Business Education

You Promoted Your Star Employee. Now They’re Struggling. Don’t Panic—Read This

Almost nothing can cut an entrepreneur deeper than misjudging the aptitude of a long-time employee. It’s an almost unbelievable and unbearable situation: giving a strong team member a shot at management only to learn the individual isn’t up to performing on the next level. Such a circumstance surely prompts a business owner to question their own instincts. Aside from the shock is what to do to resolve the problem.

Navigating the Promotion Pitfall: What Small Business Owners Can Do When a Star Employee Struggles in a New Role

Promoting a top-performing employee is one of the most rewarding decisions a small business owner can make. It recognizes hard work, boosts morale, and fills key positions internally. However, what happens when that promotion doesn’t pan out?

The employee, once a standout in their previous role, now falters under the demands of greater responsibility—a classic case of the Peter Principle in action. For small businesses, where every team member counts, this scenario can disrupt operations and strain relationships. The good news? There are proactive, compassionate strategies to address it without losing valuable talent.

1. Assess the Situation Objectively

Before taking action, step back and assess the situation. Is the issue skill-based (e.g., lacking managerial experience) or something else, like burnout or mismatched expectations? Schedule a candid, private conversation with the employee to discuss their challenges. Utilize tools such as performance reviews or 360-degree feedback from peers to gather valuable insights. In a small business, this personal touch can reveal if the promotion was premature or if external factors are at play. Remember, admitting a misstep early prevents bigger problems down the line.

2. Invest in Training and Support

Often, the employee just needs a bridge to success. Offer targeted training, such as leadership workshops, online courses, or mentorship from you or an external coach. Pair them with a seasoned colleague for shadowing, or implement a performance improvement plan (PIP) with clear, measurable goals and timelines—say, 30-60 days. This approach shows commitment to their growth and can turn things around. For cash-strapped small businesses, free resources like SCORE mentoring or LinkedIn Learning can be game-changers.

3. Consider a Graceful Demotion or Lateral Move

If training doesn’t yield results, demotion might be necessary, but frame it as a “role realignment” to preserve dignity. Explain how returning to their strengths benefits the company and them—perhaps with a title like “senior specialist” to maintain status. Alternatively, explore lateral moves to roles that leverage their skills without the added pressure. In small teams, this flexibility can help maintain high morale and retain institutional knowledge. Always document discussions to protect against potential legal issues, and consider offering incentives, such as a bonus, to ease the transition.

4. Foster a Culture of Open Communication and Learning

Prevent future pitfalls by building a promotion process that includes trial periods or assessments. Encourage employees to voice concerns about readiness for advancement. As a small business owner, lead by example: Share stories of your own career hiccups to normalize setbacks. This creates a resilient team where promotions are seen as opportunities, not traps.

Ultimately, handling a failed promotion thoughtfully can ultimately strengthen your business. It demonstrates empathy, fairness, and strategic thinking—qualities that attract and retain top talent. By viewing it as a learning experience, you’ll not only salvage a great employee but also refine your leadership for long-term success.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

If You’re Hiring Based on Skills, You’re Hiring Wrong — Here’s Why

March 2, 2022 No Comments

There’s an internet meme going around that makes a profound point, “Hire based on attitude, not skills — because you can always teach skills.” And, it backs up some very interesting statistics. For instance, did you know that 85% of a company’s success is due to the team’s attitude, and only 15% is due to individual skills? That’s why when businesses are looking to hire new employees, they should focus on finding individuals with the right attitude, not just those who have the perfect skill set. So, let’s expound a bit as to why. Attitude vs. Skill When it comes to hiring new employees, many businesses focus on finding candidates with the appropriate skills for the job. However, in order to create a successful and productive team, it’s important to also consider attitude. A positive attitude is essential for maintaining a positive work environment and achieving company goals. Is it better to have someone in a team lead role who has a strong work ethic and is all-around positive and can learn the skills or is it better to hire someone based on skills only? What is most important — the skill set or the attitude and growth potential? It depends on the job. There are some jobs where it might make sense to hire for attitude and teach the work itself when it won’t require a major investment of time to do so. There are other jobs where experience and a pre-existing skill set are essential. —Inc.com Therefore, businesses should focus on hiring people who have the right attitude, even if they may not have all the necessary skills. With the right attitude in place, employees can be taught the required skills over time. This makes sense, especially when looking at first-time job seekers in entry-level positions. Those individuals often have little to no skills at all. Those are taught through direct instruction and experience. The Advantages of Hiring Based on Attitude Rather than Skills There is no question that skills are a critical component of any employee’s toolkit. However, research has shown that an individual’s attitude is a stronger predictor of success than their skills. In order to capitalize on this, businesses should consider hiring based on attitude rather than skills due to the following reasons: Longevity. Hiring based on attitude will help you find candidates who are motivated and passionate about their work. These are the employees who will go above and beyond for your company. They will be more engaged in their work, and they will be less likely to leave their positions. Synergy. Hiring based on attitude will help you find candidates who are a good fit for your company culture. This is extremely important, as it can save you time and money in the long run. If a candidate is not a good fit for your company culture, they will likely be unhappy and unproductive in their position. Flexibility. Hiring based on attitude will help you find candidates who are able to adapt to change. When a company hires based on skillset, they may hire someone who has very specific knowledge and experience in their field. But this person might not be able to adapt when things change in the future. What other benefits are gained by hiring based on attitude instead of on skillset? Please take a moment to comment and share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your perspective! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

The Trump Kim Jong Un Summit and Its Most Valuable Lesson

March 13, 2019 No Comments

The world paid close attention to the summit between President Trump and Kim Jong Un. Regardless of its ultimate outcome, there’s a lesson going on every entrepreneur should learn. Namely, how to avoid snakes in business. The Fable of the Scorpion and the Frog They come by different names: charlatans, cheats, hustlers, swindlers, and more. For those who’ve not heard it, the fable of the scorpion and the frog weaves a short, cautionary tale. A scorpion needs to cross a river and asks a frog for a lift. The frog objects, saying the scorpion will sting and kill him. Regardless of their specific methods, con artists typically depend on their abilities to charm, intimidate, and rapidly spin convincing lies. More often than not, con artists are successful because well-meaning staff members accidentally provide crucial information in an attempt to assist them. Ultimately, the best way to protect your business from con artists is to make your team aware that they exist. CEOs and their team members should be constantly vigilant about what they share and with whom. —Forbes.com But, the scorpion points out, if he were to sting the frog, both would drown in the river. The frog reluctantly agrees and midway, the scorpion stings him. The frog asks why and the scorpion replies, “It’s my nature, I’m a scorpion.” How to Avoid Con Artists to Protect Your Business Now, con men cleverly disguise their true natures. They conceal their actual motives and that’s what makes them so difficult to spot. But, there are usually at least one or two (even more) warning signs. Here are a few ways to avoid con artists to protect your business: Listen to your gut. Con men know how to read people — it’s a necessary trait. So, they are careful to convince. Which means, it’s not easy to spot the scheme straight away. But, your gut feeling might be all you need to avoid becoming a victim. Put things into perspective. This is another way of saying, “If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.” In other words, if you hear something that seems to be too good, put it into perspective. More particularly, place it up against reality. If it’s like trying to hammer a square peg into a round hole, you have your answer. Don’t hesitate to ask around. Shysters need to move on and move quickly before word spreads. While it might not be comfortable, ask around. Do a little digging if you get a funny feeling to see if others had a bad experience. It’s worth your time and effort in the long run. Trust but verify. Along the same lines is to verify. Check out what they’re selling to learn if it’s genuine or just a hustle. With a small amount of sleuthing, you can save yourself a lot of grief. How do you spot charlatans? What additional advice would you give others about avoiding con artists? Please share your thoughts and experiences by commenting! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

3 Vital Steps to Stop Procrastinating

July 31, 2018 No Comments

Procrastination. It’s an ugly word. And, it plagues too many people. Procrastination is a very common phenomenon but it’s not necessarily a straightforward personality trait. Sure, there are serial procrastinators who put things off time and time again. But, even people who practice good daily habits can fall into the procrastination trap. It’s a bad thing because it causes you to rush and do something at the last-minute. Or, it can bite you because you put it on hold too long and now, it’s too late. Top Reasons Why People Procrastinate The truth is, people procrastinate for a variety of reasons. Sure, laziness is one reason but it’s certainly not the only culprit. It turns out fear is one of the most common causes. Either fear of failure or fear of success. Another reason is due to perfectionism. When you stop to think about this cause, it makes perfect sense. Then, there’s the matter of excitement or fulfillment. If it’s boring, it’s simply unattractive. With distractions at an arm’s reach at all times these days, it’s all too easy to find reasons to procrastinate. Don’t waste another second making excuses for the things you have to do. We put things off when there is something more challenging at hand. Instead of rising to the challenge and completing the task we have to do, we find smaller, insignificant activities to fill our time–telling ourselves that we’re getting something done. —Inc.com A lack of focus can also cause someone to put stuff off. Or, just low energy. Feeling like there’s no fuel in the tank is a big demotivator. Basically, the most common reasons for procrastination are negative feelings. Which means you can overcome the urge when it strikes. 3 Vital Steps to Stop Procrastinating There’s always something on our table we just do not want to do. It could be anything. The common thread is a form of fear or dread. This builds up the more it’s thought about, until it becomes overwhelming. And, while it nags in the distance, it’s common to indulge in busy work to keep it at bay. But, it doesn’t have to get the best of you. Here are three vital steps for overcoming procrastination: Put the hardest thing first. Eat your vegetables. It’s one of the single best ways to ward off procrastination. When you do the hardest or least appealing work first, you get it out-of-the-way. And, you can then move onto something more enjoyable. Break it up into small steps. Not every task or project can realistically be completed in one day. If this is the case, do it first but don’t do it all at once. Instead, do it incrementally over a given period. This way, you’ll see progress and have less and less to complete as you go along. Create a realistic, actionable schedule. To beat the urge to procrastinate, you need to go by a realistic, actionable schedule. One that you can follow and tick off the accomplishments, one by one. Have you beat procrastination? What other strategies would you suggest using? Please share your experiences and thoughts on how to tackle procrastination. Interested in learning more about business productivity? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.