Tired of New Employees Abruptly Quitting? Here’s a Novel Solution for Recouping Your Training Costs

One of the most costly and infuriating aspects of running a business is training new employees only to have them up and abruptly quit. It takes a lot of time, effort, and extra expense to onboard new hires and get them familiar with practices and procedures. When they depart shortly after their training, it means having to fill that position all over again. Since this is such a huge hassle and a costly one at that, some companies are actually billing employees who quit. The strategy is to ensure new employees don’t receive critical industry training only to leave and use their new skills at a competitor paying higher wages and/or offering more enticing benefits packages.

Companies Recovering Employee Training Costs through TRAPs

Healthcare, retail, trucking, beauty, and more companies are adopting a new approach in order to reduce their workforce losses. Known as Training Repayment Agreement Provisions or TRAPs, these clauses are included in employee contracts. Nearly 10% of all American companies are now using these provisions, according to a recent report by Reuters News.
When a valued employee quits, the loss can have a detrimental effect on the person’s team and department and maybe even on the entire company. Not only can an unexpected departure lead to lost revenue, but it also could lower the morale and productivity of remaining employees. —Society for Human Resource Management
Other industries may follow this emerging trend if it proves successful and legal. There are already federal and state government agencies looking into the practice, and it appears to be legitimate. If it continues to grow in popularity, it should be not only a big benefit to businesses but to employees as well, as both parties will know precisely what’s expected of them and how to proceed accordingly.

How to Use Employee Training Repayment Agreement Provisions

Because this is somewhat new, it’s very important to take thoughtful, measured steps in order to implement such a practice. Here are some suggestions for how to use an employee training repayment agreement provision in your business:
  • Consult a labor law attorney. The very first thing you should do is to speak with a lawyer who specializes in labor law in your state. Even if a future employee willingly signs such an agreement, there may be something on the books that does not allow you to enforce such a provision. So, be crystal clear it is legal and actionable in your state.
  • Speak with your human resources department. Obviously if you are able to include an employee training repayment agreement provision in your hiring contracts, you’ll need to get the right people in your organization on board and in the know. You can help to develop a new section in your training process that discloses and advises potential hires and new team member about this provision.
  • Make sure new hires are made fully aware of the provision. When you’re recruiting someone new to your organization, be sure this is made abundantly clear before you proceed with follow-up interviews and probably before the very first, initial interview. Any job candidate should be made aware of this provision well before you get deep into the hiring process.
  • Include a mechanism to recoup new employee training costs. Of course, you’ll need a way to actually recoup those training costs. So, if you offer a sign-on bonus, that may be one way to recapture the expense. Here again, you’ll need to consult an experienced, licensed labor law attorney in your state to establish a recuperation mechanism for the provision.
What else would you suggest business owners do to deal with new hires who quit shortly after being brought on? Please share your thoughts and experiences so others can benefit from your input! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

Farewell illustration

How to Deal with Employee Ghosting

Employee ghosting is a scary situation. It’s spooky because it’s so awkward and strange. If you haven’t heard about employee ghosting, you’re certainly not alone. Although, it’s a trend which appears like it’s on the rise. Basically, this is a workplace phenomenon born from personal relationships in this day and age or IRL. (That’s In Real Life — BTW or By the Way.) And, it’s possible you might just face this particular scenario. So, it’s best to err on the side of caution and take proactive measures to limit the fallout. Employee Ghosting Explained Before we get to how to deal with it, let’s first explain employee ghosting. It’s simply when an established team member, a new employee, or a fresh hire doesn’t show up, without notice or any forewarning. It’s actually a practice that’s been present in the dating world for quite some time. One person simply up and disappears, without any indication. Poof. All communications are cut off, all of a sudden. In fields ranging from food service to finance, recruiters and hiring managers say a tightening job market and a sustained labor shortage have contributed to a surge in professionals abruptly cutting off contact and turning silent–the type of behavior more often associated with online dating than office life. —Inc.com This has found its way into the professional workplace. And, it raises a number of concerns. Of course, the first is being a person short. Then, there’s the matter of reconciling or trying to make sense of a nonsensical move. Moreover, it makes your team members wonder just what the ghost knows they don’t yet know themselves. In other words, just what reason could cause a person to up and disappear? How to Deal with Employee Ghosting Now, let’s get to dealing with employee ghosting. After all, if it does happen, you certainly don’t want to be caught totally off guard. Here are some helpful suggestions for how to deal with employee ghosting: Create a backup plan. At some point, you’re going to deal with a sudden change that comes out of nowhere. So, it’s best to have a plan in-place. Get with one or more team members and create a backup plan that’s reasonable and actionable so it can be implemented, if necessary. Be prepared to reward. Of course, if someone doesn’t show up, someone else will have to shoulder the load. Which means they’ll have to work more. Make it worthwhile by rewarding them appropriately. A gift card, an extra paid day off, or a bigger bonus. Create a high trust culture. When employees call in sick or they are late, handle this professionally and according to your policy with consistency, but don’t make a mountain out of a mole hill. The same is true with employee mistakes. Be careful to react negatively or to belittle an employee who has made an honest mistake because these negative acts cause employees to not disclose the truth and hide their mistakes … even not showing up for work for fear of retribution. A safe and healthy work environment with open communication helps to foster high trust in the work place. Formulate a way forward. You can’t just rely on a temporary stop-gap solution because it isn’t tenable. You’ll need to formulate a plan for how to transition and proceed in a way that isn’t too interruptive. Stay calm and breathe deep. It’s an unfortunate situation and an uncomfortable one, just like when you have to tell your employees you’ve fired someone. But, you can make it past the setback. Start by remaining calm. Take a deep breath and handle it coolly. Have you experienced this strange trend? How do you deal with it? Or, what other suggestions do you have? Please share your thoughts by commenting! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »
Blooming cactus landscape

Why High-Performing Landscape Companies Grow with Waters

A strategic framework for consistent turnarounds, stronger profitability, and lasting business value In commercial landscaping, ambition is rarely the thing missing. Most of the companies we meet have deep customer relationships, capable crews, and a real commitment to quality. They got to where they are through persistence and hard-earned expertise. But as these businesses grow, that same growth starts exposing cracks in how the business actually operates. Scale creates complexity. The processes that worked fine at $5 million in revenue start to buckle at $15 million. A leadership structure built for one branch gets stretched thin across three or four. Informal communication that used to be fine now causes real friction. Labor costs start outpacing revenue. Margins get harder to predict. And at some point, the owner realizes every new contract is adding more weight on their shoulders instead of more freedom. Chasing more volume at that stage doesn’t fix anything. What the business actually needs is better design. Waters Business Consulting Group partners with commercial landscape leaders to find what’s actually limiting their performance, then build the systems, leadership, and financial visibility it takes to turn a reactive company into one that can scale on purpose. We’re not just trying to make the company bigger. We’re trying to build something more resilient, more profitable, and valuable enough that it doesn’t fall apart the moment the owner steps away. That’s the kind of institutional strength that brings landscape companies to Waters in the first place. The WBCG framework: building stability from the inside out Real improvement never comes from one initiative bolted onto an otherwise unchanged business. An aggressive sales push can’t fix operations that are already broken. A beautiful financial report means nothing if no manager is actually held to it. Hiring more people just adds more complexity if nobody’s roles are clearly defined. Lasting change has to touch every part of the business at once. Our framework works across six areas that all reinforce each other: diagnosing the business honestly, building financial visibility, tightening operational discipline, creating real leadership accountability, aligning growth with profitability, and building lasting enterprise value. Strengthen these together, and you get a business that performs the same way twice, reliably, instead of getting lucky once. 1. Diagnose before you prescribe anything Every struggling business shows the same symptoms: margins eroding, turnover climbing, cash getting tight, an owner who can’t get out of daily emergencies long enough to lead. Treating any one of those symptoms on its own almost never fixes the underlying problem. A profit problem is often really a pricing problem, or a production-control problem, or the wrong mix of customers. What looks like a hiring crisis is often just unclear management roles wearing a different costume. We start by taking a genuinely close look at the economics and the org structure to find where performance is actually leaking out, across financial performance, gross margins by service and customer, how accurate the estimating really is, labor efficiency, leadership capacity, the sales pipeline, and how dependent the business is on the owner. The point isn’t to produce a thick report. It’s clarity, so leadership can stop reacting to whatever’s on fire today and start fixing what’s actually broken underneath. 2. Build financial visibility you can actually act on A financial report tells you where the business has been. It doesn’t tell you where it’s headed, and by the time it lands on your desk, the month it describes is already over. The companies that perform best treat their financials as a steering wheel, not a rearview mirror. They connect what happened at month-end back to the decisions made on a job site that week, which means they catch a bad trend while it’s still small instead of after it’s compounded for two quarters. We help teams build visibility into the numbers that actually move performance: gross margin by service line, crew productivity, equipment utilization, overhead trends, pipeline quality, and cash flow. Once an owner understands the true economics of the business, they stop managing crisis to crisis and start leading. 3. Build systems, not heroics Landscaping is genuinely complicated to run well. Labor, equipment, schedules, and materials all have to line up, usually while the weather refuses to cooperate and customers expect more every year. The companies that consistently perform don’t lean on a handful of superstar employees to hold the whole operation together. They build systems: disciplined pricing and estimating, real production planning, tight equipment and purchasing controls, consistent quality checks, and reporting that actually gets used. Strong systems cut down on the variation between one crew’s work and another’s, and they let a company grow its revenue without a matching spike in stress. 4. Invest in leadership and real accountability A business can’t outgrow the capacity of its leaders. A lot of owners hit a ceiling simply because they’re still the one making every operational, financial, and personnel decision, no matter how big the company gets. We help build real leadership depth by clarifying roles and actually handing off authority, not just responsibility. Every manager should know exactly which results are theirs, how success gets measured, when to escalate a problem, and how much authority they actually have to make a call. When managers are genuinely empowered and genuinely accountable, the owner finally gets time back for strategy instead of spending every day putting out fires that shouldn’t have reached their desk in the first place. 5. Chase profit, not just activity Growth only matters if it produces profit. Too many landscape companies chase revenue that ends up costing more in cash and leadership time than it’s worth. We help teams evaluate opportunities on strategic fit and long-term value, not just top-line size, which usually means putting resources behind the highest-margin customer segments, contracts that fit inside actual operational capacity, and markets that support healthy cash flow rather than draining it. Real business health takes the discipline to turn down the wrong work so there’s room to do the right work

