Punctuality vs. Performance: When Your Top Talent Routinely Shows Up Tardy

Very few things are as frustrating as a brilliant employee who consistently arrives late. They might be your team’s top performer, a “rock star” who delivers exceptional results and drives innovation. Yet, their chronic tardiness can erode team morale, breed resentment, and challenge the very core of your company culture. (Plus, it irritates you to no end and makes you question your authority.) What’s more, dealing with such an odd situation takes considerable forethought, though having a conversation must also be timely.

How to Handle a Chronically Late Rock Star Employee Without Killing Morale

When your star performer shows up late—again—and just as the phones are lighting up or a key delivery’s gone sideways, it’s more than frustrating. It’s a gut punch to consistency and team morale. But firing your most talented person might not be the smart play, and letting lateness slide sets a dangerous precedent. So what’s a small business owner to do?

Here’s how to keep your business running smoothly while managing this delicate dance.

Separate Performance From Behavior

First, acknowledge the truth: this employee delivers exceptional results. But chronic lateness isn’t a personality quirk—it’s a behavior that affects your bottom line. Be clear with yourself and the employee that performance and punctuality are two separate metrics.

Dig Into the Timing Pattern

Don’t just track that they’re late—track when and why. Are they consistently late on Monday mornings or during high-stress periods? Is something happening at home, or are they simply disorganized? A little pattern recognition can guide your response.

Consider asking: “I’ve noticed you’re often late right when things heat up—what’s happening around that time that’s throwing off your schedule?”

This invites honesty without confrontation.

Have a Candid (but Constructive) Conversation

Schedule a private sit-down. Skip the sarcasm and go for substance. Express appreciation for their contributions, but be firm about the impact of their lateness.

Start with something like this: “Your work is invaluable, but when you’re late—especially at crunch time—it disrupts the whole team. I want to find a solution that works for both of us.”

Keep the tone collaborative, not disciplinary—unless they’ve crossed into repeat-offender territory despite multiple warnings.

Offer Flexibility With Guardrails

Sometimes, flexibility works better than rigidity. If the employee’s best work happens midday, consider adjusting their hours—but make critical times non-negotiable.

For example: “You can start at 10 most days, but you must be here by 8:30 on delivery mornings. That’s a deal-breaker.”

This provides autonomy while emphasizing accountability.

Tie Punctuality to Advancement

If the employee has ambitions—more pay, leadership roles—link those directly to reliability.

Try explaining: “Being great at your job isn’t just about output. If you’re aiming to lead, people need to trust you’ll show up when it counts.”

It reframes punctuality as a leadership quality, not a chore.

Set Team-Wide Expectations

Even if this employee is your superstar, the rest of your crew is watching. Make sure your attendance policies are clear and consistently applied, while still allowing for individual nuances.

Otherwise, you risk resentment, whispers, and a gradual erosion of trust.

Final Thought

Dealing with a rock star who has a chronically late rhythm isn’t easy, but neither is finding someone with their spark. If they’re willing to grow, and you’re eager to guide, the payoff can be a win-win for everyone.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, send us an email. You can also visit us at Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

Signs an Employee is Not Actually Ready for a Promotion

Promoting an employee is a big decision, and it’s important to make sure that the person you’re promoting is actually ready for the next level. Fortunately, there are a number of signs that can indicate that an employee is not yet ready for a promotion, even if they’re doing a good job in their current role. Signs an Employee is Not Actually Ready for a Promotion Promotions are an essential part of career growth and employee development within any organization. They serve as recognition for hard work, dedication, and competency in one’s current role. However, not all employees are ready to take a step up, despite their desire for advancement. As an employer, it is crucial to assess each team member carefully to ensure that they are adequately prepared for the increased responsibilities and challenges that come with a higher position. Here are some of the most common signs that an employee is not ready for a promotion: They’re not consistently meeting performance expectations. This is probably the most obvious sign that someone is not ready for a promotion. If they’re not consistently meeting the expectations of their current role, they’re not likely to be successful in a more senior role. They’re not taking on new challenges. If an employee is content to stay in their comfort zone and not take on new challenges, they’re not likely to be ready for a promotion. A promotion means taking on more responsibility and facing new challenges, and if an employee is not up for that, they’re not ready for an upward move. They have difficulty acting as a team player. A promotion often means having more responsibility for managing and motivating other people. If an employee is not a solid team player and doesn’t have the skills to motivate and lead others, they’re not ready for a promotion. They’re not eager to learn new things. The world of work is constantly changing, and in order to be successful, employees need to be willing to learn new things. If an employee is not excited to learn new things, they’re not likely to be successful in a more senior role. They’re not able to handle stress well. Senior roles often come with more stress and responsibility. If an employee is not able to handle stress well, they’re not likely to be successful in a more senior role. If you see any of these signs in an employee, it’s important to have a conversation with them about their readiness for a promotion. Explain to them what you’re seeing and why you don’t think they’re ready for a promotion yet. Help them identify what they need to do to improve their skills and knowledge so that they can be successful in a more senior role. Other Considerations Business Owners Need to Take into Account It’s also important to remember that not everyone is cut out for management. Some people are perfectly happy to stay in their current role and not have more responsibility. If that’s the case, there’s no need to force them into a promotion that they’re not ready for. Promotion is a great way to recognize and reward employees for their hard work. However, it’s important to make sure that the person you’re promoting is really ready to climb up the ladder. By looking for the signs listed above, you can help ensure that your promotions are successful. Now, here are some additional tips for identifying employees who are not yet ready for a promotion: Pay attention to their performance reviews. If an employee has consistently received negative reviews, they’re probably not ready for a promotion. Talk to their manager. Their manager will be able to give you a good sense of their overall performance and whether they’re ready for a promotion. Observe them in action. Pay attention to how they interact with their colleagues, how they handle stress, and how they take on new challenges. Promoting an employee prematurely can be detrimental to both the individual and the organization. Employers must carefully assess each team member’s readiness for a promotion by looking for signs of technical proficiency, effective time management, initiative, teamwork, and the ability to handle current responsibilities. By offering support, training, and guidance to employees who exhibit potential, employers can better prepare them for future roles and foster a more successful and motivated workforce. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Read More »

What to Do When Your PPP Money Runs Out

What do businesses do when their PPP or Payroll Protection Program funds run out? While small companies can apply and receive relief, that money is only finite. It will go just so far before it’s gone. And, once it’s gone, it’s gone for good. Even organizations with business interruption insurance benefits have limited resources. Eventually, the cash will run out. So, what do small businesses do then? PPP Loan Forgiveness Only Solves One Problem It’s important to remember that PPP loan forgiveness — while most certainly helpful — merely solves one problem. Meaning, there are still other debts and obligations to pay and to meet. That alone reveals the fact there’s a lot more to doing business than just compensating employees. Vendors, contractors, and others also need to be paid. The Paycheck Protection Program is a loan designed to provide a direct incentive for small businesses to keep their workers on the payroll. SBA will forgive loans if all employees are kept on the payroll for eight weeks and the money is used for payroll, rent, mortgage interest, or utilities. —U.S. Small Business Administration This gets to the heart of the larger issue — the inescapable reality of the business world. Put another way, if someone paid off one of your personal debts and you had five, six, or ten more, while that’s a blessing and it’s appreciated, it does not get you totally out of debt. Businesses don’t operate that way because there’s always additional obligations. What to Do When Your PPP Money Runs Out Since businesses stay in a cycle of dynamics, with revolving credit and monthly bills, and they apply and receive PPP money, what can they do once those funds are gone? Here are a few suggestions that might prove helpful to your business: Offer invoice financing. Instead of requesting (or demanding) the entire invoice amount to be paid, give them the option to finance their outstanding balances. You can charge a small fee and/or interest rate — so long that it’s legal and ethical. Ask suppliers for extensions. For businesses that owe other businesses money, it’s worth a shot to ask for some more time or at least try to establish payment arrangements. This will help to take off a little pressure and to free up some cash. Review personnel staffing choices. Most businesses already have or will soon, be forced into this scenario — assessing which team members aren’t essential. It’s a tough spot but because employees most always represent the largest expense, this can’t be ignored. Consider liquidation or selling equipment. Another thing you can do is to sell off non-essential equipment, if available. Or, liquidate some inventory or materials. These are all difficult decisions but they could mean the difference between staying in business and going out of business permanently. Offer new services that are in demand now. Look at what services are in demand now that may be in line with your service offerings or a close extension thereof to provide immediate cash flow. Quickly shift to provide those services by promoting them to your current customer base and use social media to get the word out. Several industries and businesses have done this in recent weeks. What other suggestions do you have? Please share your thoughts and experiences by commenting! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »

Employees are Quitting Instead of Returning to Work and That’s a Good Thing — Here’s Why

Leading news organizations continue to report a substantial number of employees are quitting their jobs rather than returning to work. The headlines are stark and alarming. They are also good news. Yes, it’s actually not cause for alarm. Instead, it’s a blessing in disguise, a silver lining to a cloud. Read on to learn why. Quitters Never Win? It’s a cliche, “Winners never quit and quitters never win.” But, we all know there are certainly exceptions. Put another way, sometimes quitting is the right choice, the best option, for an employee. Moving on and into something new can prove extraordinarily fortunate and fulfilling. However, it can also reveal qualities that aren’t net positives for businesses. After spending more than a year at home, some don’t want to go back to commuting, preferring the flexibility of remote work at least a few days a week. Others are simply burned out from logging long hours while also balancing child care and remote school, sometimes all at once. And nearly all employees are ready to see what else is out there. —CNBC Practically anyone who chooses to walk away and be part of what’s currently referred to as the “Great Resignation” is doing so for almost entirely personal reasons. And, that could very well point to a deficiency not previously exposed to co-workers, administrators, and owners. This of course being, unwanted characteristics, such as laziness, lack of passion or even interest, and just showing up for a paycheck. All of those are things a business can really do without. 3 Top Employee Qualities On the other side of the equation is the qualities that are the most beneficial to businesses. Companies should always look beyond resumes and take full advantage of the interview process (perhaps even going so far as to an informal interview over lunch or dinner). Here are some of the top qualities good employees naturally exhibit: Strong work ethic. Someone with a strong work ethic will obviously be productive. But also, concerned about the quality of work he or she is producing. But, be careful not to mistake a workaholic or the extreme statistics of the Japanese “karoshi,” people who literally die as a result of overworking. Strong work ethic isn’t the same and will offer a much more well-adjusted person to your team. Enthusiasm for the job. An enthusiastic individual is quite fortunately fairly easy to spot and even more thankfully, easy to distinguish from a phony or fake. (Phonies and fakes often exhibit many telltale signs they are just not genuine.) These people usually speak with zeal and great pleasure about their work. What’s more, will also talk about their work in a very focused yet informal and understandable manner. Team cooperation and collaboration. Place this quality in the “obvious” column, but one that’s definitely worth including. A person who is a true team player tends to be an individual who loves to listen to the input and perspective of others. Also, someone who can follow instructions without a bad or negative attitude, but can just as easily step into a leadership role, yet relinquish control for the good of the company. What other suggestions do you have? Please take a brief moment to share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your unique perspective! You might just help out someone in a profound way. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »