Business Education

Punctuality vs. Performance: When Your Top Talent Routinely Shows Up Tardy

Very few things are as frustrating as a brilliant employee who consistently arrives late. They might be your team’s top performer, a “rock star” who delivers exceptional results and drives innovation. Yet, their chronic tardiness can erode team morale, breed resentment, and challenge the very core of your company culture. (Plus, it irritates you to no end and makes you question your authority.) What’s more, dealing with such an odd situation takes considerable forethought, though having a conversation must also be timely.

How to Handle a Chronically Late Rock Star Employee Without Killing Morale

When your star performer shows up late—again—and just as the phones are lighting up or a key delivery’s gone sideways, it’s more than frustrating. It’s a gut punch to consistency and team morale. But firing your most talented person might not be the smart play, and letting lateness slide sets a dangerous precedent. So what’s a small business owner to do?

Here’s how to keep your business running smoothly while managing this delicate dance.

Separate Performance From Behavior

First, acknowledge the truth: this employee delivers exceptional results. But chronic lateness isn’t a personality quirk—it’s a behavior that affects your bottom line. Be clear with yourself and the employee that performance and punctuality are two separate metrics.

Dig Into the Timing Pattern

Don’t just track that they’re late—track when and why. Are they consistently late on Monday mornings or during high-stress periods? Is something happening at home, or are they simply disorganized? A little pattern recognition can guide your response.

Consider asking: “I’ve noticed you’re often late right when things heat up—what’s happening around that time that’s throwing off your schedule?”

This invites honesty without confrontation.

Have a Candid (but Constructive) Conversation

Schedule a private sit-down. Skip the sarcasm and go for substance. Express appreciation for their contributions, but be firm about the impact of their lateness.

Start with something like this: “Your work is invaluable, but when you’re late—especially at crunch time—it disrupts the whole team. I want to find a solution that works for both of us.”

Keep the tone collaborative, not disciplinary—unless they’ve crossed into repeat-offender territory despite multiple warnings.

Offer Flexibility With Guardrails

Sometimes, flexibility works better than rigidity. If the employee’s best work happens midday, consider adjusting their hours—but make critical times non-negotiable.

For example: “You can start at 10 most days, but you must be here by 8:30 on delivery mornings. That’s a deal-breaker.”

This provides autonomy while emphasizing accountability.

Tie Punctuality to Advancement

If the employee has ambitions—more pay, leadership roles—link those directly to reliability.

Try explaining: “Being great at your job isn’t just about output. If you’re aiming to lead, people need to trust you’ll show up when it counts.”

It reframes punctuality as a leadership quality, not a chore.

Set Team-Wide Expectations

Even if this employee is your superstar, the rest of your crew is watching. Make sure your attendance policies are clear and consistently applied, while still allowing for individual nuances.

Otherwise, you risk resentment, whispers, and a gradual erosion of trust.

Final Thought

Dealing with a rock star who has a chronically late rhythm isn’t easy, but neither is finding someone with their spark. If they’re willing to grow, and you’re eager to guide, the payoff can be a win-win for everyone.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, send us an email. You can also visit us at Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

Most Tactful Strategies for Pushing Customer Deadlines Back without Upsetting Them

May 31, 2022 No Comments

As a business owner, you know that sometimes things come up that prevent you from meeting a customer deadline. Maybe there was an unexpected delay in getting the product or service finished, or maybe your team just got swamped with work. Whatever the reason, pushing back a customer deadline can be tricky business. You don’t want to upset them and lose their business, but you also don’t want them to feel like they’re being ignored or getting something that appears rushed. So, let’s discuss some of the most tactful ways to push back deadlines without upsetting your customers. Best Ways to Push Back Client Deadlines and Still Make Customers Happy One way to push back a deadline without upsetting your customer is to provide them with regular updates. Let them know what’s going on and why the deadline can’t be met. Customers appreciate transparency, and they’ll be more understanding if they know what’s going on. You should keep lines of communication open and stay in touch regularly. Don’t make the mistake of updating your client once and then going silent – it will only cause more problems. Missing a deadline is something that happens even to the best of us. Whether you got sick and couldn’t finish your tasks on time or the project took you much longer than expected, one thing is clear – you’re about to miss the deadline and need to communicate it to the client. —Simone Smith on Brain Leaf Another way to push back a deadline without upsetting your customer is to offer them a discount or some other type of compensation. This shows that you value their business and that you’re willing to go the extra mile to make up for any inconvenience. This doesn’t have to be a deep price reduction, but enough to show him or her you’re aware of their time and budget and are appreciative of their patience. Finally, one of the best ways to retain customers even when deadlines can’t be met is to provide excellent customer service. Be responsive, friendly, and helpful, and try to resolve any issues as quickly as possible. If you make an effort to take care of your customers, they’ll be more likely to stick with you even when things don’t go according to plan. Pushing back customer deadlines can be a delicate process, but if you handle it tactfully, you can retain your customers and keep them happy. By following these tips, you’ll be able to push back deadlines without upsetting your clients. It is of utmost importance to be honest with your customers, be upfront as soon as the situation changes, and be willing to accept some criticism. If you handle the circumstances with professionalism and tactfully, they’ll be far more willing to accommodate you and will greatly appreciate your candor. What other suggestions would you make about dealing with pushing client deadlines back without angering them? Please, take a moment to share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your perspective! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

How to Know when It’s Time to Walk Away from a Business

July 19, 2018 No Comments

Walking away from a business is always a tough decision. Even if it’s a much-needed cathartic relief, there’s still the matter of the unknown as to what comes next. Regardless of circumstances, you should know that it’s ultimately the right decision. That’s not always an easy thing to do because it’s human nature to second-guess or to look back with 20/20 hindsight. If you’re thinking about walking away, that notion certainly doesn’t come out of nowhere. There is something driving it and you need to understand when it’s no longer worth your time and effort. Walking Away from a Business doesn’t necessarily Mean Shutting It Down Let’s begin with the fact that it’s not always a bad situation. There are definitely times when the right move is to move on to something new. For example, you’ve set a goal and now have realized it. So, go out on top and start something new. Or, if you’ve always wanted to try this or that and the company you’re running now is humming along, then go for it. In business, it’s important to understand the difference between bad luck and bad judgement. Misfortune will often masquerade as a mistake, and has caused many talented people to walk away from their business ventures prematurely. Getting a startup past the first year is commonly regarded as the biggest challenge to any entrepreneur. Sometimes hitting a bump in the road is just that and the best approach is to weather the storm, keep calm and carry on. But how do you know if your business still has a future and how do you turn around the fortunes of your struggling enterprise? —The Guardian The point is, there are times when it’s perfectly fine to walk away from a business without having to close the doors. You can hand over the company to a protegé, or pass it on to your children. It’s healthy to build something up, watch it grow, and then enjoy the fruits of your labor. Signs It’s Time to Walk Away from a Business Now, it’s not always the case that you succeed. And, failure does come in many forms. You just need to know when it’s time to throw in the towel. Now, not all are as obvious as a natural disaster, but, there are some which do mean it’s no longer worth the fight: It’s consistently busy but unprofitable. This is perhaps the most perplexing circumstance but it does happen. Some businesses have enough or more than enough business, yet they simply can’t realize a profit. If you’ve already reduced your operating expenses and if customers/clients will not pay more for your services or product, and you still can’t produce a profit, staying open is just an exercise in futility. Key employees keep leaving. You might well be profitable but only marginally. What’s worse is that you can’t seem to keep the best talent. This is a sign there’s something serious going awry and if you can’t identify it, it might just be time to walk away. There’s no clear path forward. If you can’t seem to envision the future clearly, there’s definitely a reason why. And, without a clear path ahead, you’re essentially walking blindfolded, which can easily lead to a bad set of inescapable circumstances. Do you have an accurate picture on your backorders or pipeline of prospective business that is required to meet your sales to produce a profit? Customers have mixed experiences. Another sign it’s time to move on is inconsistent feedback. You hear good and bad without any obvious reason. If you can’t get to the bottom of it, you’ll never make it work right. What other signs tell you it’s time to go? Please share your thoughts and experiences by commenting! Interested in learning more about why your business isn’t performing? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Should You Scale or Scuttle Your Startup

May 16, 2017 No Comments

When business begins to slow, your sense of confidence can slide, and it’s a scary sensation that usually follows. Facing the possibility of having to close the doors isn’t a pleasant one, and, you could feel like a complete failure. Before you begin to pack-up your office, take some time to look at the situation objectively. Ask yourself what’s the most likely cause and begin to take steps to solve rather than scuttle. If you are experiencing a steady slide in sales, there’s obviously a reason why that’s so. The good news is, there are always options, which can range from scaling out, scaling down, or, shutting down. The latter might not be the most welcome, but, sometimes it’s the best option, providing you with an opportunity to try something else. How to Solve the Scale or Scuttle Situation Should you be facing a mountain of bills, not seeing a jump in revenue, and having to cut back where you’ve never cut before, it certainly can be frightening and frustrating. The first place to begin is with yourself, your emotions, dreams, and, mental state. If you’re in a situation that simply taxes you too much and drains your energy, you ought to consider closing and starting fresh with something new. However, if you believe you can turn things around, you should seriously consider scaling down or out. …you’re stressed out, your relationships are fraying and your resolve is destroyed. Nevertheless,you must take action in order to end the turbulence with as much poise as possible. You can’t change the past, but you can certainly determine how you [proceed]. —Entrepreneur.com Scaling down is obviously taking measures to reduce your business workload to concentrate on key accounts. Scaling out isn’t the same as going up, it’s more lateral, providing more of what you already do, not offering new things. If you’re still wondering which way to go, take the following into consideration to make an informed, well-thought decision: Look at your workable options. One mistake some failing businesses make is to hammer a square peg into a circle, meaning they attempt to go beyond their core competencies, and, that’s just not a good idea. You’ll nearly inevitably see this backfire and make things go from bad to worse. Be prepared to stunt growth. Some businesses falter, not because of the lack of revenue, but because they take on too much. Should you and your team be stretched thin, it’s time to scale back and produce the best you can deliver. What you’ll find is more happy customers, co-workers, and self contentment. Get some unbiased advice. An outside view by an experienced business consultant can shed a lot of light on problems you didn’t even realize existed. Have your business evaluated and get some helpful advice that isn’t tainted by being too close or too attached. Know your company’s limits, and, its potential. Here again, if your company can’t comfortably keep pace with demand, it’s time to pull back and deliver quality over quantity. Should you be experiencing a spike, consider your business’ potential and grow incrementally. Understand your cash position. Having less cash isn’t necessarily or always a bad thing. It causes you to look at and prioritize expenses, weeding out what’s not needed. You’ll find creativity if you don’t succumb to fear. Another factor you’ll have to face is the emotional adjustment. We’re told all our lives that quitters never win and winners never quit, but, that goes against reality. Be willing to make an emotional adjustment and deal with the reality. [shareaholic app=”follow_buttons” id=”26833294″]