Read More »
Farewell illustration

How to Tell Your Employees You’ve Fired Someone

How do you tell your employees you’ve fired someone? The topic makes most entrepreneurs very uncomfortable. But, there are certain situations which call for this type of action. Previously, we’ve talked about how to fire someone. However, what happens thereafter? It’s not like people won’t notice he or she is gone. So, how do you deal with remaining employees in a way that moves your company forward? The truth is, there is no such thing as a perfect transition. However, there are ways to make it go smoother. Signs it’s Time to Terminate an Employee Before you do take the final step of termination, you should be totally sure it’s the only recourse. For instance, a team member who consistently drags down productivity (and, won’t take steps to correct their behavior). Or, an employee who drains morale or constantly stirs-up drama are also toxic — don’t let your organization suffer unnecessarily. Also, an employee who is apathetic doesn’t care about their work product or customers isn’t worth keeping around. One thing we know about human nature is that when there’s a mystery, people will solve it themselves: They make up the ending, and it’s almost always worse than reality. And that’s the problem–if you don’t tell people why, they’ll make up why. And the wrong why is almost always destructive. Information vacuums fill with rumors, and rumors lead to anxiety. —Inc.com Then, there’s the serial rule violator. Someone who just refuses to play by the rules. It’s time to stop banging your head against the wall and do your business a favor. These situations are typically the most disruptive and harmful to a company. How to Tell Your Employees You’ve Fired Someone Now, if it’s time to let a team member go, you’ll have to navigate your employees through a weird experience. Here are some helpful suggestions for how to tell your employees you have fired someone: Make a simple announcement. Convene a meeting or send out a memo. Simply state, “Bob no longer works here. Our transition steps are 1, 2, and 3. If you have any questions, please see Sue.” That’s it. Straightforward and to the point. Don’t share details or communicate negatively. After terminating an employee, the human temptation is to share your reasons for the termination in order to rationalize your decision. And, sometimes this leads to making negative comments about the terminated employee. Do not fall into this trap! Be a leader. Otherwise, any other communication is destructive and deteriorates your culture and you lose respect with your existing employees. Don’t tolerate rumors. Rumors are inevitable in these situations. Keep your ears open and if you hear one, nip it in the bud. Be polite but direct and firm. Do not let rumors become a distraction. Give people a chance to step-up. Since there’s an open position, you can ask who is willing to step-in and fill the void. This is a great chance to see which team members are the most eager and loyal. Seize the opportunity. This is likewise an opportunity to reset the company narrative. You might want to take it in a different direction or get back to fundamentals. Whatever change you’d most like to make, now is a prime opportunity. How do you tell your staff you’ve let someone go? What other suggestions do you have for these situations? Please share your thoughts by commenting! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »

Imagine Selling Your Business…

How Would Your Life Change?

You didn’t start your business just to stay busy—you built it to create freedom, security, and options for yourself and your family. Selling your business can be life-changing, but the real question is whether you’re intentionally building toward that outcome or simply leaving it to chance.

Sign up below for a free consultative session to learn what your business could be worth today and in the future! 

Thank you for your interest in learning what your business is worth. We will be in touch shortly.