Stop Chasing Rock Stars and Learn Why “Average” Hires Are the Real Secret Weapon for Building a Thriving Business

“A-players hire A-players; B-players hire C-players.” This quote is often attributed to Steve Jobs, and whether he coined the phrase or not misses its point. The sentiment is obviously about a fundamental strategy to succeed in business. So, many entrepreneurs subscribe to this belief, thinking it’s practically infallible. However, that’s simply not the case because plenty of business owners have discovered that chasing top talent is the proverbial carrot on a stick. Instead, they adopt an alternative approach and seek out “average” individuals instead. Here’s why.

The Toxic Obsession with A-Players and Why Reliability Beats Credentials Every Time

Business owners love to brag about landing “top talent.” They chase Ivy League degrees, flashy LinkedIn profiles, and candidates with “elite” pedigrees like they’re drafting the next Stephen Curry or Tom Brady. They post sky-high salary ranges, offer unlimited PTO, and bend over backward in interviews just to get a résumé with the right keywords.

Then the superstar shows up, demands a corner office and a six-figure signing bonus, works 60-hour weeks for three months…and ghosts you for a better offer from a competitor. Sound familiar?

It’s time to admit the truth. The truth being, the obsession with “A-players” is quietly destroying more businesses than it builds. The smartest move most owners can make right now is to stop hunting unicorns and start deliberately recruiting solid, average candidates who actually show up, grind hard, and stick around. Here’s why “average” is the new competitive advantage.

1. Top Talent Treats Your Company Like a Stepping Stone

High-credential candidates are often professional nomads. They’ve been told since kindergarten that they’re special, so they expect rapid promotions, constant praise, and a red-carpet career path. When the shine wears off—or when another recruiter dangles a 20% raise—they’re gone.

Average candidates? They’re usually thrilled to be a part of a stable, well-run company that values them. They aren’t constantly scanning LinkedIn for their next move because they know the grass isn’t always greener. They stay longer, learn your systems more deeply, and become institutional memory instead of expensive transients. Lower turnover isn’t just cheaper; it’s the difference between a cohesive team and a revolving door that kills momentum.

2. Work Ethic Beats Credentials Every Single Day

A 4.0 GPA and a prestigious internship don’t clock in at 7 a.m. or stay late to fix a broken process. They don’t volunteer to train the new kid or notice the small details that save your company thousands.

“Average” candidates often do—because they’ve had to hustle their whole lives without a safety net. They solve problems with grit and street smarts rather than quoting business school frameworks. They don’t wait for perfect data or the perfect title; they roll up their sleeves and figure it out. That practical resourcefulness consistently outperforms theoretical brilliance in the messy reality of running a business.

3. Loyalty Is the Ultimate Force Multiplier

Loyalty compounds. An average employee who feels respected will defend your brand in the community, refer their friends, and protect your culture from toxic attitudes. They become the quiet backbone that keeps everything running when the market gets tough.

The superstar? They’re loyal to their own personal brand first. When the economy tightens, or a shiny new opportunity appears, loyalty is the first thing they negotiate away.

4. You Can Actually Afford to Keep Them—and Scale With Them

Hiring “top talent” forces you into a compensation arms race. You’re paying premium prices for people who may deliver average results once the honeymoon ends. Meanwhile, solid, average candidates are available at market rates, often with far less ego and far more hunger to prove themselves.

That cost savings isn’t pocket change—it’s money you can reinvest in training, tools, or bonuses that actually motivate the team you already have. You build depth instead of flash. You create a culture where people grow with the company rather than use it as a launchpad.

5. Real Problem-Solving Comes From People Who’ve Had to Solve Problems

Elite credentials often produce people who are great at looking smart in meetings but freeze when the server crashes right before the work’s done or a key client throws a curveball. Average hires have spent their careers making things work with limited resources. They improvise. They test. They ship.

That scrappy, can-do mindset scales businesses far more reliably than another polished résumé.

How to Start Hiring “Average” on Purpose

Stop writing job posts that scream “only superhumans need apply.” Instead, emphasize reliability, attitude, and cultural fit. Ask interview questions like:
  • “Tell me about a time you had to fix something nobody else wanted to touch.”
  • “What does showing up look like to you when things get hard?”
  • “Describe a process you improved even though it wasn’t your job.”
Look for candidates who light up talking about teamwork, ownership, and long-term growth rather than their last big title or salary jump.

You don’t need to hire underperformers. You need to hire normal, capable people who are hungry to do good work for a company that treats them right. The quiet majority of the workforce is full of them—people who never made the highlight reel but will quietly carry your business to the next level.

The rock-star chase is exhausting, expensive, and mostly theater. The real winners in business aren’t the ones with the most impressive org chart. They’re the ones who built a team of loyal, hardworking, average people who actually stay, solve problems, and get the job done—day after day, year after year.

So, stop recruiting for flash. Start recruiting for substance. Your bottom line will thank you.

Want to Accomplish More?

Do you want your company to grow faster and earn more while spending more time with your family doing everything you started your business to do?

We can make that dream a reality. Give us 30 minutes, and we will show you how to get your life back. Skeptical? Good! Put us to the test.

