Why Small Business Owners Should Start Asking Employees Why They Stay Instead of Why They’re Leaving

Exit interviews have been part of corporate America since the 1950s, but gained widespread adoption in the late 1980s, exploding in popularity in the 1990s. Fast forward to 2021 and 2022, another tool was introduced and is steadily gaining adoption, and it’s known as the “stay interview.” Like many other tactics used by big businesses, these trickle down and are used by small organizations. So, what is a stay interview and why should small businesses start using them?

Retaining Talent Through Stay Interviews

Employee turnover can feel like a constant drain on resources and morale. You’ve poured time into hiring and training, only to watch good people walk out the door. Exit interviews might reveal why they’re leaving, but by then, it’s too late. Enter stay interviews—a proactive tool to uncover issues before they escalate. As a small business owner, implementing these conversations can help you retain top talent and reduce those regrettable departures. Let’s explore how to set them up and conduct them effectively.

Understanding Stay Interviews

Stay interviews are informal discussions with current employees to gauge their satisfaction and identify potential flight risks. Unlike performance reviews, which focus on past achievements, or exit interviews, which happen post-resignation, stay interviews look forward. They ask what keeps someone engaged and what might prompt them to leave.

The beauty lies in their simplicity. Conducted one-on-one, they build trust and show you value input. Research from organizations like Gallup indicates that employees who feel heard are 4.6 times more likely to perform their best work. For small businesses, where every team member counts, this can translate to higher productivity and lower recruitment costs—often thousands per hire avoided.

Preparing for Success

Start by selecting participants thoughtfully. In a small team, aim to interview everyone annually, or more frequently for key roles. Schedule during quieter periods to avoid adding stress. Prepare a list of open-ended questions, but keep it flexible—about five to seven is ideal to fit into 30 minutes.

Common questions include things like,” What do you enjoy most about your role?” “What frustrates you?” How can we support your growth?” “What would make you consider leaving?” Tailor them to your business; for a retail shop, ask about customer interactions, while a tech firm might probe work-life balance.

Train yourself or managers on active listening. Avoid defensiveness; the goal is insight, not debate. Assure confidentiality to encourage honesty—employees won’t open up if they fear repercussions.

Conducting the Interview

Set a relaxed tone. Meet in a neutral space, like a coffee shop or virtual call, away from the office buzz. Begin with appreciation: “I value your contributions and want to ensure you’re thriving here.” This sets a positive foundation.

Listen more than you speak—aim for an 80/20 ratio. Take subtle notes, focusing on themes such as workload, recognition, or culture. Probe gently. If they mention dissatisfaction with processes, ask for specifics without interrupting.

End on action. Summarize key points and commit to follow-up. “I’ll look into that training opportunity and get back to you next week.” This demonstrates responsiveness and builds loyalty.

Following Through and Measuring Impact

The real power comes post-interview. Compile feedback anonymously if needed and spot patterns across the team. Prioritize quick wins, like flexible hours, then tackle bigger issues, such as career paths.

Track metrics. Monitor turnover rates before and after implementing stay interviews. Survey satisfaction quarterly. If departures drop and engagement rises, you’re on track. Remember, consistency matters. Make stay interviews a cultural staple, not a one-off. In small businesses, where owners wear many hats, this investment pays dividends—fewer exits mean a stronger, more cohesive team ready to drive growth.

By shifting from reactive exits to proactive stays, you’ll foster a workplace where people choose to remain. It’s not just about retention; it’s about building a thriving business. Start with one interview this week—you might be surprised at what you learn.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

Biggest Pros and Cons of Employee Monitoring Systems Small Business Owners Should Know About

Biggest Pros and Cons of Employee Monitoring Systems Small Business Owners Should Know About Small business owners are constantly looking for ways to improve productivity, streamline operations, and ensure a safe working environment for their employees. One solution that has gained popularity in recent years is the use of employee monitoring systems. Employee monitoring tools can provide valuable insights into team member performance and help companies to better manage their workforce. However, there are also potential drawbacks to consider. So, it’s important to know the advantages and disadvantages of such technology. Below, we’ll explore the biggest pros and cons of employee monitoring systems for small business owners. Pros of Employee Monitoring Systems Increased productivity. One of the most significant advantages of employee monitoring systems is their ability to improve productivity. By tracking employee activity and identifying inefficiencies, small business owners can make data-driven decisions to optimize workflows and increase overall productivity. Enchanced security. Employee monitoring systems can also help to protect sensitive company information and prevent unauthorized access to critical systems. By tracking employee activity, small business owners can quickly identify and address potential security threats.t Improved employee accountability. Employee monitoring systems can also help to improve employee accountability by providing a clear record of their activities. This can help to reduce the likelihood of time theft and ensure that employees are working efficiently during their scheduled hours. Better time management. By tracking employee activity, small business owners can better understand how their employees are spending their time. This can help to identify areas where employees may be struggling and provide opportunities for additional training or support. Reduced costs. Employee monitoring systems can also help small businesses reduce costs by identifying inefficiencies and streamlining workflows. This can help to reduce the need for overtime and minimize the risk of costly mistakes. Cons of Employee Monitoring Systems Privacy concerns. One of the biggest concerns with employee monitoring systems is their potential to invade employee privacy. Small business owners must be careful to balance their need for information with their employees’ right to privacy. Employee morale. Employee monitoring systems can also have a negative impact on employee morale. If employees feel that they are being constantly monitored, it can lead to feelings of distrust and resentment. Legal considerations. Small business owners must also be aware of the legal implications of employee monitoring. Depending on the jurisdiction, there may be specific laws and regulations that govern the use of these systems. Technical issues. Employee monitoring systems can also be subject to technical issues, such as software glitches and data breaches. Small business owners must ensure that their systems are secure and that their data is protected. Summing It All Up Employee monitoring systems can provide small business owners with valuable insights into their workforce and help to improve productivity, security, and accountability. However, there are also potential drawbacks to consider, including privacy concerns, employee morale, legal considerations, and technical issues. Ultimately, small business owners must carefully weigh the pros and cons of employee monitoring systems and make an informed decision based on their specific needs and circumstances. Want to Accomplish More? Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while you spend more time with your family doing all the things you started your business to do? We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test. You can call us for your free appointment at 602-435-5474, or, if you prefer, send us an email. You can also visit us at Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Read More »

My Small Business Manager didn’t Manage the Business Well and Now it’s a Total Mess…What Do I Do?

Some business owners run their company for many years, only to discover that they can’t do everything on their own. Once this inevitable realization materializes, most start to hire others to help them with various aspects of the business. Some even aspire to be largely absentee owners, leaving the day-to-day operations to a professional manager. So, they train someone up, giving them the responsibility of managing the company and then take a more offhand role, sometimes into a completely new venture or, to focus on one particular area. Typically, this goes fairly well, especially when said manager has been well trained. However, it sometimes ends in utter disaster and the manager winds up making a mess of everything. So, what do you do if you’re stuck in the latter nightmare scenario? What Good Managers bring to Small Businesses Before we get into how to fix a bad situation, let’s first look at why business owners hire managers in the first place. Usually, managers are brought on to handle all of the day-to-day activity. This allows the owner to put his or her efforts into expanding the business and even exploring new opportunities. A good manager will bring a nice return on investment, easily paying his or her salary, all while adding to the company’s bottom line. Bad management can impact employees and a company’s overall operations. Incompetent managers exist, and they can have challenges relating to staff members and keeping them motivated. In addition, substandard supervisors may not be able to balance budgets, increase revenues or capably perform other crucial tasks. —Houston Chronicle Small Business A good manager can really be an invaluable asset, being able to oversee employees, carry out projects, order materials and inventory, assign employees to various tasks and projects, and a whole lot more. In the end, the manager is also responsible for the public face of the company, particularly when the owners aren’t on site. Of course, there’s a great deal of trust involved here and unfortunately, that trust is sometimes betrayed. How Business Owners can Fix Mismanaged Companies If your small business has been mismanaged by an incompetent or uncaring manager, you’ve got your work cut out for you. The amount of damage he or she may have done may not be immediately apparent and will materialize over time. But, you can’t just wait to find out, you’ve got to leap into action immediately and do the following after letting him or her go: Talk to the employees. The very first thing you want to do is get a sense of the employees’ perspectives. You’re likely to learn a lot and some of it may take you completely by surprise. But, you’ll probably also get a kind of consensus and that will help you to know precisely what’s most important and how to prioritize what to fix first. Speak with vendors. This may sound a little odd but it’s probably worthwhile. Since vendors interact with the managers routinely, they will have different stories to tell and just like the employees, will probably give you some type of consensus. At the very least, you’ll find out how your former manager interacted with the vendors and if he or she had good or bad business relationships. Consult your customers. If you haven’t really heard any complaints from customers, this would be highly unusual. Although, your former manager may have been great in providing excellent customer service, while still mismanaging the business’ finances and/or mismanaging the team members. Regardless, getting your customers’ input is very important because it will let you know the reputation of your company. Lastly, you’ll have to go through the slow and meticulous process of piecing the operation back together. This might include having to make other personnel changes, establishing new relationships with different vendors, and possibly, having to repair customer relationships. Fortunately, a good business consultant can walk you through this very difficult process step by step. Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »