s also smart to think strategically. In other words, if a new hire isn’t working out in a particular role, move him or her into a different position instead of letting them go and having to go through the process all over again. Be confident. Sure, this might be a time of uncertainty. It’s unnerving, upsetting, and can be difficult to cope with. But, if you remain calm and show confidence, that will permeate through the company and help your employees greatly. What other attributes would you suggest business owners take on in order to get through a period of short staff? Please take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences by commenting so others can benefit from your unique perspective. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Best Ways to Manage Your Time and Energy

May 24, 2017 No Comments

Building a business isn’t easy and it requires a lot of time and energy to be successful. For the majority of entrepreneurs, challenges are met by putting in long hours and trying to be more productive. However, this leaves little time for family and friends, exercise, and hobbies. While it’s generally accepted as just part of the cost of doing business, eventually, a hectic schedule and overdrive pace will take its toll. This can lead to health issues, deteriorating relationships, and personal dissatisfaction. You might also come to despise your own creation and view it as a curse, rather than a blessing. Best Ways to Manage Your Time and Energy If your business is an energy drain, it will do more damage than just make you tired. It will also cause you to make decisions that aren’t necessary in your best interest or your employees’. You’ll probably begin to rationalize assigning certain responsibilities to different team members, it won’t necessary be for the good of the company, but rather, just to give you a break. That’s not a good practice and will lead to even more poor decisions. The core problem with working longer hours is that time is a finite resource. Energy is a different story. Defined in physics as the capacity to work, energy comes from four main wellsprings in human beings: the body, emotions, mind, and spirit. In each, energy can be systematically expanded and regularly renewed by establishing specific rituals—behaviors that are intentionally practiced and precisely scheduled, with the goal of making them unconscious and automatic as quickly as possible. —Harvard Business Review If you feel tired, unenthusiastic, and generally uninterested, it’s because this very phenomenon is happening to you, and, it’s time to realize its unhealthy impact and do something about it. Your energy, like your time, as the nearby quote states, is finite. Both must be managed in order for you to be productive and content. If you’re not productive and content, then, you’re sabotaging your own company, and doing your employees and customers a disservice. The best way to manage your energy is to manage your time and here are some ways you can improve your time management skills: Create useful lists. One reason people tire is they are hand-wringing over what needs to be done and that often wastes enough time to cause them to rush. When you write down a list, you have a clear, actionable plan. Prioritize your lists and entries to ensure that you have ample time for what’s most important. This might take some time to master, but, eventually, you’ll become more organized and discover how much time was wasted when you didn’t have lists to follow. Minimize company meetings. The not-so-subtle truth about meetings is nothing actually gets done. Okay, so you lay out a course of action, or, come-up with a strategy, but, you don’t execute during meetings — you execute after them. So, keep company meetings to a minimum to increase productivity. Take advantage of waiting times. You wait in traffic, you wait at the doctor’s office, you wait, you wait, you wait here and there. What’s more, you’re fully aware of the fact that waiting means time is being wasted. So, make it productive. These are great times to go over or create to-do lists, write out a grocery list, reply to email, make a phone call, the possibilities go on and on. Stop trying to multitask. There’s a persistent myth that multitasking is a way to get more done in less time. However, when you multitask, you’re asking your body, mind, and senses to do something that isn’t natural. It’s counterproductive and conducive to making mistakes. Instead, focus on one thing at a time to do it right. Delegate responsibilities. Delegating doesn’t have to be a four-letter word. It’s part of being a good leader and giving others the power to unleash their own potential. It’s also a great way to avoid multitasking and get more done. When you accomplish something, be sure to reward yourself. Do so in a healthy, upbeat way and without excess. You’ll find that you enjoy what you do more and be more optimistic about the future. As you transition into 2016, knowing you have a finite amount of time to achieve your goals with the energy you have, what will you do different to better manage your time so that you remain energized, productive and get results? Want to find out about what a business coach can do for you? [shareaholic app=”follow_buttons” id=”26833294″]