You can call us for your free appointment at 480-636-1720, or, if you prefer, Waters Business Consulting Group to learn more about us and the services we offer.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest

Related Posts

Now Might be an Opportune Time to Expand Your Business — Here’s Why

Any experienced financial advisor will tell his or her clients to buy when the market experiences a downturn. “Everything is on sale,” is the old adage, and for good reason. If an investor rides the roller coaster, he or she will make up any “paper losses” only to add real gains later on. Business owners know this but are often too afraid to take the risk. Then, later regret not seizing the opportunity. Why Economic Downturns Create Opportunity Most economic downturns hurt a variety of industries. By the same token, that creates opportunities for those unaffected, and even those who are. Here’s an example. A construction business will probably suffer during an economic downturn as more people will attempt to go the DIY route. But, once the homeowner gets in over his or her head, they’ll need a professional. Entrepreneurs are often reluctant to spend money to make acquisitions, expand capacity or open new markets during an economic downturn. However, downturns can be an ideal time to invest in your business. Every recession creates opportunities for innovative entrepreneurs. And inaction doesn’t mean safety in uncertain times. Rather than simply hope things will get better, you should act to improve your operations and position yourself for growth when the economy recovers. —Business Development Bank of Canada The contractor who continues to aggressively market their services will likely be the one to benefit. Because their competition will likely cut back on advertising and maybe even layoff crew, the construction firm that remains publicly out front will reap the rewards of strategic marketing. Meanwhile, those who pulled back will only continue to shrink. 3 Reasons Now is the Time to Expand Your Business Even though just about everyone knows that a bear market presents opportunity, a good percentage will err on the side of caution, rather than taking a risk. So, it’s important to know the rewards that favor those who seize the opportunity. Here are three reasons now the time to expand your business: Commercial real estate is slow. Because of the nature of this economic downturn, commercial real estate is in a slump. That means you can use the circumstances to your advantage and negotiate a favorable deal. With a little bit of swagger and confidence, and a keen eye on opportunity, it’s possible to negotiate aggressively and score a real win. Remote work costs less than on-site. It’s no secret that remote workers cost substantially less than on-site employees. This is a great way to expand your workforce while getting a substantial discount and expand your business as a result. This also allows you to streamline your processes to get more productivity without paying more for it. There’s a larger pool of talent available. When the economy slides, many talented individuals become unemployed. That means, if you’re discerning enough, you can put their advanced skill sets to work for your business. What’s more, motivated and successful individuals will most likely come to you, while lackluster individuals and people who aren’t ambitious won’t. What other suggestions do you have for expanding a business? Please share your thoughts and experiences by commenting and giving others some ideas! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »

I Want to Create a New Position for My Small Business – So How Do I Go about It?

Entrepreneurs wear many, many hats. It is not at all unusual for a small business owner to perform several different roles. But, this Jack of all trades, master of none can’t go on in perpetuity. The longer it lasts, the less chance there is that the business can scale up. In order to grow a company, it’s necessary to have help and many business owners reach a point where it is unavoidable. So, they make a few hires but still continue to perform various functions until they realize that a new position will free them up to pursue their main goals. Hiring should Equal Growth It’s very common for small business owners to be nervous about their first hires. However, they eventually get past this and the team settles into a comfortable routine. This can easily result in a false sense of security and it’s not at all unusual for the owner to slip right back into or continue bad habits. If a heavy workload causes your employees to feel overwhelmed and frustrated, it may be time to add new positions to your department. Hiring an additional staff member or two can help you split tasks between employees more equitably and give employees the time they need to devote to their work. —Houston Chronicle Sure, someone has to perform those functions and the owner typically feels it is his or her responsibility. But, there comes a time when it’s clear that handing off at least some of those tasks to someone else would be very beneficial. What generally holds a business owner back is not having a clearly defined position, as they did with previous hires. Fortunately, there are some steps you can take to create a new employee position. How to Create a New Employee Position for a Small Business When it becomes obvious that you’re taking on too much, be it administrative tasks or something else, it’s time to seriously consider hiring someone to do that work for you. Here are some steps you can take in order to create a new employee position: Estimate its ROI. Before you start posting job openings, take some time to work out the most likely return on investment. Ask yourself if one or more of your current employees can assume these responsibilities. If not, then it is more likely you need to create a brand new position. Just work out a realistic scenario on how much this will add to expenses and what size return of investment you’ll get for this potential hire. Determine if it’s part or full time. Next, you’ll need to determine whether this is a part-time or full-time position. Go over your schedule and create a ballpark figure of how much time you spend on these tasks. This will give you a pretty good idea of the number of hours you’ll give over to a new employee. Plus, it will tell you how much time you gain back doing more important things. Compile a list of applicable skills. Last but certainly not least, you’ll need to create a list of applicable skills that a new employee would need to possess. This will also tell you if these responsibilities are truly interrelated or if they are a mixed bag. What’s more, it will point you in a more specific direction and help you to hone in on the right personality. What other suggestions do you have for an entrepreneur who is considering creating a new team member role? Please share your experiences and thoughts so others can benefit from your input! Interested in learning more about business? Then just visit Waters Business Consulting Group.

Read More »